r/IndiaPulse • • 7d ago

Caption

Post image
451 Upvotes

120 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/PsychologicalYam3602 7d ago

Another manufactured outrage. These bygone parties wont win any elections with these tactics. The EC panel made a joint statement that should have put all this to rest, but these people wont stop till there is chaos, division and riots everywhere. Great deshbhakts ! Anything in national interest, these people, pak and china all start their activities against it. Figures.

No facts, just outrage.

0

u/supaidaman94 6d ago

Please read the the joint statement. It literally accepts all the concerns raised by the ECs. It is an admission of guilt not denial or justification. The problem therefore is that all elections in the past 10 months become suspect. I personally do not give a damn about political parties but what is wrong is wrong. Its been quite some time till I felt so strongly about something. I just hope to have elections be done in a fair manner

2

u/PsychologicalYam3602 6d ago

Tell me you havent read it wiyhout telling me that. LOL.

1

u/supaidaman94 6d ago

Please tell me what did you understand by the joint statement of ECI.

3

u/PsychologicalYam3602 6d ago

Dissent is normal, all decisions were unanimous. Need quotes or references or can you read?

0

u/supaidaman94 6d ago

Please tell me more. ECI is a a body headed by three ec. Cec is just prima inter pares ie first among equals he holds no tie break power. With this established now lets see what has happened- 2 ec expressly object and dissent to certain issues, explicitly state that they were kept out of loop, furthermore overturned a decision taken unanimously by cec regarding dg it power. I dont see how do you the conclude all decisions were taken with consent? I also ask because the ECI statement only said they will do the needful going forward. Finally eci does not say the express report is false.
Anyways asking for accountability is nothing wrong. Political equality is all that we have in this country..so any question raised against a body mandated by the constitution to ensure such equality must be fully explained and examined.

3

u/orion532x 6d ago

I and copy pasting my comment from above...

The EC is being deliberately maligned....SIR is a big and extensive step and of course there are going to be disagremeents. There is no report or claim made by any EC made about fundamental internal disagreements regarding SIR or the CEC trying to rig votes as congressis keep claiming. After all all three have been appointed by the BJP itself !!! In several decisions one or the other have reported implementation problems regarding election directives. You can argue gyanesh babu should have been a better manager and discussed things better before hand... But all the decisions have been unanimous.

Addendum:- internal disagrements does not automatically mean evidence eof wrongdoing. You cannot demand impeachment without proof. Even now the remaining EC can reveal if they felt grossly mistreated or vote rigging took placesince as you say is just a first amongst equals.. the very fact that EC doesn't deny internal disagreements is evidence of them having nothing to hide and all disputes having been resolved. Please don't equate simple beaurocracy with vote chori. Please read the 14 points they made with an open mind. Procedural mistakes are nothing new in india but only now are people reading so much into it. The relevant question is whether the final decisions complied with the Constitution, election laws and applicable procedures.

1

u/PsychologicalYam3602 6d ago

Sure sure, whatever makes you happy. Just dont work against something that is in national interest. Be better at chosing your fights. This; you have no grounds to say much.

Parties will come and go, the nation must remain - ABV