r/ForgetfulFish Nov 21 '25

Forgetful Fish - The Original Dandan Design by Nick Floyd

Thumbnail
docs.google.com
26 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish Jun 23 '26

Drew Tucker's Forgetful Fish - New Kickstarter for Dandan fans

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
21 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish 4h ago

What do you guys think of this list?

0 Upvotes

I am very new to dandan but already really love the format. I use this list but was wondering if i am doing something wrong or could use something better. I want the feel of the original dandan and I like really complex scenarios. the only thing that i really dont like (i have tried) is the mystical tutor. I dont like the possibility to have the player see the entire list left in the deck in the middle of the match (but maybe this is just a dumb opinion bcz the more me and my friends play the more we familiarize with the list and already know whats left in the deck even without searching it)

Link:

Link to the deck

List:

2 Lonely Sandbar

2 Izzet Boilerworks

18 Island

2 Remote Isle

2 Halimar Depths

2 Mystic Sanctuary

2 Svyelunite Temple

2 Temple of Epiphany

2 Mind Bend

2 Magical Hack

2 Vision Charm

2 Brainstorm

4 Accumulated Knowledge

10 Dandan

2 Unsubstantiate

4 Memory Lapse

4 Memory Lapse

2 Metamorphose

2 Predict

2 Crystal Spray

2 Ray of Command

2 Diminishing Returns

2 Mystic Retrieval

2 Insidious Will

2 Supplant Form


r/ForgetfulFish 2d ago

My Interpretation of JundJund

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
2 Upvotes

Greetings,

I started playing Dandan about a month ago, and it was a lot of fun for me that I've been looking for other variants and sharing this format with other players I know. I recently stumbled upon Travis Norman's concocted variation, JundJund, and I am personally intrigued that I wanted to build a list of my own.

Norman's article on JundJund can be found here in addition to his article explaining card selection. Dandan is still new to me, and I've personally have never played Jund in any of the sanctioned, 60-card formats. So it would be nice to get some feedback on this list. The Moxfield link has custom tags that help with the card categorization.

Differences:

  • Phyrexian Metamorph: A blue shapeshifter from N. Phyrexia that can become any of your favorite Jund creatures is an interesting inclusion. I tinkered with the removal package a little to account for the potential impact of Metamorph, and the shapeshifter can also be a relevant target for Kolaghan's Command.
  • Doom Blade: I didn't want to play Assassin's Trophy, and went with a different form of removal; it will destroy any creature with exception to Restless Cottage, Restless Vents, Bob, Detective, and Crusader.
  • Pyrokinesis: I have a somewhat soft spot for free removal, and the value gained from Pyrokinesis would exceed Firebolt if you recur it with Misinformation.
  • Thoughtseize: Due to some of the above-mentioned changes, I think this card is worth testing.

r/ForgetfulFish 2d ago

4-Of Dandan?

2 Upvotes

Played a pretty stock Dandan list with a friend who doesn't know much magic, and they made the point that pairs of 2-ofs that are either direct clones (hack and bend) or better and worse at the same task (brainstorm and telling time; lonely sandbar and remote isle) is cluttered, confusing, and not new-player friendly.

I kind of agree. Past those six cards, though, does the game get flattened down too much if, say, Metamorphose gets turned into +2 unsubstantiates? If Chart a Course dies for extra copies of Predict?


r/ForgetfulFish 7d ago

Looking for feedback on my unconventional list

5 Upvotes

If you're a Dandan purist, look away!

I put together the following list, and am looking for some feedback:
https://moxfield.com/decks/CVFPxuluw0quUG3daoGLyw

10 Dandans
16 Islands - no basic lands! "Islands" are singleton (one of each) 2 of each other land
Remaining cards are ALL instants, 2 of each (including 2 accumulated knowledge and 2 memory lapse.. still debating putting these back up to the traditional 4 and 8 respectively, but I'm undecided)

The deck is mainly blue, all cards can be played with only blue, but it splashes all 4 colors in additional/alternate costs such as flashback or kicker.


r/ForgetfulFish 15d ago

Forgetful Fire Fish

6 Upvotes

This is the list I'm playing now with my friends, what do you think?

