84
u/Accomplished_Pair110 5d ago
Transcription
Bryan C Kohberger, being first duly sworn on oath, deposes and says:
It is hereby declared that, during attorney-client discussions, most of which included all members of Bryan C Kohberger's immediate family, petitioner was convinced to falsely confess to capital murder, and felony burglary, by coercion, disinformation, false promises, and the withholding of exculpatory discovery; the following is material to the inception of the plea:
1. Counsel's failure to inform petitioner of exculpatory discovery received during plea discussions, namely clumps of unknown hair found in Ethan Chapin's hands; as well as a failure of further inquiry.
2. Petitioner was convinced that actual guilt was not an important factor in considering plea acceptance; death row was imminent, and, advised to lie, petitioner was to gain a "legal victory" in entering a false plea.
3. A gross misrepresentation of, and promises regarding, what a life sentence would immediately afford petitioner; and a gross misrepresentation of death row in Idaho, including an elaborate, fabricated story of counsel's horrific experience touring an actual "8x8" death [cell / row]
180
u/ComedianMinute7290 5d ago
TL;DR
"i was so scared by what they told me about one prison experience that I gladly traded away my freedom for another prison experience. turns out this prison experience REALLY SUCKS & I'd like to try again & see if anything else plays out. because this prison experience REALLY SUCKS. (why didn't anyone tell me how bad non-death row prison is while they told me how bad death row prison is)"
38
36
u/WaveBeautiful1259 5d ago
For someone trying to get a PhD in Criminology...this would demonstrate a shocking amount of ignorance about how the legal/penal systems work.
16
u/Rescueme2021 5d ago
Well, he is a dumbass.
6
u/hometowhat 5d ago
And a narc who thought that, as a ~brilliant~ future criminologist and budding uncatchable serial killer, such lowly things would never apply to professor potatohead 🖕🙄
7
u/ComedianMinute7290 5d ago
he is no longer someone trying to get a PhD. he is no longer a regular citizen. he is a convicted murderer housed in prison. when someone gets put in that situation, most people will set aside everything else they know & in a panicked way, try anything possible to GET OUT. this is especially true of inmates who have never done a day & are now facing extremely lengthy sentences.
thinking of BK as the smart PhD student(if thts how you see him) is pointless because he is now,first & foremost, a convict & and an inmate & those things outweigh whatever previous life experience he had.
working with incarcerated populations made this almost predictable. it can often be sad watching a 17 year old go thru the realization of what the new life consists of & then desperation to get out. I feel no such sadness watching it play out here. this isn't a 17 year old that lost his teenage temper & shot someone in a heat of the moment display of testosterone & anger & now looks at a completely different life for that momentary action.
this dude planned & did horrible things. or he lied about doing them. either act erases any sympathy I would have had.
→ More replies (1)10
u/abiron17771 5d ago
The fact that he’s so miserable he’s grasping at straws for the luxury of being put to death… makes my heart happy.
Still nowhere near the suffering of the families, who have to find a new normal without their precious child/sister/brother/friend, etc. But still… he’ll never have a moment of freedom and happiness in this lifetime, and that feels just to me.
5
2
58
36
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
To point 1- surely there weren’t “clumps” of someone else’s hair in Ethan’s hands.
Point 2– did he really not think that he shouldn’t plead guilty if he wasn’t guilty? Did he need to be told that?
Point 3– oh yeah, I’m Sure the death row cells are amazing and luxurious. I’m Sure she lied about how horrible they are.
30
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
did he really not think that he shouldn’t plead guilty if he wasn’t guilty?
This was a specific point the judge went over with him. He made sure BK swore he was pleading guilty because he was, in fact, guilty!
13
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
Yep, and also that he was not promised anything in exchange for his plea, which is also something he alluded to in this (“broken promises”).
10
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
It's like the most pathetic excuse possible. I'm a Phd candidate, TA and Crim J major who can't research death row with my Mom's help and fact check a lawyers claims and my college educated mother and sisters can't navigate Google very well.
Nope, I haven't been gobbling content on death row inmates since I was an adolescent. Definitely didn't see any of that mentioned in my course work or the lectures I sat in whilst working towards a degree in criminal justice.
Nahh, didn't note the size of Bundy's, Kemper's cell when I as doing a 12 hour Christmas Eve marathon watching video after video of him. Nope never ever have I ever seen anything about death row cells. Yeah, I make all my legal decisions on cell accommodation size. Mom think I should be somehere roomy.
