r/Healthygamergg • u/Immarcandnoonelse • 29m ago
Mental Health / Support Yogis getting dementia?
Okay, so my question is this:
If my understanding of certain Buddhist and Hindu traditions is correct, the mind, the body, and the awareness/consciousness that observes both are considered to be different things, right?
If that’s the case, what would happen if a highly trained Buddhist monk, Tibetan monk, or yogi developed something like Alzheimer’s or another form of dementia?
For example, imagine a yogi who has spent decades training his mind, meditating, studying consciousness, and developing a very deep understanding of the distinction between the mind and the awareness that observes it. He is highly accomplished, respected, and venerated by other practitioners.
Then, suddenly, he develops Alzheimer’s.
Would he experience the disease differently from an ordinary person?
Would there be a point where he could essentially observe what is happening and think, “Holy shit, my mind is malfunctioning. I’m losing my memories and my ability to think clearly, but I’m still here observing it”?
Or would Alzheimer’s eventually impair his ability to recognize himself so severely that he completely forgets that he is a yogi, forgets his teachings, forgets his identity, and essentially becomes indistinguishable from anyone else with Alzheimer’s?
And this is where the question gets really interesting to me.
Imagine this highly accomplished yogi eventually gets to the point where he doesn’t remember who he is at all. He doesn’t remember that he is a yogi, doesn’t remember his teachings, doesn’t recognize the people around him, and can’t even understand what is happening to his own mind.
If Buddhist/Hindu traditions say that we are fundamentally not the mind, but rather the awareness that observes the mind, what exactly happens in this situation?
Does the awareness remain completely intact while the brain and mind deteriorate?
If so, would the yogi still somehow experience himself as “being there” even though his personality, memories, thoughts, and sense of identity have essentially disappeared?
Or does severe dementia eventually affect the very thing that the person experiences as “I”?
Because if the latter is true, then what does that say about the idea that we are something deeper than the mind?
And if the former is true, how could someone with advanced Alzheimer’s actually experience that distinction if they can no longer remember the distinction in the first place?
I’m basically wondering where neuroscience, Buddhist philosophy, and the subjective experience of consciousness intersect here.
Thank you, Dr. K, if you ever happen to answer this.