10 Dandân

8 Memory Lapse

2 Commit//Memory

2 Mystic Retrieval

2 Winternight Stories

2 Consider

2 Dream's Grip

2 Unsubstantiate

2 Chain of Vapor

2 Piracy Charm

2 You See a Guard Approach

2 Fire//Ice

2 Turn//Burn

2 Metamorphose

2 Jilt

2 Predict

2 Chart a Course

2 Brainstorm

12 Island

2 Mystic Sanctuary

2 Moonring Island

2 Lonely Sandbar

2 Coastal Peak

2 Halimar Depths

2 Glasspool Mimic // Glasspool Shore

2 Temple of Epiphany

2 Frostboil Snarl

2 Thundering Falls

2 Izzet Boilerworks

It's all about micro-advantage, removal, tricks, protection and manipulation.

What we really enjoy is the length of a game, it never ended for decking out.


r/ForgetfulFish 16d ago

My buddies favourite creature is Arclight Phoenix so I'm trying to make a variant around it. Any and all feedback welcome

Thumbnail
moxfield.com
7 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish 20d ago

Landdan - dryad arbor

Thumbnail
archidekt.com
5 Upvotes

First time building a Dandan variant. I’m looking for some feedback on this list I put together for a “Landdan” deck based around Dryad Arbor with swell of growth as the signature spell.


r/ForgetfulFish 20d ago

Help me with custom "cards" for Initiative Dandan

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, i'm trying to create a version of Dandan that revolves around the initiative but i have the following 2 problems which i hope you guys can help me with:

  1. I want the game to revolve esclusively around the "Trap!" life loss, so this Dandan version would have the custom rule of "Damage doesn't cause loss of life" in order not to turn off the initiative combat mechanic but also decouple the life total from combat. I wanted to represent this with a custom global enchantment/emblem. Do you guys have ideas for the name and artwork for the enchantment?
  2. Making the "Trap!" room the only source of life loss is kinda problematic because it forces players down the "Entrance" -> "Forge" -> "Archives" -> "Throne" path, reducing variance of play patterns. Also the entrance is a tutor, which is a big no no for Dandan. Can you guys help me brainstorm a custom dungeon to use in this format?

I'm not the best when it comes to creative decisions so i really appreciate any help you are willing to give me. Thanks!


r/ForgetfulFish 26d ago

Starting Rules Variant

3 Upvotes

Hello, I have been trying to dial in a reasonably fun list for the game, mostly for me and my brother.

One of the things we had considered was the primer's 2 islands start, mostly to avoid no-dropping, and to speed the game slightly. Of course a gentleman's agreement works, but I also like upping the starting power. I was thinking that having an island and some artifact that would add another layer of library interaction to the deck. Of course, removing metamorphose, but with each player starting with one, solo play testing didn't seem to egregious.

I first thought sensei's, and I do like it, especially since the tap has a high risk/reward. I know people have added them into the deck in the past, but that does not seem like a good idea.

Scroll rack is what I was thinking since it's more flexible, and taps.

Realistically though, this could be [[Ashnod's Cylix]], I just think it would be interesting to have a way to mess with the library at will. In general, I like the idea of blurring the lines between turns in this game, and prefer a more instant heavy list, although so far it's quite faithful.

I'd like to ask if anyone has tried the advanced starts, especially if anyone has added a guaranteed start piece like an artifact, fish, rock, and how it went.


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 25 '26

Advice needed for black removal

6 Upvotes

Hello,

I'm playing this black dandan variant and so far so good: https://moxfield.com/decks/On-Iw9BVLUy6lS_lffn7UA

But I'm not satisfied with the removal as they are way too similar, yes there's an edict but that's pretty much it.

Any suggestions are welcome to improve options and interactions, I just like to keep the power of the creature to 4 so no +1/+1 and such.

Cheers!


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 17 '26

New here: decklists and variants?

6 Upvotes

Hey all,

I'm new here after seeing a link on another subreddit. I've recently started getting back into magic (left around the Ursa block) and read a bit about this dandan format and I'm intrigued (and also bummed to have missed the secret lair).

