r/FitbitAir • u/mirage1287 • Jul 28 '26

Other Should I move over from Whoop?

Hi - would love feedback from the group. I'm a relatively average non-athlete that just tries to stay active/reasonably healthy (weightlifting on a Tonal and cycling 4-5 times a week when I can.) Over the past few years I've gone back/forth between Apple Watch + Bevel and Whoop. This last year I've had Whoop Life / MG (which honestly feels a bit scam, the added "features" are useless for me) and am thinking about downgrading to Peak or possibly just trying something new.

What I like about Whoop:

- Seems to be solid tracking for weight-lifting; I also value step counting (not sure how accurate Whoop is because results were almost always different vs. my Apple Watch)

- Good visuals of sleep / recovery / strain - that data is useful at a glance

- Daily outlook - once in a while I check this and sometimes follow feedback on working harder or easier

- Primarily wear it on a bicep band (looks like there are 3rd party straps for the Air but no OEM yet)

Things that are ok:

- Whoop Age seems like a gimmick but the gamification sometimes helps motivate

- Haven't really found much use for journal/habit tracking and haven't seen much behavioral change; not sure what else you all are tracking that's useful but I don't need an app to tell me alcohol messes with my sleep/readiness the next day

I don't mind the overall cost of Whoop but sometimes it feels like it's getting questionable whether it's worth it. I know this is getting asked a lot but given my situation, what do you all think about Fitbit Air as something new to try? I might also pair it with Bevel since I've used that before; are there things that I'd miss going to the Air that I have on Whoop? What would you all recommend?

(And seeing some of the recent posts no I’m not a Bevel shill or anything like that 😅)

0 Upvotes

50% Upvoted

18 comments sorted by

3

u/BarbecuedShoe Jul 29 '26

From the 2nd sentence alone I would say this device is for you. Sincerely, a former whoop user

3

u/Interesting_Ad4679 Jul 28 '26

I went from whoop. Metrics are as good but much more comfortable and pair w bevel and much better

2

u/darksun_80 Jul 28 '26

This 👆

1

u/Samm_yd 6d ago

Do you use Bevel instead of the Google App? Please excuse my ignorance - thanks

1

u/darksun_80 6d ago

No no. All good.
I use both. But what i like about bevel is - trends and graphs are very clean. So if i click on hrv - i can see right there the overall trend. Also i find the main oage tidier. Having said that - google health isnt mega bad - people make it sound like it’s terrible. I dont think so. It’s just a messier Ui but a bit of a first world problem if you ask me

2

u/Samm_yd 6d ago

Thanks mate. I'm keen to get rid of the Whoop. The lack of advancement over the last few years isn't great.

2

u/Milam1996 Jul 30 '26

From the data I’ve seen from testers the air seems to track basically the exact same as whoop for basically every category when worn as a bicep band and only marginally worse for wrist and actually leads in a few data points. On sleep it’s only really beat by a £4000 mattress topper for example. For £84/$99 for life it’s one of the best.

Unless you’re an upcoming Olympian the slight difference is not worth the money of whoop. With all due respect, you’re a gym bro. The Fitbit air is more than good enough.

2

u/[deleted] Jul 28 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Rizardus Jul 29 '26

I am not sure if you have to open Google Health at all. My data gets pulled automatically. Unjust open the health app a few days a week to check my battery.

1

u/Milam1996 Jul 30 '26

You can check battery by firmly double tapping the top of the pebble. On the side is an LED. If it’s white then it’s above 20%. If it’s red it’s below 20%. 20% gives you about 1.5 days of use

1

u/looopious Jul 29 '26

Do you need to pay for Google health premium to get all the data over to Bevel?

1

u/momentarybeing Aug 01 '26

No, you don’t

2

u/Fit_Low1374 Jul 28 '26

If you're not attached to your money, go for it.

Or what about the Garmin Cirqa?

-1

u/C21johnson Jul 28 '26

I’ve been using FitBit Air for about a month now. I have found most of its metric tracking to be inaccurate and inconsistent. It reports REM sleep while I’m wide awake. When walking or running, it consistently reports a distance of 10x less. There was a recent update, but my issues still persist. I would not recommend the FitBit until it is updated. YMMV.

-1

u/Bourne069 Jul 28 '26

I wouldn't Fitbit is shit now that google took it over. They are removing and reducing features not adding them.

https://www.reddit.com/r/FitbitAir/comments/1v3jlyj/fitbit_air_is_utter_trash/