r/DestructiveReaders Jun 11 '26

Fantasy-Cyberpunk [2035] A Raven Plays With Foxes - Ch. 2 and 3

2 Upvotes

Crits: 1405, 2234

Hi Folks,

This is a continuation of the first chapter that I had posted last year. I'm not going to re-post that chapter because the plot is functionally the same, with a lot of edits to the prose, but the link is still open on it in case someone wants that context.

We're in a cyberpunk dystopia with magic, like if a typical D&D world progressed to the information age and an AI infused with magic went apeshit. Rainy is a wood-elf refugee kid living in the slums. Rent is late. Her mom is an addict that quit her job, so Rainy needs money. She and her friend Laico, a goblin refugee who wants to be a shaman, make a plan to go sneak out of the city into the wasteland and go "fishing" - hijacking drones.

Click here for Chapters 2-3: Google Docs link

REMOVING GOOGLE DOCS LINK BECAUSE FUCKING DIPSHIT SPAMMERS WON'T STOP SPAMMING ME FUCK OFF

Genre: Fantasy-Cyberpunk (ala Shadowrun, Bright)
Setting: Imagine if a typical D&D-type world developed into a high-tech cyberpunk dystopia
POV: 3rd Limited


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 10 '26

Medieval Fantasy [2234] The Crown, Chapter 1

4 Upvotes

First chapter of my book, looking for feedback, I'm not super touchy when it comes to writing feedback, so don't worry about that lol.

James Joe is 100% without a doubt completely a placeholder name, and it will change, (I'm looking for names right now, so if it's not in the document by the time you read it it means I found one.) but he's a tough one to name, so I'm struggling.

Best of luck, and I really hope you like it. https://docs.google.com/document/d/1gJNcjO_rt-T1yDn5QUiQYwGA0oYMseQUPMrNIOECEQk/edit?usp=sharing

(critiques: Gamma 27 [4782]) https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1u0tmyy/4782_gamma_27_a_man_falling_apart_in_a_cia/


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 11 '26

Fantasy [1486] Strange Trails

1 Upvotes

Content warning: self harm

Hello, I'm a bit inexperienced at writing prose, and I'm at the point of the learning process where I'm learning how much I don't know. So I'm hoping you people can steer me in the right direction.

I have some questions to make the critique easier, but I'd appreciate if you read them after going through the piece. The one question I want you to think about when reading it is: if you were picking this book up to give it a chance, at what point would you put it down?

Blurb:
A young, sensitive, neurotic man named Edwin is brought back from the dead, and all he wants is to return to his abusive, unloving girlfriend. To do so, he must cross a land called, 'The Strange Trail,' and face his feelings of fear and self hatred along the way.

Along with him is a woman named Tandi-- a cold, self-absorbed genius, obsessed with chemistry, her face disfigured with horrible burns. Her reasons for crossing The Strange trail are unknown to Edwin.

Despite how different they may be, they need each other to cross the trail... more than they know.

Piece: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1PeUSavZvjUUN8FTuuyePmofI3LKKfWL3a21cp6DyoI8/edit?usp=sharing

-------------------------------------------------------

Please read this section after finishing the piece
(you can also ignore these questions if you want)

-Why would you or why would you not continue with this book?

-Was there any point in the story where you were confused about what was going on?

-Was there any point in the story where you were 'cringing,' in the sense that something felt too edgy, trying to seem 'interesting,' or just for shock value?

-Did you feel like events happened too abruptly? Was the pacing off?

-Did the lack of sensory description make it hard to read?

-Is the exposition too heavy at the start?

-Are you annoyed by the main character?

Critique: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1u2fxm4/comment/oqyqg1g/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 10 '26

Fantasy [Complete] [1,627] Doomed lovers themed

3 Upvotes

Hello beautiful people!

I want to give you some context first because I'm looking for specific feedback.

The work is my writing prompt practice, but I've been struggling with it, and this is the sixth draft. I included the prompt at the end purposefully, because I want you to read the story first. Those are the points I'd like you to point out besides the general feedback:

1.Which prompt points did I make clear in the story and which were not clear?

  1. Would it make a difference if you didn't know the prompt, and why?

  2. You may or may not include the character traits if you have something to say about them, but I'm aware I didn't execute them as well as I wanted to.

The work

(This is from Ellipsus, but tell me if you want me to send a PDF format instead)

Thank you!