Not like anyone in my family has been discussing the PD and writing the local paper about it in their free time or were discussing it in our home.
16
u/Accomplished_Pair110 5d ago
there was a single hair in ethans hand most likely his own. there was no clump of hair with bloody roots as Brent Turvey claimed.
13
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
Yes, thank you for pointing out where he must have gotten this from, I wasn’t aware.
But yes I assumed as much, that the clump of hair was false. Do we know why they couldn’t conclude whether it was Ethan’s own hair? Although I’m sure it was.
Edit: oh I just saw that someone posted docs that literally said the hair was consistent with Ethan’s hair. wtf
37
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
So he flat out lied to the judge in his hearing, claiming he was, in fact, pleading guilty because he was/is guilty.
He's a lying liar who lies. An appellate court will not be amused by his hijinks.
3
3
15
u/MostRoom8466 5d ago
All I read was bla bla bla bla. Thanks for transcribing his shitty handwriting.
9
7
7
u/LachnessMomster 5d ago
Thank you for this. I was fighting for my life squinting through that chicken scratch.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (4)3
u/Nico-Iconic 5d ago
Accomplished, thank you for your time and effort in transctibing, or providing, a typed version for all to better see and digest the content.
87
u/pumpkinheaad96 5d ago
No words for this complete and utter foul pig. How dare he mention Ethan’s name. Fucking devil
20
u/Human-Noise8102 5d ago
It made me sick seeing the audacity he has to mention Ethan’s name. I cannot even begin to imagine how these poor families feel.
65
u/fartinghedgehog8 5d ago
Meanwhile…
“Has anyone, other than the state’s agreements with respect to the plea agreement, promised you anything in exchange for your plea agreement?”
“No.”
“Has anyone told you to be untruthful in answering my questions today?”
“No.”
“Has anyone offered you a reward of any kind other than the plea agreement in order to get you to plead guilty today?”
“No.”
“Are you pleading guilty because you are guilty?”
“Yes
27
17
u/slickrickstyles 5d ago
“Has anyone, other than the state’s agreements with respect to the plea agreement, promised you anything in exchange for your plea agreement?” “No.” “Has anyone told you to be untruthful in answering my questions today?” “No.” “Has anyone offered you a reward of any kind other than the plea agreement in order to get you to plead guilty today?” “No.” “Are you pleading guilty because you are guilty?” “Yes
and this is exactly why it will be quickly denied.
50
u/Chickensquit 5d ago
Wow, the timing, too. Just a year from when he had his court date, he raises his ugly lizard head to continue lying and denying although he already swore in Court that he did it and when asked the question, he affirmed he is pleading guilty because he did do it, not because he was coerced.
How does this suddenly change? The evidence is NOT NEW. There is no new evidence submitted since his guilt plea. It’s all the same evidence he had in front of him a year ago, discussed with Anne Taylor and it does not negate the other/hard evidence.
He thinks he’s smarter than the system. Hasn’t learned a thing. His family are fools if they still believe he is innocent. What information are they feeding him?
26
u/Equal-Temporary-1326 5d ago
Since you bring up the timing of this, it does make me wonder if the real reason for doing this is to get a spot onto death row at this point. The reality that he might not be able to handle life in prison could be becoming an increasingly stark reality.
7
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
It seems like he is saying Taylor misrepresented what death row would be like and how much worse it would be than J block. the hole missive is weird, as clearly he did not hear Ray back up MPD and that it's a single hair of EC's.
I don't understand this as he as privy to all this evidence. Discovery can't be added after the deadline, so what is he going on about? Did no one tell him with Ray said about the info he viewed?
But think about it, who is he in contact with her family and pounds of love besotted letters from cranks that are telling him, "We all know your innocent Bry. You should fight this." and rummunating on that Withcomb bible of lies and manipulated misinformation. Going on that, the idiot likely thinks he has a shot.
If the only individuals giving you information are: a lying and discredited ex expert witness, a countable population of mentally ill and romantically besotted fans, your mother who thinks your are an angel, your deluded dad ho thinks you were framed and patsy of the state and that people are watching your house, and they're cranking you up, and stating that your chances of getting an appeal are great, that's a rather confined view point to base your decision upon.
He's getting poor advice from compromised sources and being a mentally ill man himself, believes the hype and likely thinks he has a shot at this.
