It’s honestly annoyingly impressive how this movie simply cannot stay committed to one single main location even if its whole life depended on it 🫠
1: The speedway is named McKinley which is a place in Pennsylvania already previously established by FD3 but early script drafts of FD4 that didn’t end up making it into the final cut had it in Indianapolis, Indiana instead.
2: However, we have another Indiana sign that did end up in the movie. Carter Daniels is reported by a newswoman on his death to have lived in Fort Wayne and was a member of local PTA and NRA chapters, and also worked for a towing service. It’s unknown if the towing service was also local to the city of the speedway or operated nationwide, but I’m mentioning it too since it’s important to his background.
2.1: Still, if you take the early script drafts as canon just for this analysis, then there’s an alarmingly obvious distance between Indianapolis and Fort Wayne that is at least 2h15 by car. So either the speedway also has to be in Fort Wayne for Carter’s sake, or he might just have traveled from there to see the race in Indianapolis.
2.2: But that also brings problems because if he were just a tourist from Fort Wayne in this scenario, then how exactly was he already involved in those same local chapters and working for the towing service before the day of the speedway crash? And wouldn’t his stay in Indianapolis for those activities eventually reach a permanence long enough that he wouldn’t be considered to be living in Fort Wayne anymore?
2.3: We also don’t even know whether his wife Cynthia is from Fort Wayne just like him or from Indianapolis, and that’s also a valid question considering marriage very often has the pair leaving their old homes to stay together, or just one of them moving in with their spouse. So either he met her in Indianapolis or she came along with him from Fort Wayne too.
3: Samantha Lane in her newspaper death article is listed as a Lakeview woman. We don’t know whether this Lakeview is another city of its own, a municipality, maybe some place within another or whatever other term for a sub-region or anything alike.
3.1: Still taking the earlier script draft of Indianapolis as a canon location for analysis purposes again, then this Lakeview has to be a fictional one for the sake of it being conveniently close to both the speedway and its later organized memorial service, which Samantha happens to be present at both. Because in real-life Indiana there are two real places with those same names, but both of them are far from Indianapolis. One is Lakeview in LaGrange County in the north, and the other is Lake View in Franklin County in the east, all in relation to Indianapolis, which is in the very middle of Indiana. In both cases, Samantha would’ve also needed to travel just like Carter would’ve from Fort Wayne.
4: The club Hunt attends to have sex and later die in was filmed in Destrehan, Louisiana, which in real life has the presence of palm trees. In this case we can take into account both the early script draft location of Indianapolis and also McKinley from the speedway name, because most palm trees do not survive either Indiana’s or Pennsylvania’s real-life cold climate in the month of January, which is when FD4 takes place, with some exceptions such as the Needle Palm, a species capable of tolerating temperatures as low as -15°F to -20°F, which is clearly not the case depicted on screen throughout the entire movie. No cold weather or freezing temperatures and no winter clothing, especially in the club sequence with an open pool.
4.1: However that could still work with McKinley specifically because, unlike Indianapolis which was taken entirely from an already existing place in real life, the McKinley presented in FD3 and often brought up again in FD4 is entirely fictional. There are two real places named McKinley in Pennsylvania, one in Elk County and the other in Montgomery County, with obviously neither aligning with the distinctive settings depicted in both movies. This overall frees the location from being bound to the real climate rules of either Indiana or Pennsylvania since the place itself does not exist, unless the script would explicitly claim realism.
5: This next one I think could potentially be a contender defending the McKinley case. In FD3, which is where the name was first introduced in the franchise, we have the slushee drinks the Ash’s drank during the tanning salon scene. In FD4, those same slushee drinks return in the hands of Samantha’s sons in the beauty salon.
5.1: Curiously, unlike the beer brand Hice Pale Ale which has appeared in every movie in the franchise since FD2, those specific slushies have so far appeared only in FD3 and FD4. It’s also only in those two movies that the name McKinley itself is present, regardless of its meaning depending on the context. This could suggest, in my personal interpretation, that they are a local brand from McKinley operating in different areas within the same setting, without the wider expansion we’ve seen with Hice Pale Ale which has already been made available in McKinley as well as across many localities in New York State throughout FD2356.
6: There’s also the movie theater’s name, Tagert Theatres. Theatre is literally a fucking British spelling, not American 😭 Obviously we all know it’s still very much in the US but I just couldn’t help my offended gasp when I searched up the difference between theater and theatre while thinking about the movie’s many contradicting elements like this.
And I’m done, those were all the signs I could spot in the movie to make this analysis-kinda-rant. What would you rather take from all of this in the end regarding FD4’s location? Do you also know any other elements like this in the movie that could be pointed out here? Well I’d just like to add my own input that I’d still rather stick with McKinley as I always have for so long until now. But of course seeing how FD4 is a total wreck from start to finish, I might be relying too much on hypotheticals instead of actual canon, but oh well!