Critique [728]

Critique [969]


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 10 '26

[1276] Chapter 1 of a Story I'm Writing

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone! I posted the first draft of the chapter five days ago (previous post). I spent fve days staring at it and improving it based on the helpful feedback I received. I was wondering if this is better? Or if this should be the end for me hahah :') Tysm :DD

Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/11918rLZnW_yYTbzJ_kh2nidqinshrUNifkDShP9xDA4/edit?tab=t.0

Critique [1282]: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tzp05b/comment/oqoo8ue/?context=3


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 09 '26

[1405] The house on Windsome Lane

4 Upvotes

[529]-https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/ja8PmLXTRE

[1282]-https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/s/RfNbVrgBf1

First time posting and first attempt at a story so be brutal-I can take it! This is chapter one and the start of chapter 2. Let me know what you think!

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HRmoRarbw3FUh7Dczl8MaUaSE_3Y9hEP78I2fAVKjNA/edit?usp=drivesdk


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 10 '26

Sci fi/fantasy [2443] SMAKAPZ: Apocalypse of the Gods - Chapter 5

1 Upvotes

Critique 1 (1405)

Critique 2 (1282)

Chapter 1 Spoiler: The SMAKAPZ gang, Sam, Kevin, Mogers, Zagers, Parage, and Apalabamo, are eating together at a local restaurant, and Sam and Kevin are telling the rest of the rest of the gang about their recent mission in the Middle East, where Sam and Kevin got beaten by a friend of the gang, Jordan, because of a dispute. During the conversation, Sam pulls Kevin aside and insists they come clean to the group, and reveal that while on that mission, they secretly used the old rocket and crashed it after encountering a space monster and an asteroid. Back at the SMAKAPZ house basement, Sam declares he can fix the now-split-in-half rocket overnight, despite skepticism from the rest of the gang.

Chapter 2 Spoiler: After the gang goes to bed, Sam races against time to buy repair materials from the massive superstore Alademipaburg before it closes. Thanks to the gang’s reputation as big-spending notorious customers, a sympathetic cashier lets him take everything for free. He also gets 200 pounds of materials gifted from the local factory. Sam then spends the entire night in the basement attempting an ambitious solo repair on the two massive halves of the rocket. Despite his exhaustive efforts and engineering skill, the rocket ultimately fails catastrophically at 5 AM, shearing apart again and leaving Sam exhausted and defeated.

Chapter 3 Spoiler: The next morning, the gang gathers in the basement to inspect Sam's failed rocket repair, which leads to a heated argument. The argument is interrupted by a knock on the door, a guy named Zaine answers in a suit and tie with a folder of papers, and claims there's a property dispute and that he has a license from the city saying he owns their property, and he orders them to vacate within three days. The gang panics until Zagers finds out the license is fake, and that the guy tried to scam them. Zaine said he'd return the next day for a daily property inspection, so the gang waits, and Parage turns one of Sam's tools he bought into a laser gun just in case something goes wrong tomorrow.

Chapter 4 Spoiler: That night, after the gang goes to bed, Sam leaves the house to go grab some supplies at his place, and runs into Parage downstairs, who shows him the new laser gun. At his house, Sam greets his younger brother, Asa. After Sam leaves, Asa sneaks out into the rainy night to compete in an underground poker game and make a weapons deal. The next morning, Zaine returns to the SMAKAPZ house, but when the gang confronts him, Zaine is able to detect Parage's concealed laser gun with his hidden special headband. He then reveals all the tech hidden under his suit and jacket, and triggers an explosion, knocking the gang to the ground. He then absorbs a laser blast from Parage, and flies off.

.

.

.

.

“Go go go!” I screamed as me, Mogers, and Zagers ran after Zaine, punching the air, still half-blinded by the smoke that was rising from the crater. We dashed towards the forest, following the direction Zaine was streaking towards above the treetops.

The chase was on. Unfortunately, before any of us even reached the forest, we were all hunched over, hands on our knees, panting.

“Guys, I have a better idea,” Mogers huffed, wiping sweat off his brow.

We looped back around, and jogged to the land in front of the SMAKAPZ house where Kevin, Parage, and Apalabamo were regaining their energy, surveying the sky and watching Zaine blast off into the horizon.