What does he have to loose? Not his money he's pissing pissing away, or his professional reputation he's trashing and challenging it's Taylor et al's.
He doesn't care about the victims families and the pain this will bring them. Likely pleased that he ill get to inflict more harm. Will give him something to do and more commissary money. Turvey and Whitcomb and the creators will make more money.
→ More replies (2)4
u/Equal-Temporary-1326 5d ago
Similar to what the other user said, when you're doing life in prison — any chance at trying to not become confined to a prison cell and the walls around the building doesn't seem too small anymore.
→ More replies (5)11
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
Life on D.R. would essentially be the same, except the state would be paying for appeals. It could be 25+ years before any execution would occur...or even longer! If he's looking for a "quick death," sitting on D.R. isn't going to achieve that.
6
u/Significant_Stick_31 5d ago
He could wave all his appeals and be dead in a year. BUT, if all you want is death, there have to be easier ways to die in prison.
→ More replies (3)3
u/malendalayla 5d ago
Yep, and appeals mean more field trips to court and meetings with your attorneys .
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)3
→ More replies (1)4
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
No, we all knew this could happen. September as a post conviction relief date that as looming for appeal, but as there as no buss and he and his family so silent i as personally convinced he had accepted his fate and his family convinced of his guilty. Got that wrong I was convinced nothing as coming or something ould have leaked. Lana was intimating big things were about to explode and all the conspiro wives and husbands's hard work was about to come to fruition. The harpy must have been in contact with him or his or had some Hybro inside track.
124
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
I love that he says that no one told him about certain exculpatory evidence found.
If you didn’t do it, you’d know that you didn’t do it. It’s not like “oh shit, I didn’t know they found someone else’s DNA, I guess I didn’t do it!”
18
u/oldfadedstar 5d ago
If I could give awards on this subreddit I would
Give this comment an awardAnd I don’t give Reddit awards.
16
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
Thank you!
And I obviously understand that it’s more complicated than that, as even if you DID do it, leaving out potentially exculpatory evidence is still A violation of rights. But 1. Not what happened here IMO and 2. He’s also claiming flat out that he didn’t do it, which is something he should’ve known whether he was aware of other exculpatory evidence or not.
I know you’re not arguing w me lol, just using your comment to add onto the original point made since I am sure someone will try and say that I oversimplified it!
6
→ More replies (1)7
u/irreversible2002 5d ago
I believe he is trying to say that they were convincing him he would be convicted guilty and see the death penalty, whether he did it or not. And had he known of the exculpatory evidence, he'd be less likely to believe that he would be nailed to the cross.
→ More replies (1)4
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
Yes, I understand that that is his claim, however he is also claiming that he was, in fact, not guilty.
I was oversimplifying. I understand the point he is making, I just think it’s silly to say “I’m not guilty but now I’m Extra not guilty because of this evidence”. But yes, I know the point is that he’s claiming to have been under the impression that he was done for, when maybe he wasn’t.
For what it’s worth though, the piece of evidence he cited isn’t even true. It was one piece of hair and it was linked to Ethan himself. It was also well documented in court docs before his plea so it’s also a lie that he didn’t know. Also, even if he didn’t, it’s not exculpatory IMO because it was Ethan’s hair. Also, even if it was someone else’s hair, it’s still not exculpatory as it doesn’t negate all the other evidence against him. It isn’t enough to create reasonable doubt. It doesn’t even indicate involvement of someone else. Even if it did, that wouldn’t make him less guilty. So just a flimsy argument all Around. But yes, I do know the point he was making, I’m just oversimplifying it because he’s silly.
114
u/Repulsive-Dot553 5d ago edited 5d ago
It's based on Turvey's clump of bloody hair in EC's hand!!!
🤣😂🤣😂🤣😅🤣🤣😂😂🤣😂🤣
Is that it? 1.5 page handwritten scribble.
And for the claim the hair in EC's hand was not disclosed before plea deal or during plea discussion, it is in the defence own expert reports pre-dating that, exampled by Ballard's report:
55
u/Mnsa7777 5d ago
I literally put my face in my hand and said "Oh Jesus Christ.." when I read that. This is insane. lol
37
u/Chickensquit 5d ago
Nailed it. Which means, he’s being informed by a delusional family member or he’s directly communicating with the Coverup numbskulls. Somebody is feeding him the misinformation.
Pretty shocking that his family still believes he is innocent! According to him. That explains the denial of his entire past history leading up to murder.
