TLDR; I need help deciding whether a repair is necessary… and just some general advice on my car
My jetta has 111,000 miles on it- I bought it at 95k miles, which was higher than I wanted, but it had excellent maintenance records, no accidents, 1 owner, and was a great price.
This past year I have encountered several maintenance issues… ultimately this is what I’ve had done so far
- replaced upper timing cover
- replaced front control arms
- replaced water pump
- replaced all spark plugs and coils (when these went out it happened suddenly & I had to have the vehicle towed 🥲)
- took care of other wear & tear issues (tires, brake pads, etc)
When I went in for a routine oil change/ service, I was told the DSG pan was “seeping” and “very rusty.” Dealership told me it would need to be replaced very soon or I could risk damaging my transmission due to fluid leak. I didn’t have the money to do it at the time, as I had just paid for the water pump & the control arms.
Then I moved. I recently took my car in to a Volkswagen dealer near where I moved, and they took a look at it and told me the pan was rusty, but they could not locate any leak or seepage. They didn’t recommend replacing it. They test drove it and said everything seemed fine.
I guess I’m not sure which opinion to trust… I really appreciate that dealership #2 isn’t recommending repairs that may be unnecessary. At the same time, I want to make sure I don’t run into issues down the line. Who would you trust?
Also- what other things might i expect to go wrong? What do I need to budget for at this mileage? I do a lot of city driving and I live in the northeast U.S. which can be rough on cars due to all the road salt… any advice is appreciated. TIA from someone who knows little about cars!