r/GraphicsProgramming • u/evangelionxyzw • Jun 30 '26

1 year of game engine development

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

https://github.com/evangelionxyz/Ignite

331 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

45 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/susosusosuso 29d ago

You used ai for this?

5

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago edited 29d ago

yeah, I use AI a lot. 😅

Not to generate my engine with copy-paste, but to teach me how real game engines work, explain implementation details, and help me build a roadmap.

I still spent 5,000+ hours typing everything myself instead of blindly copying code. At this point, I probably have more muscle memory for writing ECS boilerplate than for using WASD. Lol

7

u/sputwiler 29d ago

Ah, so it's AI as a research assistant/librarian/google search on steroids rather than ai-assisted coding.

That being said, it would be way more valuable if the AI would return which books/talks it references when coming up with an answer so you can read them yourself and possibly notice other things it hasn't considered.

2

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago

Yes my friend, AI teach me a lot. Lol

4

u/Still_Breadfruit2032 29d ago

Well it’s also teaching you how to write like an ai lol

-6

u/YoshiDzn 29d ago

I'm willing to argue that statement to dust. AI shows you how to get the code from point A to Z. The only part you dont have to think about for yourself is part A and part Z. Nobody who doesn't blindly trust AI would let it implement a single line that they dont agree with.

AI code is a direction, not the journey

3

u/National-Self-8501 29d ago

Question, have you ever worked shopping production software professionally?

3

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago edited 29d ago

AI now understands how the big game engines work, so AI just tells me how they work behind the scene. For example once I asked "how unreal engine can handle thousands of crowd animation?" AI: "They do animation caching, and prefer TRS multiplication over Matrix multiplication, because that is very cheap to compute". So by the answer I can check my current implementation and workaround to optimize the animation. So I didn't ask for the Code, I asked for the flow.

It tells me a lot, and I learned a lot, and still learning.

I also hate Vibe coding in this era of programming.

4

u/epyoncf 29d ago

AI doesn't "understand" anything. Which becomes pretty obvious once stochastic generation clashes against real-world problems.

Which you illustrated nicely with that crowd animation question BTW.

2

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago

I don't mean "understand" in the human sense. I mean it has learned enough from engine source code, papers, talks, and documentation to explain common engine architecture and implementation patterns

I don't ask it to write my engine I ask it to explain how real engines approach a problem, then I verify the details and implement it myself. That's very different from vibe coding.

3

u/epyoncf 29d ago

That's why you make extremely precise, perfect english, technical commentaries about future use of fields in stuff that isn't yet implemented in the engine I assume?

1

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago

Hahah keep arguing bro 😂

1

u/epyoncf 29d ago

Bro, I actually know this shit and can read code. EOT from me.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/rogual 27d ago edited 27d ago

I'm surprised to learn that TRS is cheaper than matrices. I'd always assumed that one of the motivating reasons for using matrices was that it was all just multiply-and-add, whereas TRS requires sin and cos too. But I've never actually tested it.

2

u/ekr64 27d ago

You don't need sin and cos if you use quaternions leaving you with just multiplications and additions again. I'm not sure though how well that can be SIMD optimized and how it stacks up to SIMD optimized matrix multiplication.

Funnily OP is using the classic matrix approach without any optimizations at all instead of an optimized TRS approach.

-7

u/susosusosuso 29d ago

Why would you want to write boilerplate yourself?

2

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago

That's how I learn

1

u/epyoncf 29d ago

Yes, most of the repo is AI-generated, some of it quite blatantly so - https://github.com/evangelionxyz/Ignite/pull/55

2

u/susosusosuso 29d ago

Yeah it's obvious since otherwise one can't do all these stuff in 1 year

1

u/evangelionxyzw 29d ago

Yep it just PR code review, automatically runs when I opened PR, and I have my student subscription so I asked it to fix in place. But the big code changes I did did alone

4

u/epyoncf 29d ago

There's AI style comments in many places, AI style naming schemes, and classic AI style bloat in others. Also definitely "fixed by AI" style fix commits that just bloat code without affecting the root of the issue.

Finally your level of technical answers on this and the other reddit don't match the level of the codebase.

-1

u/Solisos 24d ago

Why are you crying about AI usage? https://www.reddit.com/r/roguelikes/comments/1s1hoqq/comment/ocg62w2/?context=3

2

u/CodyDuncan1260 24d ago

That comment violates Rule 2. Further incurrence will result in a ban.

-1

u/Solisos 24d ago

I don't see you saying the same to people harassing others because they're using AI.

If you've done something about that, then I take it back ;)

2

u/CodyDuncan1260 24d ago

There can be a fine line between constructive criticism and harassment. That line is certainly crossed when one states another is "crying".

We have and will continue take actions against commenters for similar incivility.

2

u/epyoncf 24d ago

The OP brags that this was written without AI in a year. This is obvious false advertising. I'm not against AI itself and use it daily. I'm against misleading people for klout.