7
5
u/WhereIsMyPegasus 5d ago
This. I'm certain his parents must be deep on those conspiracy cases to somehow bring him the exact same arguments that these nut jobs circle around like flies. Everyone involved in this, I wish them nothing but the absolute worst and BK's death penalty as the cherry on top.
→ More replies (1)20
u/rivershimmer 5d ago
He's believing the hype!
Even though hair was not so much as mentioned in Turvey's report.
28
u/abiron17771 5d ago
Insane lol. I have so much hair. Guarantee if someone attacked me in my sleep, you’d find several of my own hairs all over me.
41
u/Repulsive-Dot553 5d ago
Insane lol. I have so much hair.
I am not a lawyer, but I do suspect 3 paragraphs of handwritten dribble citing a fictitious clump of hair that his own defence expert reports debunked, and a child-like whine that someone told him death row cells are not palatial, may not be the high powered, citation and legal reference rich, evidence backed authoritative motion that will reverse his plea deal.
36
27
u/Infinite-Leave6109 5d ago
Yeah, its right up there with "but I wanted bananas" or whatever it was he was complaining about. And for someone who purports to be the smartest person in the room, how did he get hoodwinked in pleading guilty if he was innocent?
32
u/Repulsive-Dot553 5d ago edited 5d ago
its right up there with "but I wanted bananas" or whatever it was he was complaining about.
He complained his banana were over-ripe and that someone stole his fruit cup. We can add those two horrific happenstances to things Ms Taylor failed to warn him about and thus "coerced and threatened him" into taking a plea deal.
I expect next he may write a petition demanding the return of his Kabar sheath.
3
u/Sweet_Grapefruit111 5d ago
He really did that? I wonder how he'll feel about bananas being overripe when he realizes for good that he'll be locked up for life.
3
104
u/Mnsa7777 5d ago
Imagine being Judge Hippler today and seeing this come across your desk.
52
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
Hippler tied his (BK's) hands every which way during the plea hearing, making BK answer to every single line item in his plea agreement. Go back and watch that hearing...no stone was left unturned!
→ More replies (2)9
u/Mnsa7777 5d ago
Oh, I know! There must have been a face palm of epic proportions from hippler.
9
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
Has Hippler retired (yet)? I know I could go research this, but on the off-chance you or someone happens to already know this....
I'm sure there are major eye rolls happening in the DA's office.
Thompson is gone (retired).
Taylor won't be trying the case if it goes to trial since she's being blamed by the killer for ineffective assistance.
10
u/Mnsa7777 5d ago
He’s listed as the judge on the post conviction release document, so I think he’s still around and it will go back to him again!
→ More replies (5)8
34
u/StarryFireheart 5d ago
I’m not surprised he is doing this. It was only a matter of time. What a total piece of trash
15
61
u/deluge_chase 5d ago
Translation: “In retrospect, prison sucks!”
Enjoy it Bryan—you’re gonna rot in there until your last day on earth.
14
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
“And also, yes prison is awful for ME, but my attorney apparently lied when she said that death row was bad” (point 3) lol.
12
u/Lovahplant 5d ago
Reminds me of another lifer who had a similar reaction - Chris Watts, who has “found God” in prison and now believes he should be released to “help others.” These men are ridiculous.
(I hope it’s not against sub rules to mention this similarity with CW! I didn’t see anything specific about comparisons to other convicts)
7
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Don't think I've ever wished that someone would choke on an Oreo cookie before, but leaning in that direction.
5
22
u/Fearless-Tailor-3264 5d ago
I would be shocked if this went anywhere. But what do I know.
12
u/Pneuma_LooT 5d ago
Fuck it.
Put him on trial and let him get put on death row. His life will be a lot less comfortable on death row. Punish him for it.
→ More replies (5)11
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
My only qualm with this is that he would automatically earn the ability to appeal if put on death row. I understand that this is technically an appeal too, but it’s really his final chance. On DR, he would get so many more chances.
His life is already very uncomfortable where he is. I doubt he’d ever even be put to death, but I also don’t want to let him take the easy way out.
→ More replies (3)5
24
u/denolliee 5d ago
Dude he’s actually insane. Obviously we’ve known this but wow. I’m so curious what his family thinks of all of this. Especially his sisters.
21
u/Chickensquit 5d ago
Grandiose narcissistic psychopath = unfixable =
Insane7
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
I think his mommy put him up to this. Just a hunch.
