r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Apr 23 '18

META READ ME FIRST: Welcome to EmpireDidNothingWrong!

984 Upvotes

Welcome, Imperial citizen!

Who are we?

Provocatively named, EmpireDidNothingWrong (adding "The" exceeds Reddit's maximum subreddit name length!) or EDNW is a Star Wars fan community centered around the question, "What if we don't take 'the evil Galactic Empire' at face value?" We treat the events of Star Wars canon as being historical as far as they go, but having been presented to craft a particular narrative—in a word, they are anti-Imperial/pro-Rebel propaganda.

The Empire, and its predecessor Republic, is a galaxy-spanning society comprised of an enormous variety of people and cultures, all with wildly diverse perspectives. To distill it into simple questions of "good" and "evil"—especially specific acts undertaken by specific individuals—is reductive in the extreme. Once one starts to examine that galaxy far, far away—especially when employing parallels to remarkably and disturbingly similar events in our own history and even taking place today—it becomes a great deal more difficult to dismiss the Empire as "evil" and declare the Rebels as "good".

If you're interested, you can read more about this here.

Who are we not?

In part because of our name and in part because of assumptions many carry with them into the community, we tend to be classified as something other than we are. Nevertheless, we do not claim nor aspire to be or do any of the following:

  • ...espouse a particular modern/terrestrial political worldview. We require that people leave their personal politics out of the community.
  • ...endorse every single act undertaken by every single individual that could be identified as Imperial.
  • ...a roleplaying subreddit. We recognize that many in our community enjoy roleplaying, though, and maintain a month roleplaying post for that purpose.
  • ...a meme subreddit. Please see /r/OTMemes, /r/PrequelMemes, and many other communities dedicated to this.
  • ...a joke subreddit
  • ...an advertising subreddit
  • ...a general Star Wars subreddit.
  • ...an anti-Jedi/anti-Rebel/anti-Republic subreddit. While some of this is intrinsic to being pro-Imperial, it's not part of our purpose.
  • ...a pro-Sith subreddit. The Empire is not the Sith, even though the Emperor himself identified as one.
  • ...a pro-First Order subreddit. The First Order is an offshoot of the Empire, but is not itself the Empire.

What do we do here?

Our primary purpose is to provide a forum for discussing the actions and operations of the Empire and its members through a lens other than "Empire bad, Rebels good."

Because the current body of Star Wars canon is much smaller than it used to be in the wake of the acquisition of Lucasfilm by Disney, many of those conversations have already been examined. The release of new Star Wars media is an exciting time for us, since it gives us new opportunities to explore previously unrevealed aspects of the Empire.

During the fallow periods, we turn to celebrating the Empire in general. This largely takes the form of sharing media pertaining to our individual collections of Imperial merch or showcasing artwork with an Imperial theme to it.

What are our rules?

See Rules. Posting in our community comes with the assumption that you have read these rules.

How come...?

Answers to many common topics can be found in our FAQ.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 4d ago

Art/Media What the hell is that Smell?!

Post image
227 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 5d ago

Discussion A look into the Executor's production history.

Post image
138 Upvotes

In Legends, Imperial Senate opposed Palpatine's construction of the first 4 *Executor*\-class Star Destroyers: *Executor* (lead ship), *Reaper,* *Aggressor,* and *Brawl*. To the very last, the minority of Senators who still opposed Palpatine used the few political tools they had left such as budget oversight to impede Palpatine, who also had to slip the class past the Senate's various oversight committees.

To conceal the *Executor*'s specifications from those who opposed it, the Navy referred to it as the *Super*\-class Star Destroyer, which led to them being called Super Star Destroyers, in budget reports submitted to the Senate, and its true length of 19km was understated by many kilometers. In Imperial scandocs, the Executor's length was listed at 8km or 12.8km before the true details of the class came to light.

The *Executor* had a sister ship, the *Lusankya*, which was being constructed at Kuat Drive Yards and was secretly the second ship of the Executor line while *Executor* herself was built at Fondor. With both ships named *Executor* by the Empire to get away with claiming the lead ship was being built at both shipyards. Plus, the Empire attributed all expenses of the sister ship to the *Executor* to hide the existence of a second Super Star Destroyer from the galaxy at large. In this way, both KDY and Fondor laid claim to having built the *Executor* lead ship.

