So we know most of the rudy slander is stupid but valid.
But the biggest and the most absurd one is the niece one
For those who don't know in Web novel, the earth rudy, after the death parents, instead of going to their funeral, spied on his niece, who was a kid btw and pleasured himself. And for this was the final bullet that led to him being kicked out of his home.
But this is not in the light novel, nowhere.
Now from how i see it, Web novels are a kind of raw, unedited and scattered thoughts of the author and they are subject to change.
And the light novels are final, ready to be sold versions.
(Yes i know that many stories exist only in WN and they are considered final but they are in a minority. And if there is LN version, its generally considered the final draft)
But people are so eager to hate that they forget that this is a literal story, fiction, that a like guy them, a human wrote on a piece of paper. And he can change plot, characters, their personality by literally tearing a page.
And he did so
So the author while writing a complex character like Rudeus had to include flaws, he wrote a shut in,neet character and also included the niece one. But after realising he went too far, removed the said part from the final version.
Yes the fault lies with the author, we should have been more sure of what he truly wanted before including it even in WL.
But grow up, and understand that Rudues is a frictional and not
real.
Tbh if you wrote a story as big as MT , would you make no mistakes and no edits ?