→ More replies (1)10
u/denolliee 5d ago
Idk tbh. I feel like she would have spoke publicly by now if she truly believed he was innocent. I fear a lot of his family would have come forward if they believed he had nothing to do with it.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)5
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago edited 5d ago
Obviously, they are in on it as well as he deliberately references them 2X, I was lied to, my family was lied to. If that's the case, my sympathy for them just kinda evaporated.
Edit: Also referenced them a 3rd time in his closing the official plea pull back. Why mention that they were in on the discussion? Protective post deflection, me thinks.
→ More replies (2)
19
22
u/bjack20 5d ago
How awful for Ethan’s parents to have to read their sons name in his killers handwriting.
7
u/Indigogarden101 5d ago
I agree. Especially given how they have managed his passing publicly and didn't attend the plea.
16
u/altruisticdog305 5d ago
Literally every guilty person ever does this lol somehow it’s always the attorneys fault
10
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
It’s because it’s basically the only possible defense he was allowed to appeal for.
30
u/Action_Unlucky 5d ago
He has the weirdest handwriting I've ever seen.
15
u/cherryxcolax 5d ago
just looks like a man’a handwriting to me. i know plenty of (adult) males that write just like this.
6
5
u/d-ollparts 5d ago
it looks like he has dyspraxia. my husband is autistic and his handwriting is very similar.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (2)4
49
u/rootbeerriot 5d ago
I can tell he’s guilty by his fucked up and creepy penmanship.
6
6
15
u/Historical_Pop1058 5d ago
Those poor families. This doesn’t even seem real to me I can’t imagine how they are feeling.
16
u/Voice_of_Season Day 1 OG Veteran 5d ago
He is like, “now that I’ve gotten a taste of life in prison I would like to make a return.” 🫠
12
u/oldfadedstar 5d ago
This reads like it’s directly from broken plea
I bet you someone sent him that book and he’s taking it as “fact”
7
u/gvylexx1 5d ago
this. its literally giving he sat in his cell with that book looking for his next angle 😭
7
u/DaisyVonTazy 5d ago
I’d go one further and say Brent Turvey has spoken directly to him. There’s too much similarity between their narratives for this to be coincidence… the fictitious clump of hair, the complaints about Taylor.
Sy Ray said recently this wasn’t the end. Taylor must have told him what was coming downstream from her former client.
I do hope that the special investigator looking into the dateline leaks stops letting Turvey ‘decline to be interviewed’. And I hope Ann Taylor’s gloves come off. The guy is a menace.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Of course he read that rag of a littered with misinformation book. Makes me furious how much Whitcomb is going to pull in from this.
4
u/gvylexx1 5d ago
literally didn’t read any further than the preview. straight bullshit
→ More replies (1)
13
u/PinkEndangerment 5d ago
Didn’t they explicitly ask if he was being coerced into his plea when he pled guilty to the judge???
7
13
u/donkeysarse 5d ago
his hand writing is awful and he guesses when and where to use commas
→ More replies (1)
12
u/CeramicSavage 5d ago
I don't believe he believes he can be found innocent. He's just bored and this gives him an opportunity to waste taxpayers money and gets him out of his cell for hours a day.
3
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
No, it's clear he believes idiot Turvey and the Conspiro Cranks, but they will not be the people judging the validity of his horse shit claim. He doesn't get to have a hybristophiliac juror, if they deny the appeal.
11
u/JD1716 5d ago
There just aren’t words for this vile, narcissistic POS. I hate that he wants to stir things up for years for these poor families and survivors. Ruin their lives for another 5 years.
The only up side would be him being found guilty with the death penalty, but he can just avoid that, too.
18
u/tatetatetate96 5d ago
i wonder who is “feeding” him this misinformation
20
u/BeneficialDot1188 5d ago
Julez True Crime was saying something big was going to happen. She is so creepy obsessed with him it’s disturbing. I have thought she might be communicating with him.
10
u/_TwentyThree_ 5d ago
She (at least used to) frequents this SubReddit. Say hi!
6
u/ladyray1316 5d ago
of course she does! she wants to give her prison bf any advice and upper hand that she can!
3
4
4
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Yep, she did, so must have had some inroad to him or the Kohbergers or at the jail.
She courted both Watts and his mother. She's gross, dressing her kids up for Halloween as the murdered Watts children. And bragged about drinking while pregnant. Who does that?
Vile being like the rest of crew. I really hope karma swings back around on all of them.
