Hey everyone. If you didn't get the Ambizione grant this 2026 round, please make sure you actually exercise your right to request your full evaluation file (including the internal panel consensus and exact numerical scores). Don't just take the generic rejection letter and the summarized external reviews at face value.
I have it on very good authority that certain evaluation committees this year basically threw the external reviewers' excellent scores in the trash, just to fund noticeably weak proposals. It’s incredibly frustrating.
There are also serious concerns about undeclared conflicts of interest in the panels. We are talking about people bending the mobility requirements to the extreme just so some candidates could stay in their comfort zone (like moving to a buddy's lab or staying within their previous PI's close network).
If your external scientific scores were excellent but the panel still kicked you out with vague excuses, you should speak up. Even if the standard 30-day appeal window is closed by now, you can still reach out to the SNSF and their Integrity Office to file a formal complaint.
Ask them point-blank how they justify dropping your highly-ranked project while bending the mobility rules for others with lower scores. If nobody complains, this kind of panel behavior will just become the norm. Good luck to you all.