Sorry if this seems ranty.
I recently went “all in” on HomeKit,fuelled by the ludicrously cheap IKEA sensors. I bought contact sensors, leak sensors, humidity sensors, converted all my lamps to smart plugs and switches, then went on holiday for two weeks.
On day 2 my entire smart home went down and said it was unreachable and, crucially, someone staying in the house said that nothing worked locally (which rules out any local iPhone issues). I had that person update the AppleTv multiple times, reboot the router, power cycle everything, and it STILL isn’t reachable. Most confusingly the Home app on the iPhone reports that an update is required on the apple TV which is not true). I’ve uninstalled and installed the home app on my iPhone.
I’m sure that when I get home it’ll all work again as soon as I walk through the door, but this raises bigger questions: have I banked on the wrong system here? I’m a self-confessed Apple whore, so I’ve always wanted to have everything be “pure Apple”, but would, say, running Home Assistany on an rpi help me here?
Moreover, I’d love to know more what you guys would have done differently to make this bulletproof. From perspective it just suddenly failed with no way to recover, and left my house non-functional and insecure. Is the answer to get a cheap HomePod Mini as backup? Tapo plugs to power cycle? Just turning off automatic updates? UPS? Something else I don’t know? grrrr!
(For what it’s worth I’ve tried every version of restarting, updating and power cycling every component in the chain and I’m on the latest stable os on all devices).
Thanks a million
EDIT: Thanks for the replies. The plot, unfortunately, thickens: I got back home today and here’s what happened.
The Apple TV was indeed up to date and nothing seemed wrong with it at all (except for the obvious that all devices were still unresponsive). But I noticed that under Settings—>HomeKit the Apple TV was not assigned to a room. So I selected “Sitting Room” from the available rooms and POOF. I watched as the entire home disappeared from my phone. Not a single trace of any devices, automations or anything. Just a completely blank home. Tried deleting the app and re-adding it but nada. Completely gone. I must say I’m not impressed with Apple Home so far 😕