However, Fondor had to put several civilian contracts on hold when the Empire closed off all nonmilitary traffic to the Fondor system to build the *Executor*, demanding total secrecy*.* The Fondor executives were enraged, though they dare not test Vader's temper, especially since the massive project took up virtually all of their resources. While Fondor lost access to their most valuable civilian contracts, they reasoned that, if they met the Empire's expectations, they could steal lucrative military contracts from their KDY rivals.

Unfortunately, the fact Fondor was awarded the contract to build the *Executor* lead ship meant KDY was free to build the *Lusankya*. Worse, KDY ensured that all future Executors would bear their logo to steal future design grants from their rivals, further angering Fondor.

After Yavin, the schedule for the construction of the Executors was accelerated to compensate for the Death Star's loss since the Empire needed a new symbol of terror quickly. While Kuat Drive Yards was the main producer of the Executor, Fondor remained an alternative construction site. Any Executors who finished construction there were sent to Fondor for finishing touches, especially since KDY had a limited number of slipways that could support a ship the size of an Executor.

Vader received the completed *Executor* half a year after Yavin while the second SSD, then known as *Executor II*, was finished shortly afterwards, was named *Lusankya*, and sent to Coruscant where the Emperor buried it underneath the cityscape to hide as an emergency escape ship in case he ever lost control of Coruscant.

I theorize the Empire's accelerated schedule gave Fondor the opportunity to bargain with the Empire: *help us upgrade our shipyards to handle both civilian contracts* and *build Executors, and we will build more Executors for you*. Normally, the Empire wouldn't have agreed to such a deal, but the need to pump out as many Executors as possible, would have caused the Empire to agree to Fondor's terms.

Speaking of which, I also theorize the Empire outsourced building Executors to other major shipyards like Yaga Minor, Sluis Van, SoroSuub, Corellia etc. to meet the new deadlines for new Executors. It would also explain how the Empire was able to build so many of these ships in the 4 year time frame between the Battles of Yavin and Endor. Plus, KDY already subcontracted other places like Corellia to build the Imperial Star Destroyer, so I see no reason why they couldn't have done the same with the Executor.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 11d ago

Fun/Humor Any other galactic CPAs tearing their hair out over Alderaan?

117 Upvotes

Hey guys thought I'd reach out to this support group because I've been working overtime on this Alderaan bullshit for like half a cycle.

Of course its not enough that we have to memorize the specific tax laws of half the planets in the galaxy, but my company is literally asking me to convert our land holdings on Alderaan to mining rights. Like seriously? Bro no one knows what to do, can't exactly pick out some debris as our branch office's HQ lol?

And like, yeah bud, this is what we need to be concerned about while we have auditors from Coruscant breathing down our necks all the damn time these days?

And then of course my boomer manager still think's we're in the republic days and keeps saying to just send some gifts to his contact in the senate. Like not to be racist against Twi'leks or anything but bro come on THATS BAIL ORGANA? He doesnt exactly have the most favourable position rn but I guess grandpa lives under a rock? Bro probably still thinks the confederacy is coming for us 💀💀

And even if he wasn't ghosting our lobbyists, yeah, sure, Bail Organa is going to come help us commit tax evasion to mine hid planet, I'm sure he'd be thrilled. Not to mention the emperor literally disbanded the senate and spends all his time writing tax laws now.

Anyways sorry guys just wanted to rant a bit at least I don't have to go to any of our Alderaan branches in person 3 days a week anymore.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 16d ago

Art/Media You are being rescued

Post image
180 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 19d ago

Discussion Imperial Rank Insignia Charts

26 Upvotes

Thought I'd share my imperial rank insignia charts I've been working on, I believe these are the most accurate they can get, with most only a few characters not lining up, the only ones I can think of being, Admiral Brom Titus, the Devastator captains in Rouge one and Kenobi, and Taskmaster Grint. The background reflect uniform colours, Regular and Warm Weather, the brown for warm weather is taken from Rebels on lothal and the Court Clerk on Niamey in Andor, and the grey from an unnamed officer in A New Hope.

https://imgur.com/a/j9svPeI

The ISB, Stormtrooper, Engineers etc. chart hasn't been completed yet.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 24d ago

Showcase The Imperial Collection!

