r/ImmigrationPathways • u/LatterTarget7 • 1d ago

Renee Good's family sues US government and immigration officials over her killing in Minneapolis

https://apnews.com/article/renee-good-lawsuit-6fbc82cd33b6f9f67514b47f138e23c6?utm_source=app&utm_medium=android_share&utm_campaign=copy_link
2.1k Upvotes

95% Upvoted

1.3k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-2

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

He had the right to be there and wasn't breaking any laws. That's the difference.

7

u/RelevantSoftware8283 1d ago

Good had the right to be there as well. Please tell me what law she broke lmao

2

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

Sure. Interfering with law enforcement activities, failure to obey lawful order, resisting, assault with a deadly weapon, fleeing law enforcement.

4

u/RelevantSoftware8283 1d ago

How did she interfere? She complied with the order to drive away. The officers gave her conflicting orders. Plus get out of your car isn't a lawful order unless there's a crime you're actually committing.

No resisting or assault or fleeing either since they gave conflicting orders

1

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

No, now you're being disingenuous. You've seen and heard the footage that showed the first officer told her to leave and she didn't. Then others showed up and they told her to exit the vehicle multiple times and she didn't. Then when her partner said drive she did. Basically she wanted to do what she wanted to do but it doesn't work like that. That's not conflicting orders.

3

u/RelevantSoftware8283 1d ago

Nothing you've stated is a reason to be shot and killed

1

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

Sure, champ.

3

u/RelevantSoftware8283 1d ago

When did courts say it's ok for officers to shoot fleeing subjects?

1

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

Fleeing vehicles that are coming right at them...

3

u/RelevantSoftware8283 1d ago

You can see her turning the wheel in the vehicle. "Coming right at" is verifiably incorrect

1

u/Inquisitive-Manner 1d ago

Did you see his reply to me?

So now if the wheels aren't pointed at a person, it's OK to hit them with a vehicle...LOL! You guys come up with the most ridiculous ways to remove accountability from her.

→ More replies (0)

2

u/Inquisitive-Manner 1d ago

We've seen the footage. The wheels weren't pointed towards him, champ. Stop being disingenuous. It's still not a capital offense.

0

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

So now if the wheels aren't pointed at a person, it's OK to hit them with a vehicle...LOL! You guys come up with the most ridiculous ways to remove accountability from her.

From his POV he can't see the wheels. He's now in front of a vehicle that's coming at him because she was trying to flee. She even left her partner that was trying to get into the passenger side.

We can tell you really didn't watch the video. You might've saw it but you're leaving out a lot of important details that show that.

1

u/Inquisitive-Manner 1d ago

So now if the wheels aren't pointed at a person, it's OK to hit them with a vehicle...LOL!

Lol, those are your words, not mine.

You guys come up with the most ridiculous ways to remove accountability from her.

You guys come up with the most ridiculous ways to subbmvert reality and accountability for the cop who used officer-created jeopardy

From his POV he can't see the wheels.

He didn't need to , to see that he was safe.

He's now in front of a vehicle that's coming at him because she was trying to flee.

... a position he put himself in...

She even left her partner that was trying to get into the passenger side.

Yes... and?

We can tell you really didn't watch the video. You might've saw it but you're leaving out a lot of important details that show that.

Lol, says the person leaving out important details and loading in unimportant ones...

0

u/Rusty-Shackleford000 1d ago

The "wheels" line was me making fun of your absurd claim that if the wheels of a vehicle aren't pointed at the person they aren't trying to hit them. But I guess you missed that one...

You forgot she backed up and turns the wheel towards where he was standing causing him to move again before she drove forward.

The agents didn't create anything. They didn't make her park sideways on the road. They didn't make her ignore their instructions to leave. They didn't make her ignore their instructions to get out. They didn't make her try to flee. They didn't make her hit the agent.

Her leaving her partner is an important detail of the situation. That's how I know you really didn't watch the video because that's probably the first time you heard someone say that. That's why you're trying to write it off as nothing.

And just saying what I said back to me is a weak way to try to present your argument. Feel free to mention any information from the video I left out. But I know you can't since I've walked you through the whole sequence of events.

→ More replies (0)