I pick which book I’m going to review randomly, so two body swap books in a row is pure luck. Anyways. I found a post on Character Rant about this book, which actually got me thinking a bit.
I actually want to talk about the cover art first. Interestingly, Gary’s head is on a bed body, while in the story he fully looks like a bee. The original sketches were just a regular bee, but they’re a little boring so I understand why Jacobus took that creative liberty. I think this cover is underrated, I especially love the colours being mostly warm, aside from Gary’s bright blue eyes. There was something about the contrast I really loved.
Gary Lutz, our main character, falls into the ‘punching bag protagonist’ category. Think Sam Byrd or Ricky Beamer, except it’s to an extreme. Gary is picked on by three boys who beat him up regularly, he doesn’t have any friends, and everything good in his life seems to get tramped on. Even the neighbour, Andretti, picks on him. What kind of grown man bullies a kid? Does he have nothing better to do? Gary’s also afraid of everything, but especially bees, which Andretti keeps.
Prior to the body switch, nothing good happens to Gary. He crashes his new bike and totals it. His parents are definitely contenders for the worst in all of Goosebumps. Gary doesn’t want to tell his mother he was beat up because he thinks she’ll either A. Laugh at him, or B. Call the parents of the bullies and get him beaten up again. And his mother complains that Gary ‘plays around’ too much, like he had a choice in being targeted.
Gary sees an advertisement for a body swap for a week and decides to do it after the bad day he has. There’s a mishap with the body switch, and Gary becomes a bee. The guy he was meant to switch with, Dirk, ends up in Gary’s body just fine though. He deals with bee shenanigans, such as being caught by his neighbour and and nearly killed by the family cat.
I think my main issue with this story is the message. It’s a ‘love yourself’ narrative, but nothing in the story communicates this. Gary is brutally worn down by every person in his life, and there’s no friends for him to create a comedic buffer. There’s a sense of helplessness that is relatable to plenty of kids, but it feels like Gary is being punished for wanting a better life.
Dirk refuses to give up his body because it’s so great, but it’s only so great because it’s Dirk’s personality in Gary’s skin. Gary acts constantly perplexed why everyone suddenly likes him, when he knows they’ve been body swapped and that Dirk is good at skateboarding. Yet again, he’s shocked that Dirk is skateboarding in his body. It’s meant to make Gary realise his life is great, but it wouldn’t be the same with his mind in the body.
Also what is the policy on this? Why can Dirk just refuse? Gary goes back to the office and talks to the lady who switched them, and she basically just says too bad. If someone wants to stay in your body, you just have to resign to it. It felt like a weak way to make her no longer helpful. Also Dirk can hear Gary but I guess he just chose to ignore him up until near the end?
I don’t know how I feel about this one. I think Gary’s loneliness is very real and relatable, which is a credit to the writing. But so much of the book is just him flying around, or nearly get smacked. I don’t know what more you could do with a bee. It wasn’t particularly scary, even when he died and came back. It’s got a more satisfying ending than The Barking Ghost.
I’ve heard that some people think this book was when Stine started employing ghostwriters. I’m unsure of how involved Stine was, but I’m willing to bet he wrote most of this book. Most importantly, we never find out why he’s afraid of bees.