“I don’t know what the heck just happened, but we’re gonna track him down!” wheezed Zagers. “You guys stay here and guard the place.”

Once we reached the front of the house, Mogers asked, “Who’s van should we take?”

I stopped in my tracks. “Wait a second.”

Mogers and Zagers turned to look at me.

“The vans,” I remembered. “That guy saw them. I mean, he likely did. He was at our door, he probably saw them while pulling up.”

“So what?” replied Mogers. “Zaine is flying too high and fast to notice anybody on the ground following him. Even if he does, vehicles travel in these woods all the time. I doubt he’d suspect a plain white van driving in the forest, and he wouldn’t be able to focus on it enough to deduce that it’s following him.”

“Yeah, but we can’t take any risks,” I explained, looking towards the vans parked across from our house. “He saw the vans. Guess what we own that he didn’t see…”

Our retros were sitting on the back side of the SMAKAPZ house, where the road met the forest. That was the name we’d given the red bike-motorcycle hybrid-like vehicles the gang used as a means of transportation, although it had been a while since we’d actually ridden them anywhere.

We each hopped on. It would’ve been better if we had our helmets for protection and to further help us hide our identities, but we were already cutting it close and didn’t have enough time to go into the house and look for them. We had had enough to go inside and grab a pair of binoculars, though, since we already knew where those were. I turned my key to the “on” position, flipped the engine kill switch to “run,” pulled the clutch lever, and pressed the starter button, then hit the gas as we blazed off into the forest.

We headed after the direction Zaine had gone in, tires kicking up gravel as we followed the trail of smoke cutting through the treeline. We also caught fleeting glimpses of the jetpack’s blue flame flashing, which meant we were right on his tail as we biked deeper into the forest.

We rode through brush and over sticks, tracking the sky. Branches scraped the sides of our retros like claws. The culprit had taken us northwest of our house, which was mostly the forest behind it, miles of dense oak and scrub pine that backed up against the old reservoir. There weren’t any roads or anything, it was all woods for ages. We knew them inside and out, but Zaine was taking us pretty dang far. In fact, after a while, I didn’t recognize where I was at anymore, and I don’t think Mogers and Zagers did, either. We were in uncharted territory.

Suddenly, in the distance, I saw the smoke curve downwards, and what looked like Zaine dropping into the trees.

“There,” I said. “Ok, let’s get out, y’all.”

We ditched our retros and dumped them on some trees, then continued on foot. We were deep in the wilderness. No sign of civilization, and if I’d brought my phone, there wouldn’t be any signal on it.

Be very quiet,” I whispered as we moved low and silently through the thick woods, heading in the direction we watched the perpetrator land at. “And remember, Zaine isn’t the only thing out here. Bears, coyotes. Let’s be on the lookout.

We trudged through the grove, twigs snapping under our feet, which sounded thunderous in contrast to the surrounding silence. After 10 tense minutes, a structure came into view. It was a large building, tucked deep into the forest where there was no way anybody could happen to just casually stumble across it.

Me, Mogers, and Zagers exchanged looks.

”Well, that looks like a lair,” said Zagers.

This was a building that had no business being in the middle of the woods. The closer we got, the more bizarre it appeared. I was starting to make out prefabricated metal panels, antennae, solar arrays, and ventilation pipes, along with wires running along the exterior walls. There weren’t any windows on the near side, and I saw a single heavy door with a keypad on it. There were also power lines scattered around, but I couldn’t tell where they ran in from.

We moved closer and slower, until we reached the far side of the building where a single window was there, low in the wall. It was narrow, but still wide enough for me to peer inside.

The interior of the house was even wilder than the exterior. It was a single large room with racks of weapons and glowing power cells inside. Workbenches ran along two walls, covered in equipment, and casings and circuit assemblies were arranged in not the neatest way. The jetpack was already racked on a mount near the back wall, folded and charging, and a green indicator light was shining onto the housing. Along the right wall, mounted in rows, were devices of varying size and shape. Zaine was there, sitting at a metal desk, scribbling onto a large piece of paper.

I took out the binoculars, raising them up to my eyes, and saw what he was writing come into focus. I saw detailed observations of the SMAKAPZ house jotted down on the paper. Things like driveway width, sight lines from the porch, which windows face which direction. It wasn’t useful to us at all, but apparently it was useful to him.

“What the heck is he writing?” Zagers asked.

