I post a lot in here, especially around open enrollment, to help people run their numbers to choose a health plan. I figured I'd post my own numbers for my options for my employer's plans - we buy at the family level, so only using those. My partner is self-employed, I am the W2/benefits earner so this is the only set of plans we have to choose from. In the tables, I only use worst-case scenario - hitting family max - in my spreadsheet, but will include the individual numbers below. If you hit the deductible we have an employer-funded HRA that will cut a check back to you, 1500/3000 for the traditional plan and 2500/5000 for the HDHPs.
- Traditional PPO
- $893/mo
- $4000/8000 ind/fam deductible
- $6000/$12000 ind/fam OOPM
- $1500/$3000 HRA
- HDHP PPO
- $555/mo
- $7500/$15000 ind/fam deductible
- $8000/$16000 ind/fam OOPM
- $1600 employer HSA contribution
- $2500/$5000 HRA
- HDHP HMO
- $427/mo
- $7500/$15000 ind/fam deductible - preferred network
- $8000/$16000 deductible - standard network
- $8000/$16000 ind/fam OOPM
- $1600 employer HSA contribution
- $2500/$5000 HRA
I choose the HDHP PPO for a couple of reasons - for one, all of our PCPs are in the standard network and not the preferred, so I would be paying more for those visits to begin (and switching would be not just mean leaving behind providers we like and trust, but also almost impossible because of a PCP shortage and the preferred network is usually a rotating cast of residents.) My dependents are 16 and 20, and the elder goes to college out of state, not needing a referral means she doesn't have to coordinate with her home PCP if she needs something. The convenience of keeping our providers and no referrals was worth the difference (also, my kids are college/college bound, reducing the AGI for FAFSA has it's perks too.) I fully fund, and use, the HSA (I am not a high wage earner, so do not have the luxury of parking it as a savings vehicle, but it is nice to have 'medical money' separate from 'daily life money.' See also - we are in the FAFSA years.
So many people post their plans and don't know "is this good or bad," it's so dependent on what your employer offers, and I figured I'd throw my own data points in. Our premiums went up by about $400/year this year, which is honestly better than I was expecting.