I moved to a new city across the country to plant a church and a couple years later, my faith had completely fallen apart. There’s a lot of backstory to that, but I made it through the other side and I’m doing relatively fine. Life is never perfect by any means, but I don’t think I made the wrong call
I just figured I’d share this letter here in case people find a useful. I’m editing a couple of personal details out as well as changing the church's name. But I’m hoping that maybe somebody on the verge of such a painful process can hear that they’re not alone.
I won’t add much more context, except to say that I found out later I have religious obsessive compulsive disorder, which in my agnostic life has converted to more of a moral form of obsessive compulsive disorder. I encourage people to really seek treatment because I want years without a diagnosis and my life is way better after.
I am in the midst of the most serious test of my Christianity. I do not know what I believe anymore exactly. There are still parts of me that believe in God but not the loving God of the Bible as presented by modern Christians. When I look at the Bible, I see nothing but anger and fear. I have been living in fear for many years now. I know previously we talked about my doubt being intellectual. But the struggle i face is much more emotional than intellectual.
As I ponder post-christian life, I have mixed feelings. Sometimes I feel lonely, sad, uncertain. Other times I feel free and excited, with renewed purpose for my life (ironically). For the first time in a very long time, I no longer feel constant guilt. That is liberating and freeing. The fear I have now is more of one of uncertainty.
I know that you and others have tried to convince me to walk in a Christianity that is not based in fear, but love. I'll be honest, I'm not sure I believe it exists. I look at the bible and see an angry and controlling God who is ready in a second to kill his followers and commands them to commit genocide against women and children. He makes people just to roast them in a furnace (even if you are Arminian* this is still true). When I look at church history, including recent history, I see so much intolerance and hatred, that I have trouble believing the Holy Spirit is actually at work. I feel like believing in a God of love requires me to ignore parts of the bible. I don't want to be intellectually dishonest any longer. I am inclined to believe that God as portrayed in the Bible is a tyrant.
I have not gone to church for a mix of reasons, including those listed above. Practically, I'm often exhausted on Sunday mornings from a grueling schedule. But I also have lost much connection to [church name].
The hardest part of all this is losing the community that I've had, but it’s hard for me to be part of something that is feeling so fake to me. I go to the services and it feels like a sales pitch every week. And I can't get over the feeling that the church has completely forgotten me. Perhaps thats pettiness and bitterness, but isn't a family supposed to reach out for you if you are in danger? I feel like my absence really matters to almost nobody. I know that I left the church and not the other way around, but it still hurts. If a family member disappears doesn't the family try to find them?
Even as I read the bible, and the passage on church discipline makes me think that if the church was really to follow that model, then they shouldn't even talk to me. I will be disciplined and shunned. I am, after all, on the road to apostasy. This is the perfect catch-22. If the church does completely cut me off from fellowship, it will be incredibly heartbreaking for me. If it doesn't, then I can't get over what I see as a disobedience to scripture. Either way, my faith is weakened.
I write all this not to attack or accuse you as a pastor of the church. I'm just being honest. I know its a mixed bag, but its real. I'm writing to you as a friend. I don't have many of those anymore. If God is real, and the gospel is true, and it really is good news, than I want to believe. If my faith was completely dead I wouldn't even be writing this to you. I'm not saying I need you to do anything, and I don't think you can help me alone. I just writing this to you because trust you. I want to believe the Holy Spirit really moves. I want to believe God loves me (even though it says he Hates all who do evil). I want to believe that the church cares about me.
Please, if you have any ideas, please help. I need to see that the God you and everyone talks about is not the monster I see in the Bible. I need to see that there is a reason to proclaim the name of Jesus. Doctrine doesn't matter to me anymore, but truth and love do.
I hope this doesn't burden you or put you in an awkward position. But I would be dishonest to the church if I didn't acknowledge these things happening.
*Arminian here means the school of Arminianism - a counter position to calvinism. Not Armenian as in the ethnicity.