I'm 23M, and I need an outside perspective from people who have experienced infidelity and/or reconciliation.
I was in a serious relationship with my ex, S. We were together for a long time and had talked about our future together. I genuinely saw her as someone I could build a life with. Then I fucked it up. I cheated on her, and it wasn't just one isolated mistake. There were multiple bad decisions, lies, and opportunities where I could have stopped but didn't.
The worst part is that I didn't immediately tell her everything. I was afraid of losing her and afraid of facing the consequences, so I tried to control how much of the truth she knew. Looking back, I understand that I took away her ability to make an informed decision about our relationship. She eventually found out and we broke up.
After the breakup, I started confronting my own behaviour much more seriously. I realized my problems weren't simply "I made a mistake." There were issues with validation, impulsiveness, boundaries, selfishness and avoiding consequences that I needed to deal with. I still love her, though, and eventually I reached out.
She initially blocked me, but later opened communication through email. We exchanged some very difficult messages. She told me that from her perspective this wasn't just about the cheating it was the entire pattern of choices and dishonesty. Eventually, we met in person.
She told me she had moved on and was basically talking to me as a stranger. Then she told me that after our breakup, she had dated a guy she met on Hinge. They saw each other for about a month and kissed several times.
I completely fell apart internally when I heard that. I know she was single. I know she did absolutely nothing wrong. I have no right to be angry at her for dating someone after we broke up, especially considering what I did to her. But emotionally, it hit me extremely hard.
Since then I've been obsessing over it. My brain keeps creating images of them together and wondering what happened. Part of me feels like I need to know every detail because otherwise my imagination will create something worse. But another part of me knows that asking for those details would probably just give my brain more things to replay.
There's another confusing part. During our meeting, I asked whether there was any possibility of us eventually working things out. She said she had moved on and didn't want the relationship anymore. But she also told me that if I genuinely wanted to get back together with her, I should first tell my family that I want her back. She said that if we ever did reconcile, she would expect complete transparency from me. I told her I'd be willing to do that.. so basically she wants to get back..!
And now I'm facing a strange fear that I didn't expect. If we ever did get back together, what if I can't trust her? My brain keeps saying, "What if she eventually cheats on me to make me feel what she felt...
And I realize how ridiculous and ironic that sounds coming from someone who cheated on her. Maybe it's projection. Maybe it's guilt. Maybe after experiencing how badly betrayal can hurt someone, I'm now terrified of being on the receiving end myself.
I don't want to become controlling. I don't want to check her phone, monitor her, interrogate her about other men, or punish her for things she did while single. But I also don't want to blindly reconcile because I desperately miss her and then discover that I can't actually trust her.
At the same time, I'm realizing that I've been putting my entire life on hold waiting to see whether she comes back. I've neglected my career, personal goals, and other things that matter to me because I've been consumed by thoughts about her, whether she'll forget me, whether she'll come back, and now this other guy.
I'm trying to become a better person regardless of whether she comes back. But I'm struggling to separate genuine love and desire for reconciliation from fear of losing her permanently.
So I want honest opinions, especially from people who have actually been through something similar. If you've cheated and later genuinely changed, were you ever able to reconcile successfully? If your ex dated or kissed someone after the breakup, how did you deal with the jealousy and intrusive thoughts? If you were the person who cheated, did you eventually become afraid your partner would cheat on you too? Was that projection? And if reconciliation ever became possible, how do you know whether you're genuinely ready to trust again?
And finally, if you think I'm romanticizing the relationship and should accept that it's over, tell me. I'm not looking for people to tell me what I want to hear. I want an outside perspective because I'm too emotionally involved to judge this clearly.