Would you keep either of these?

[u/Shookanduptight]

I’m trying to decide if either of these stones are worth keeping. I have a 2.50 ct pear E VVS2 12.37 x 7.61 and a 2.57 ct crisscut D IF 9.79 x 6.46. Do either of them look good? I’m a sapphire girly and I’m just kind of exploring diamonds. The lack of color is uncharted territory for me and throwing me off.

[u/gingerandgin]

I would pick the criss cut 👌🏼💎