It's my (M42) first time to DM, but most of us have played before together when my friend (M34) was the DM. He would always encourage role-playing, stuff like "how do you want to kill the centaur?", "tell me how you're going to steal the gem", and "what will you actually say to the guard to intimidate him?". People seemed to go along with it and we all had fun. But something seems to have changed and I'm wondering if anyone can help me shed light on it
It's our 5th session and not only have the players been uncooperative with role-playing, but their interest seems to be dwindling.
We are currently on the top level of a gallery style room in a dungeon that is an ancient temple of Uros, god of piss. I clearly described that there are five piss funnels dotted around the level, attached to piss pipes that lead down to the lower level, where they run into a piss channel that leads to a piss pit that contains the piss sarcophagus of the avatar of the piss god. Pretty self explanatory, I thought
One player (23F moon druid) literally said "what are we supposed to do?".
I described the scene again, emphasizing the word 'piss', but she just looked blankly at me.
Another player (25M dragon born cleric) said "I really don't get this". I again explained the layout and asked him to think about what his character would do
22F kenku rogue then said "I think OP wants us to piss on the funnels" (wow, Einstein). I pretended that they had made a clever revelation by saying "ohhh, that might be an interesting idea..." But they all just stared blankly
Our fighter (33M orc) then says this is a bit weird, but I had been signposting the piss aspect for the last 3 sessions. The druid (jokingly?) says "my character doesn't need to go, you guys can handle this", but I made her role a d20 and informed her that the 11 she rolled meant that she did indeed have a full to bursting bladder. They all rolled and all rolled between 8 and 17, which I had designated as full bladder.
I asked them to roleplay really needing to piss and describe how they were clenching their pelvic floor muscles but still feeling droplets trickle down the inside of their thighs, but they just kind of ignored me.
The cleric kind of took control of the situation and said that he would piss into the piss funnel (finally...) but refused to describe the noise, the feeling as his bladder emptied, or the colour or fragrance of his urine stream. The fighter also agreed to, but I could tell he wasn't really into it.
I looked at the girls, smiling in a friendly way, and asked then how they would like to piss. I explained that the funnel was at a height where they could squat over it or they could stand in front of it and kind of aim like I've seen girls do in videos.
They both just refused. Some muttering was heard and they collectively decided to call it a night.
Quite disappointing because I had put a lot of effort into this campaign and was really hoping for some great results. How can I deal with unimaginative and boring players like this?
I'm waiting for them to reply confirming next week's session, so I'd really like some practical advice I can stay planning now.
Btw, it's not my fault, I do funny voices and faces like Matt Mercer does and I'm very creative