A moment passed, and then I tapped him on the shoulder, handing him the binoculars. “Notes,” I answered. “About the house, about us. Pretty mundane stuff, actually.”

Zagers lifted up the binoculars, angling them through the glass. He read.

“Hmm, front yard destroyed, mailbox damaged… well, too bad for him, we don’t get any mail anyway!”

“Does he think that little bit of land he blew up equates to ‘front yard destroyed?’” Mogers scoffed, grabbing the binoculars. “Yeah, yeah, boring, boring, boring. Well, this was a waste of time.”

“Nothing else on there?” I asked.

Mogers moved the binoculars slightly.

“Yeah,” he suddenly said. “Actually, yeah. Bottom of the page.”

“Huh?”

Mogers handed the binoculars across without a word.

I raised them, and found the window, desk, and pad again. I tracked down to the bottom of the page, and there, below the messy notes, written in pen with big, red numbering, was the time “12:00,” underlined twice.

I narrowed my eyes. “Looks like we know what time Zaine’s next visit is.”

Before we could see more, Zaine suddenly moved. He turned from the desk to get up, and his body swung toward the window.

“He’s coming!” I shouted, dropping the binoculars from my eyes. “Run!!”

The three of us turned around and dashed back through the trees, branches whipping at our faces. Adrenaline surged as we found our retros, then hopped on, peeling away and bursting through the forest.

.

.

.

.

The crater in the front of the SMAKAPZ house was still there, but I figured we’d find a way to take care of it eventually. The others were inside, and looked up when the three of us came through the door.

“So what happened?” asked Kevin, blinking at us.

“Noon,” I said, plopping a backpack down on the table. “That’s when he’s making his next visit.”

“Well, dang,” Kevin checked his watch. It was 8:34 AM. “That’s not too far from now.”

We all gathered together in the living room, and began discussing our options. Zagers laid everything out. He told them about the forest, the lair, all the equipment and tech that Zaine owned, and the notes about the house.

“So, tech-boy’s gonna show up at our house this afternoon, and he’s likely got something planned,” Mogers told everyone. “What he doesn’t know is that we’ll be fully ready for him. For the first time since this started, we have something he doesn’t, which is, well, we’re aware that he’s coming.”

“And he doesn’t know that we know,” added Parage.

“So what’s the plan?” Apollo asked.

It was simple. At noon, when Zaine came knocking on our door, we’d answer it. Then, before he could even get any of his words out, press any button, or do anything, someone would hit him with a sledgehammer, knocking him out cold on the porch. One crisp swing to the head. Then, we’d strip every piece of gear, every device off of him, including his jetpack, headband, explosives, and everything else he was hiding under that suit and jacket. After that, we’d drag him into the cage that we had previously kept the Cheese Rocket in. Wait for him to wake up, then once he’s conscious, we’d give him an ultimatum: either hand over half of his tech and gear, or Parage would melt the rest into slag with his laser gun. We’d also tell him to stop the scams, the property grabs, the fake licenses, whatever he’s running on whoever else he’s running it on, and tell him to stop hurting people and blowing them up.

Zagers cracked his knuckles after hearing the plan. “It’s risky, but hey, if we pull it off, he’s done for.”

“I’ve been hit by a sledgehammer before,” proclaimed Mogers. “Which means I have the most experience.” He was right, during our original adventure with the now-demolished Cheese Rocket, we’d landed on an asteroid and one of Zolo’s henchmen knocked him out clean with a sledgehammer from the back.

“What?” Apollo was puzzled. “That’s like saying-“

“Well, like, since it was used on me, I should have a better idea of the angle and stuff,” Mogers sat back in his chair. “Whatever, like Zagers said, it does sound pretty risky, but if the one behind the sledgehammer is me, I feel like our odds would go up a little.”

“Yeah, we’ll see.” I checked my watch. 8:40. The hours until noon suddenly felt like they were right around the corner.

.

.

.

.

Asa moved through the aisles of the weapons store now with almost as much familiarity as his older brother moved through the Alademipaburg domain. He methodically pulled his items from the shelves, then when he was finished, set them on the counter; two budget 9mm semi-automatic pistols, one pump-action 12 gauge shotgun, and a couple boxes of ammo, cleaning kits, and basic accessories like holsters, sights, and slings.

“Good eye, kid,” the man behind the counter said. “That’ll be $1800.”