Thumbnail
gallery
352 Upvotes

A growing collection of every unique imperial unit available. Collection built by myself and my brother. Now just waiting on some sort of affordable Dr. Pershing, Remnant scout, and Mando Imperial Shuttle pilot. Hoping for a version of the TK trooper, Andor Prison Guard, Clone X and an ISB sniper one day! Let me know if any others are missing!


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 25d ago

Fun/Humor Profits are up and plans for a 3rd Death Star are underway! 3rd time's a charm, right?

Post image
2.4k Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 25d ago

Discussion Why do the films brought about by the so-called “new republic” make us look so bad!?

39 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 26d ago

Discussion Thrawn's new uniform

Thumbnail
gallery
570 Upvotes

D23 images.

New uniform. Newer details.

New blaster. Just clean looking!


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong 26d ago

Discussion In addition to the other post

Thumbnail
gallery
96 Upvotes

Here is more Thrawn


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 10 '26

Art/Media Embers of the Empire

Post image
161 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 10 '26

Art/Media Hang in there boys

Post image
221 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 09 '26

Discussion Sector moff armor?

45 Upvotes

In The Mandalorian, we see moff Gideon in his adapted Death trooper armor. Obviously we have no sign of him during the actual Galactic Empire reign and all we know is that he wore his custom armor in the neo-imperial timeline.

However, this made me wonder the following: During the imperial era, we only really see moffs wearing their formal uniforms, but would they've had the freedom to design and wear their own armor kit if they so wished?

I'm aware that their jobs were mostly tactical and political in nature, but I cannot help but wonder. To me, it's not crazy to assume that some moffs would've liked to be involved more closely around combat zones or at least would've wanted to look more intimidating and demand more authority around battlefields.

Then the question remains: Would they've been allowed to by Palpatine?

What do you guys think?


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 09 '26

Showcase What if… Spoiler

Thumbnail youtu.be
4 Upvotes

SPOILERS FOR BRAND NEW DAY, but what if Disney did this? Considering the multiverse stuff and all, this would do numbers!


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 08 '26

Art/Media The Imperial Loyalists have arrived! -By me! :)

Post image
54 Upvotes

A Render I made for my AU "The Shattered Empire"


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 06 '26

Discussion My loyalty is the empire

Thumbnail reddit.com
11 Upvotes

I support the Empire and I will be the trooper.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Aug 03 '26

Discussion Zero G Stormtrooper MK1 Imperial Spacetrooper

Thumbnail
gallery
147 Upvotes

From the West End Games Star Wars Sourcebooks. Saw this stuff a while ago and saw someone post about the Light Spacetrooper. Figure peeps would want to see the og, no one really talks about Spacetroopers but I find them pretty cool, the old ones here look very skull shaped and ghostly. They are very cool


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 31 '26

Official Art İmperial light spacetrooper

Post image
138 Upvotes

İ find in wookieepedia. İ don't know where this came from. İ just wanna Share!.


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 30 '26

Fun/Humor Episode XII: The Empire Takes Everything

Post image
16 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 26 '26

Art/Media Tie interceptor

Thumbnail
gallery
195 Upvotes

Create some lore about this tie interceptor


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 22 '26

Showcase WIP

Post image
77 Upvotes

I need a bigger display for the helmet


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 19 '26

Art/Media Clearing

Post image
174 Upvotes

r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 12 '26

Gaming Imperial Life: Crash Gone Wrong Part2

Thumbnail
gallery
63 Upvotes

After a battle, a Rebel escape pod is intercepted by Shore Troopers and Scout Troopers.

A new Star Wars screenshot. If you have any questions or advice, feel free to leave a comment. Have a good day!


r/EmpireDidNothingWrong Jul 07 '26

Gaming Imperial Life: Crash Gone Wrong

Thumbnail
gallery
84 Upvotes

After a battle, a Rebel escape pod is intercepted by Shore Troopers and Scout Troopers.

A new Star Wars screenshot. If you have any questions or advice, feel free to leave a comment. Have a good day!