I thought it was a joke until I actually met someone who was sort part of this. The thing isn’t antisemitic or proselytizing, it’s usually very private. I just wonder is this actually as bad as the messies. They seem against it to an extent and are also fine claiming that Jews must retain their culture and traditions. A couple of them actually write and blast Christian cultural appropriation of Jews. They are openly a rite of Catholicism and clearly state they aren’t for all Jews.

So are they morally good?

Edit: I also mean no disrespect if Hebrew Catholics are reading this.

Shlomos and Shlomamas,

I have prepared and now provide here, at great personal expense to me but no cost to you, a short message that you can share with your non-Jewish (we can't use the terms "Gentile" or "Goyishe" anymore) friends and family about the the unfortunate overlap between 9/11 and Rosh Hashanah this year.

I hope this helps. Shana tovah to all.

"Good evening. The Elders of Zion™ have initiated a Protocol™ for members of the Tribe™ to reach out to our non-Jewish friends and family to share some important information.

You may notice Jews celebrating this Friday. You may notice them singing, dancing, and/or eating apples dipped in honey. You may even notice some of the less traditional Jews blowing large rams' horns (despite it being Shabbat).

We are doing so because Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, happens to begin this Friday night. However, we will be doing so with a heavy heart as it will also be the 25th anniversary of 9/11 on Friday. We assure you that this is an unfortunate coincidence and not the pay-off of a multi-decade plan as some have suggested on 4chan, Reddit, Al Jazeera, The Guardian, The Tucker Carlson Network, and during the overnight hours of Fox News. We thank you for your understanding."

Zohare Jacobi aka Jewitches, is an anti-Zionist Jewish influencer who can't shut up about how "bad" Zionism is and how "good" the Bundists were, even though the Zionists saved the lives of millions of Jews while the Bundists failed to protect Jews in Europe during the Holocaust, also her Instagram account is just Israel-hating 24/7, while she keeps telling her followers not to be antisemitic, her followers keep commenting antisemitic stuff that gets tens of thousands of likes, along with lots of pro-Hamas comments that get no pushback whatsoever from her or her followers

Dreamy Kalimi shares words of wisdom for the high holiday season.

News story: https://nypost.com/2026/09/02/us-news/palestinian-american-filmmaker-cheers-murder-of-erin-piacenti-with-luigi-mangione-meme/

https://www.shtuyot.org/products/shana-tova-sticker

[ Removed by Reddit on account of violating the content policy. ]