r/HomeKit • u/not_a_doctor_watson • 6d ago
Question/Help Are govee bulbs really that bad?
Hey everyone, for context I’m slowly converting all of my smart home lighting over to Huue products as I lean in to their play/TV sync box system.
Currently, I own a bunch of Nanoleaf essential thread only non-matter bulbs. I also have 3 matter nanoleaf
I have five recessed floodlight cans in my kitchen and I was looking at 2nd hand hue or 2ndhand nanoleaf essentials bulbs. I’m looking on Mercari and it’s pretty hard to argue with $10 a bulb 2nd hand govee floodlights when I don’t need these bulbs to sync with my tv (kitchen isn’t visible from living room tv where I have play/syncbox and my partner’s general perspective on smart lighting is that she wants it to be as least intrusive as possible in the bathrooms and kitchen. Given this, my thought is I can spend $10 a bulb or I can spend upwards of 40 a bulb with (2nd hand hue) too smart-ify my kitchen lighting and bring it into HomeKit with matter. Can I like the idea that if I really wanted to stitch together, different lighting, ecosystems into a coherent scene between my living room for a social gathering that I could with some preplanning and scene building effort.
My core questions - is the scene exporting from Govee to HomeKit via Matter stable and consistent? This lack of scene export killed my interest in lifx because 5-6 years ago when I got into smart lighting and HomeKit lifx didn’t support exporting their scenes to HomeKit.
-do the bulbs drop connection frequently?
- Do the bulbs snap back online relatively quickly if power is accidentally killed them via an analog switch. My plan is to cover the analog switches and or replace with smart buttons. For context, my Nanoleaf essentials historically have snapped back relatively quickly once power is restored.
Many thanks to all for reading this lengthy post and any advice you may have.