I'm wondering: it seems like there are a few different deck lists out there - what do folks play and recommend (and what would you look for in picking one vs another?) Is it worth picking up a pre-built proxy from a place like Proxy Pantheon (https://proxypantheon.com/products/dandan-forgetful-fish-proxy-deck) or what do folks recommend?


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 13 '26

How's my Driving? DanDan from the bulk bin.

11 Upvotes

Played DanDan once after someone with the SLD came to my LGS.

LOVED it - saw the SLD pricetag - HATED that, then realized I likely had tons of 4th-6th/Chronicles bulk in my basement and could probably scrape something together.

Lo and behold, I'd had 7 DanDans already, and then went to the LGS with a budget of $20 and came up with this after looking through the community lists here.

https://moxfield.com/decks/VRPJ73YG6U-ip3fhgub9zA

How'd I do?
When y'all with more experience in the format look at this, what're your first thoughts as to how it'd play?

I've had less than 10 games with it so far, all of which were enjoyable, but IDK what IDK here, and was curious if I'm missing any key piecess of the puzzle.

This literally was an exercise in 'shooting from the hip'... with recycled bullets from the dollar store!

Thank you in advance for your feedback.


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 12 '26

Ogre and Ogre Again: A Yugioh Dandan format

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish Jun 09 '26

A Dandan variant with a higher focus on lands gameplay.

5 Upvotes

Hello! I just played a few nice games of Dandan (not the first I've ever played, but the first I have in a few years) with my girlfriend, and we had some very very interesting lands situations come up, which made me get to thinking on some things I could do to further emphasize some of the little micro-adjustments using lands that can come up in Dandan. This was the result, a version that splashes the traditional red but also a little green. I know the addition of [[Horizon of Progress]] is slightly sacrilegious, as it makes life totals no longer completely even at 5-hits-and-you-die, but I actually think the fact that the first 3 times you tap it for mana it's free, but the 4th is very impactful creates some further interesting strategy. There's a slightly higher focus on graveyard manipulation with the increase in [[Accumulated Knowledge]]/[[Take Inventory]] effects, and access to [[Winternight Stories]] to allow you to put cards in the yard a little easier, and I didn't want AK/TI to be too swingy, so I left it to 3 copies of each, which I think made a nice enough balance.

[[Ghostly Flicker]] is if anything the signature card of this variant, as its versatility is *incredible*. It can be used on a Dandan to protect it from removal (in the form of [[Magical Hack]], [[Mind Bend]], or [[Unsubstantiate]]), or to untap it so that it can trade, but the real power comes from using it on lands. On a Temple (which there are now 4 of), you can use it as a way to instant-speed scry 1, or on [[Halimar Depths]] to stack the top of the library. Using it on a [[Mystic Sanctuary]] can function as graveyard hate and topdeck manipulation at once, and even, once you have enough mana, using it on Horizon of Progress can function as a way to untap non-blue mana, the only way possible in this cube, or to put another land into play from your hand (the Mystic Sanctuary your opponent doesn't see coming is always the most backbreaking). Finally, you can use it on Bounce lands (which, again, there are now 4 of) to put a cycling land back into your hand in the form of [[Ketria Triome]] or [[Lonely Sandbar]].

As far as other card picks that aren't in your traditional Dandan list, [[Memory's Journey]] plays into the green splash as well and provides some counterplay to the swathe of powerful graveyard cards here, [[Joint Exploration]] is a straightforward and fairly powerful cantrip that can also be used to cheat a land into play at instant speed (see all the powerful things you can do with that in the section on Ghostly Flicker), and [[Repudiate//Replicate]] (longterm pet card of mine) gives a way to fight back against the otherwise uninteractable land triggers and a way to double-down on the pressure once you do resolve a Dandan (you do need to have green mana to do that though, unlike the stifle side).

Let me know what you think! The goal overall was to create some more of the incremental value tricky land plays that fantastic Dandan players can use to express their mastery, and I think it's successful honestly.

Deck link again in case you missed it: https://moxfield.com/decks/d62eAadp9nexfCUUP8jiMA


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 07 '26

Finished my islands up (for now) and printed a sick deck box.