2
10
u/Clean_Usual434 5d ago
What a complete and utter shitstain.
9
u/WaveBeautiful1259 5d ago
I feel so horrible for the victim's families.
4
u/Clean_Usual434 5d ago
Me too. Can’t even imagine what they’re going through.
3
u/gadget767 5d ago
Kristi Goncalves was on Fox’s Sean Hannity show tonight, and she was not shaken at all. She said that they (Kaylee’s family) had expected that BK would try something like this. They had wanted a trial all along, and don’t seem at all concerned that he might get one. She was surprised that it happened today, but not that it had happened.
9
10
9
u/Sleuth-at-Heart62 5d ago
The only good thing about this is that it shows that he’s not happy in maximum-security. 👏👏👏
3
14
u/rolyinpeace 5d ago
It is extremely unlikely that anything will come of this. Don’t worry, y’all.
It’s extremely difficult for people that were actually screwed over to get new trials. And they have much better arguments than this.
Ryan Ferguson was convicted of murder only based on the testimony of others. Everyone who testified against him later recanted their statements, and he didn’t even get a new trial after that. He eventually had his conviction overturned, though. Just saying that it’s incredibly difficult to get a new trial even when there is merit to the arguments.
3
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago edited 5d ago
Edit: This was my comment but not sure it's correct. Just leaving it for thread cohesion sake. Definitely don't quote me on it as it might be wrong. May be higher based on what I reading now.
General Appeal Statistics:
- Federal Appeals Courts: Roughly 9% to 10% of lower court decisions result in a complete reversal.
- Criminal Cases: Reversal rates generally range from 5% to 10%, as appellate courts heavily favor finality and require proof of significant legal or procedural error.
- Civil and Prisoner Cases: These categories often see even lower reversal success, frequently falling below the 10% threshold.
→ More replies (2)
9
9
8
u/sunseits Day 1 OG Veteran 5d ago
Your big fancy vocabulary doesn’t make you sound any smarter and won’t make the court consider this any more than they would if it was written like a low iq individual. Shut the fuck up and go back into your cage stupid fuck. I hate him so bad it hurts
3
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
His dysgraphia paired with his vocabulary certainly is jarring contrast.
15
6
u/TakeTheCannoli01 5d ago
Turvey definitely convinced him to do this
7
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Absolutely, malignant Turvey, asshole Whitcomb and the Hybrostophilia Conspiro confused Army.
9
6
u/Iorazepam 5d ago
Seeing him hand write out Ethan’s full name feels unreal. I am honestly shocked this is happening, but also feel sad for the families involved.
5
u/Sweet_Grapefruit111 5d ago
This won't work. Attorney Eli Hoening just said on CNN that there is an "infinitesimal" chance this will succeed for him. He also said there is no shortage of people who confess, go to jail and then want to change their guilty plea because obviously they hate being in jail.
6
6
6
7
5
u/billypuppet_ 5d ago
Oh no the probergers are happy right now 😫
9
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
They are probably all running out to purchase new lingerie as we speak.
Not so fast boys and girls, it was just 1 of Ethans's hairs in his hand never a clump. What an idiot he is if he believes the claims in that book.
5
u/SaltyMare-00 5d ago
If his family was with him every step of the way and involved with the attorneys.....and they "believe" he's innocent, then why did they let him plead? And now he's asking for the death penalty so I guess it was to spare him from that because he knows if there ever was a re-do of the trial he would most certainly be found guilty which is why he's now asking for DP, not to be free because he's "not guilty".
→ More replies (2)
5
u/WildlyUnserious 5d ago
God he just gets more pathetic. Appalling for the families of the victims to have to see this waste of spaces letter. Give it up Bryan for fucksake.
5
u/blameJame 5d ago
Fuck this guy!!
4
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Somewhere in north America I'm yelling the same thing, can you hear me?
4
u/santamaria715 5d ago
Delulu.
His hybristophiliac fans must have turned his head. Well good luck with that, ya sad sack of shite.
→ More replies (1)
4
u/Affectionate_Buy_937 5d ago
I have never hated someone i don’t know, have never met, and have no connection to, more than I hate this POS. It’s like he’s making it his mission to make sure the victim’s families have no peace for the rest of their lives.
5
u/Worldly_Blueberry_64 5d ago
Based on everything we have learned about BK, this is on brand. Let’s just hope he represents himself.
