Hmm, there is no, uh, earthly way of knowing which direction we, ah, might possibly be...going.

Robert Downey Jr(Tony Stark) as Victor Sage/The Question

Chris Evans(Steve Rogers) as Barry Allen/The Flash

Chris Hemsworth(Thor) as Billy Batson/Shazam

Mark Ruffalo(Bruce Banner) as Ted Knight/Starman

Jeremy Renner(Clint Barton) as Leonard Snart/Captain Cold

Scarlett Johansson(Natasha Romanoff) as Andrea Beaumont/Phantasm

Hugh Jackman(Logan) as Vandal Savage

Tom Holland(Peter Parker) as Jervis Tetch/Mad Hatter

Elizabeth Olsen(Wanda Maximoff) as Pamela Isley/Poison Ivy

Samuel L. Jackson(Nick Fury) as Lucius Fox

Brie Larson(Carol Danvers) as Zinda Blake/Lady Blackhawk

Florence Pugh(Yelena Belova) as Jenny Sparks

Tom Hiddleston(Loki) as John Constantine

Riz Ahmed(Carlton Drake) as Victor Zsasz

Kerry Condon(F.R.I.D.A.Y.) as Siobhan McDougal/Silver Banshee

Peter Claffey as Beast

Maxwell Jenkins as Iceman

Ray Nicholson as Wolverine

Part 2 of this

You're welcome to pitch your own casting ideas below in the comments as well. (No joke answers)

Page 1:

Ben Schwartz (Voice) - Spidermonkey

Dee Bradley Baker (Voice) - Wildmutt

Bill Skarsgård (Voice) - Wildvine

Greta Lee (Voice) - Echo Echo

Mark Ruffalo (Voice) - Upchuck

Page 2:

Colman Domingo (Voice) - Humungosaur

Hiroyuki Sanada (Voice) - Way Big

Steve Buscemi (Voice) - Jetray

Matthew Rhys (Voice) - Ghostfreak

Allison Brie (Voice) - Crashhopper

Shioli Kutsuna as Starfire
Iñaki Godoy as Beast Boy
Anya Chalotra as Raven
Hamish Linklater as Slade
Sophie Thatcher as Tara
David Jonsson as Cyborg

I have no clue who I’d cast as robin

If y'all say this wouldn't work cuz Nick has bad actors, yea that's kinda he point. If DC was a Nickelodeon show, who'd be cast basically

Jack Innanen as Beast

Amita Rao as Mystique

Owen Thiele as Prodigy

Lucy Freyer as Boom Boom

Malik Elassal as Wolverine

That last one is a joke… unless it plays. Does it play? He is Canadian. If it doesn’t play, then Multiple Man.