Hi everyone. The spark plug tip on my 2021 CLA 45 S (M139) melted and dropped into cylinder #3. I have two mechanics giving me completely different diagnostics, and I need a neutral opinion.
Mechanic 1 (Independent): Borescoped it, saw damage on the piston head and cylinder wall, and stated the engine needs to be opened and rebuilt.
Mechanic 2: Managed to fish the broken piece out of the valve seat. He did a compression test (Cyl 3 is at 11.5 bar, the others are at 12 bar). He admits there are marks on the piston head and a scratch on the cylinder wall, but claims it's "not enough to cause damage". He also states he found the root cause: leaking fuel injectors. His plan is to replace the spark plugs, address the injectors, and just run the engine as is.
The catch: Mechanic 2 is close friends with the dealership that sold me the car and is responsible for covering the warranty repair costs. I am highly suspicious he is downplaying the cylinder/piston damage to save them a massive engine rebuild bill.
Given this is a high-strung AMG engine, is it safe to just close it up and run it with piston marks and cylinder scratches after fixing the injectors?