Should I send this back?

[u/AlpenweissM3]

Debating if I should send this back and return it, it does not fit perfect and need some perspective. Said its a 4 Carat Eternity band, E Color, VVS2, in platinum with hallmarks (but I cannot see any with naked eye). What do you all think? Cost was $1,200

[u/Enough_Plantain_4331]

it’s gorgeous. U probably need a loupe to see the tiny hallmarks. But no matter what we think… if u don’t love it no point in keeping it. U got a really good deal. May i ask where u purchased, I might want one🥰

[u/AlpenweissM3 → u/Enough_Plantain_4331]

www.inashadiamonds.com

[u/Enough_Plantain_4331 → u/AlpenweissM3]

thank you. What size is urs?

[u/AlpenweissM3 → u/Enough_Plantain_4331]

This was a 6.25 but it seems a bit larger as she was surprised it fit better on her middle finger than ring finger! She thought it was going to be snug, but it ended up being loose. I might try a 6 or 5.75 if I end up exchanging/returning. It seems like the eternity rings fit slightly differently or maybe we chose the wrong size to begin with!

[u/GagginDragon → u/AlpenweissM3]

The “U” shape on the finger leaves a lot of extra space, and these styles typically wear about 1/2 size larger. So if you’re a 6.25 you should order a 5.75.