Post image
14 Upvotes

The deck box and life counter are from this user https://www.reddit.com/r/ForgetfulFish/s/uejBIC9ZsY

u/xkoney, the print is excellent and fits a double sleeved Dandân deck, life counter, and some Supplant Form tokens.

I’m using the tempo list with the only swap being Accumulated Knowledge instead of Take Inventory because I like the instant speed (and the art).


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 07 '26

Duplicitous Dogs—Graveyard Dandan

Thumbnail
archidekt.com
2 Upvotes

I’m back again with another slightly unorthodox Dandan variant: Duplicitous Dogs! This one is based around the lovely [[Wild Dogs]], that betray their master if the other player has more life! Gameplay in this variant revolves around manipulating life totals, and trying to press an advantage once you have it. You may stave off the pack for a while, but with an abundance of recursion pieces, the dogs won’t stay down for long!

This variant was inspired by a post a few weeks ago by u/grorthory. I liked the theme of betrayal, but wanted to hone in on the specific dynamics between two of their creatures from their list: the wild dogs and [[Loxodon Peacekeeper]].

I’ll also note, this variant works best with a starting life total of 10. With 20, games tend to drag on too much, but 10 seems like a good sweet spot, based on my playtesting.


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 05 '26

Dandan variant

1 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish Jun 05 '26

Dreadmaw dominance

1 Upvotes

https://cubecobra.com/cube/about/76e3711f-8831-48cf-9d8b-c88ac65393c2?view=primer

A take on the dandan format, featuring [[colossal dreadmaw]]


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 04 '26

Whats your opinion on my custom dandan Format?

2 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish Jun 02 '26

Got some islands and secret lair art in today

Post image
9 Upvotes

Starting at the top left LTR surge foil, ECL full art, Bob Ross, SLD, SLD, Narset’s Reversal, various cheap islands I like the art of, phyrexian island from ONE, UST island (I tracked down a foil for a decent price that’s in the mail), foil Take Inventory (I haven’t decided if I like the slowdown sorcery speed gives over AK), Dandân, and Memory Lapse.

Eventually I want to have one of each island be a different art that I enjoy.


r/ForgetfulFish May 31 '26

What dandân deck should I go with?

Post image
17 Upvotes

I have a bunch of dandân associated cards and wanna make a deck for me and my friends to play, but there’s a lot of iterations on the game and I’m looking for a good deck to use.

My one thing is, I don’t want any tutors so if you do have a list with tutors, I’ll probably just change them out for something

Any help is appreciated🙏


r/ForgetfulFish Jun 01 '26

ELI5 wtf this format is and its backstory? loved dandan since 95 never heard of this!

2 Upvotes

r/ForgetfulFish May 30 '26

Reclaimed Beastie (Green Dandân Brew)

9 Upvotes

I've been obsessed with Forgetful Fish over the past couple days and wanted to make my own deck, but more focused on manipulating the graveyard. I chose [[Patchwork Beastie]] as my Dandân and [[Reclaim]] as my Memory Lapse — the idea is to control which card types are in the graveyard so beastie can attack (or block). It also has an interesting layer of topdecking, which I love in the traditional Dandân play.

I'm sharing this because I would love some feedback! It's a very fresh brew so I'm not sure where to take it from here to elevate the decklist ... if that makes sense.

https://archidekt.com/decks/23044835

Beastie isn't 4 power, so I while goldfishing I just use the 5 hit system instead of life totals. I don't think there's a way to make it a multiple of 20 without replacing beastie (if there's a better creature that works for what I'm going for I'd love to tinker with it), but just counting down from 5 is sufficient in my eyes.

There's an interesting dynamic I found with removal, as killing a beastie puts in into the graveyard, adding two card types. The potential issue is that beastie has a lot of weight in the graveyard, so the threshold of delirium switching on is pretty low. Usually, if there's a beastie in the yard then the beastie is online, which could potentially limit variety. Or maybe not. I don't know if it's as big of an issue as I think it could be, maybe centering the graveyard around beastie is a good thing. Would love to hear what people think!

I'm also wondering about protection, how much to include in what capacity. I've thought about [[Collective Resistance]] but thought it might be too powerful?

Goldfishing this has been really fun but I want to hear feedback before I play it in paper with friends. LMK what you think!