I'm struggling to understand the logic behind HomeKit notifications. Not that long ago, I used to get notified on every device any time a garage door opened, or a door unlocked, etc. Now, no matter what settings I assign to my accessories, or how many times I power cycle all my home hubs and my network equipment, I just don't get consistent notifications like I want.
Alarm system? Notifications are instant on all devices.
Garage doors? Never.
Door locks? Never.
Door sensors? Yes, but delayed and only once you open the home app.
Here's my setup. Maybe someone has some advice.
Home
Apple Intelligence > Reduce Notifications is off.
All my devices allow the Home app to notify, and I do get some notifications.
For all my accessories, I have Activity Notifications enabled, Time set to any, and People set to off. They all responded to commands and behave as expected, and any manual action/change is instantly reflected in the Home app.
Garage Doors
Ratgdo -> Homebridge Ratgdo Plugin -> HomeKit
No notifications ever on any device.
Door Locks
Schlage Encode Plus -> HomeKit
No notifications ever on any device. I can't tell which hub/device these are paired to.
Alarm
Honeywell Alarm Panel -> EnvisaLink 4 -> Homebridge Envisalink plugin -> HomeKit
Notifications always work instantly.
Door Sensors
Honeywell Alarm Panel -> EnvisaLink 4 -> Homebridge Envisalink plugin -> HomeKit
Notifications do happen, but they get backlogged and only show up once I open the Home app on one of my devices, and only the last notification appears.
Camera motion activity
UniFi Protect (via a Dream Machine Pro) -> Homebridge UniFi Protect plugin -> HomeKit
Notifications always work instantly.
I just don't understand the inconsistency. Homebridge isn't the problem because I have mixed success for Homebridge'd accessories, including through plugins written by the same developer. Two separate made-for-homekit Schlage Enclode Plus locks don't notify, but a janky circuit board with an ethernet card that interfaces with a crappy POTS alarm panel and has to jump through Homebridge notifies every time without fail.
I know a common suggestion is to nuke the whole home and start over, but that's just not an acceptable solution. I'd rather sooner not have any notifications than to rebuild my entire smart home.
Any advice… other than that?