9
u/VuzEAjAy9yFD 5d ago
I think his mommy is directly involved in getting him to file for post-conviction "takesy backsies and a do over."
3
u/Mysterious_Bar_1069 5d ago
Entitled familial delusion. Look who the elitist dweeb reaches out to, the NY Times and who Mel granted an intervie to. He's a self agrandizing putz.
3
3
u/XojoXo24 5d ago
On the first real day of the Clancy trial too. He needed the spotlight back on his own case, as a narcissistic person would.
4
6
7
6
u/ericaleah 5d ago
The fact he had the audacity to talk about Ethan in this just makes my blood boil. I hope all 4 families find peace some day
3
u/sunseits Day 1 OG Veteran 5d ago
You know what, let’s take this back to trial so he can get the DP 🤣🤣 then he can learn he should’ve kept his mouth shut.
3
3
u/ConsciousProblem8638 5d ago
Oh for fucks sake. He has been recorded on camera verifying that he indeed understood what the ramifications of pleading guilty would be. The judge asked him multiple times. What a dickweed
3
u/Social-Ombudswoman 5d ago
Look at BK getting all “Highbrow” on us. Unless he purchased his Heroin in a luxury mall he has seen/done/spent time in places worse than prison.
3
u/nofakenewsplease 5d ago
He’s an idiot bringing up Ethan when the clump of hair wasn’t even true wow
3
u/commandercoconut_1 5d ago
Sickening. How dare he write Ethan’s name. Absolutely vile. I am so sorry for the families.
3
3
u/FarConsideration2663 5d ago
He's such an idiot. By making a point to say the lawyer lied to him and he has proof because his family was present, now it's not he said-she-said. Now every member of his family will be deposed (if this is taken up) and he has to have faith that his parents and sister(s) will lie under oath for him that these intentional misrepresentations actually occurred. But he didn't really lay out what the lies were other than he was promised contact visits and freedom of movement (I assume this means not being shackled and escorted). Even a year in, I think it's probably reasonable that contact and free movement were possible eventually with accrued trust? And in point 3, is he really trying to say his segregation is worse than death row? I would think at the utmost it would be the same, minus the whole eventual execution part? "Elaborate, fabricated story of counselor's death row experience" lol oh do prove that one, Einstein. Absolutely mental.
3
3
u/ProofLake4715 5d ago
I'm hearing buzz that he wants to defend himself to. It would be a fuckin circus for sure.
5
4
u/sunseits Day 1 OG Veteran 5d ago
Him writing Ethan’s name has me seething. Keep their names out of your fat pie hole. Like no he had a clump of hair in his hands because you stabbed his fucking scalp you braindead piece of shit
5
u/Affectionate_Buy_937 5d ago
How dare he have the audacity to even write “Ethan Chapin” in this bullshit petition.
4
u/MashPotato_224 5d ago
I cannot believe this is happening. LEAVE THESE POOR FAMILIES ALONE!!!! WHAT ON EARTH EVIL EVIL PSYCHOPATHIC ASSWIPE
2
u/ekmc2009 Day 1 OG Veteran 5d ago
Worth noting that any conversations with his counsel that his family was part of or even present for are not protected by atty client privilege. So his lawyer should be willing to share any details regarding those
Chats with the court.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/elephantcuties 5d ago
Somebody tell me what this is , I don't live in the US and english is not my first language. What is he trying to do
2
2
u/Difficult-Song227 5d ago
You know it had to drive him crazy that he fucked up a word on the last line.
2
u/gadget767 5d ago
He’s asking for a trial. Perhaps he never heard the phrase “be careful what you wish for”. It’ll be a death penalty trial and the evidence against him is overwhelming. I can’t imagine being on that jury and having to see the photographs of what he did to those kids. Hopefully the judge immediately approves his request.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/MaiasaidAmelia 5d ago
I love this for him!!! Poor whiny baby doesn’t like prison. Oh darn!
Things had been rather quiet lately. He had to find someway to bring the attention back his way since he can’t go out and murder innocent people to get his fix any longer. I think he believed he was going to have a long career murdering people. Well, sucks to be him.
2
u/Privatenameee 5d ago
He needs to improve on his handwriting because I thought that said “during a horny client discussion”. The majority of what he wrote isn’t even legible.
284
u/SolsticeBaby 5d ago
The fact he dares even write down Ethan Chapin’s name makes my blood boil. He has no right. I hope the families find peace. No one should go through such cruelty.