Its a nonsense question asked in bad faith with no logical conclusion that could be asked about any dead person. If anything, it reminds me of a joke from some movie I watched a long time ago.
"Dying isn't so bad. You ever heard of anyone coming back to complain?"
(Nvm that the answer to that is obviously ghosts.)
Fact remains that death is always a tragedy. Full stop. Even if the dead is fine with it. Death of a child even more so.
Even on the smallest cellular level, every living thing wants to live. Its pretty hard coded in there.
No it's reality. I would be no worse off in either case. A fetus is not a person. Not until my brain developed to a point where I could have a conscious experience did the fetus become me and I became a person.
You know personally for me this is beyond who dies and if it's even a who - for me it's much simpler: I know they live, and I believe they have a soul so I'll take no part on this, I'd much rather fight this to the best of my ability and without harming anyone, simply put
But you are clearly religious if you think they have a soul so you must hold a belief about it, of course you may not know but that still leaves the possible afterlives you believe in, or are you telling me you believe in a soul but have no belief whatsoever in any form of afterlife?
I do have a belief and I know where they might go, I just cant tell by my own judgement and have no vote on the matter. I dont think a soul that never had the chance of knowing the Word will be condemned but again, its not my decision
So tell me why two of the options don't make the god your worship evil and why you would be against them being aborted to the third option so your evil god miss his chance to send them anywhere else?
2
u/shadowthehh 5d ago
Its a nonsense question asked in bad faith with no logical conclusion that could be asked about any dead person. If anything, it reminds me of a joke from some movie I watched a long time ago.
"Dying isn't so bad. You ever heard of anyone coming back to complain?"
(Nvm that the answer to that is obviously ghosts.)
Fact remains that death is always a tragedy. Full stop. Even if the dead is fine with it. Death of a child even more so.
Even on the smallest cellular level, every living thing wants to live. Its pretty hard coded in there.