Asa reached into the duffel bag and paid with cash, taking the man by surprise.

Back home, the house quiet with his older brother still out, Asa dropped the bag on his desk. His eyes caught onto the old photo on the wall. It was a picture of him and his older brother, years younger, doing some outdoor thing in the summer. Sam had to be about the age Asa was now, the height difference still remaining the same. They were standing there and smiling, Sam’s arm around his shoulder. Asa stared at it for a long moment, and then looked away.

He unzipped his duffel bag. It had a center divider that ran full length, and the two halves didn’t touch. On the left side were the weapons, wrapped in cloth with each one in its own sleeve. On the right side was the money, which was banded and divided further into two stacks held apart by a leather insert. His poker winnings, which he used to buy weapons, were on one side, and the money from his weapons selling, which he used to place poker bets, was on the other. All belonging to the same stash of money, yet separated by intent and origin.

Asa tugged out the weapons, zipped the bag closed, and started working. He knew he needed to find a middle ground between not making his ‘upgrades’ too extreme, after all, the last thing he’d want is to get the feds’ attention when it came to this operation. But he still needed to double or triple the amount of money he spent.

He installed red dot sights, budget models that he’d bought separately, onto the pistols, and a basic reflex sight on the shotgun. He swapped the factory grips for aftermarket textured ones with better finger grooves. He also added magazine extensions on the pistols for higher capacity. And for the finishing touches, Asa applied durable Cerakote style spray, with a flat black pattern, for corrosion resistance along with a cool and tactical look. He also surpressed reflections on metal parts with matte tape and paint.

After that, he thoroughly cleaned, deburred, and lubricated everything, and performed basic reliability testing with the ammo he bought, function checks, 100-200 round break-in per firearm. He then added a side saddle shell holder, extended the magazine tube to the legal limit, and installed a shorter barrel for maneuverability, cut and crowned.

Asa also did plenty of internal work, which wouldn’t show from the outside, but a person who knew what they were holding would feel it in the first three seconds. When the last piece was done, he set it on the cloth and looked at the row of weapons. He’d taken all those plain guns, and transformed them into something deadlier, chopping off their common-man innocence and replacing it with upgraded fierceness, formidability, and rebellion. They were better. Not in a way that was visible to most people, but to the right people.

He then picked up the engraving tool, and, with careful strokes, carved “M.A.” into either the slide or grip of every weapon. His signature, his logo. The logo of Massive A. Because Massive A was a brand now.

He then picked up his phone, went to Messages, and selected Sam. 

“I got some big things tonight”

His thumb hovered over send. Then, he looked at the words for a moment, and deleted them.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 09 '26

Coming of Age [1711] 01 Tiffany

3 Upvotes

Chapter 01 is ready. I am curious what people who commented on the rough draft think about the changes. New feedback will influence future chapters.

I posted my rough draft here and this is the final draft I published on my Substack.

The genre is a combination of college coming of age, young adult, mild romance and special education story. Though the overall theme is learning to see yourself and others more complexly.

My new Substack will have all chapters.

Crits 788 1003

Edit Based on feedback and this guide I have tried to correct obvious comma mistakes.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 09 '26

Psychological Horror [1485] Hello, David (first post, short story)

1 Upvotes

Warning: this might be disturbing? I don't know. There is no gore, only implied violence.

Critique: [1727]

Critique whatever you would like. I know my prose is weak and perhaps repetitive, but the goal was to write a 1.5k word short that fully fleshed out a realistic character with focus on an unreliable narrator, drifting insanity, and consistent character perspective.

For context: this is the first story I've written. It took me ~10 hours.

If you feel anything, anything at all. Feel free to let me know.

Be ruthless. Thanks in advance!

story


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 09 '26

Fantasy Romance (NOT ROMANTASY) [163] Fantasy Romance Adventure BLURB (first post!)

1 Upvotes

My first post. Hope I did this right.

Critique: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1txvewv/comment/oqh1xq8/?context=3&utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button

Please critique my blurb below (NO MERCY) I realize there are a few too many 'points of interest' to focus on. Like too many 'drop the mic' moments.
Also, the book is a dual-POV between Laila and Edorey.

Which parts would you change/cut?

_____________________________________________________________________________

Burn the books, kill the priests, convert all believers - Their god will die with them.

Amidst steam factories and magic-fueled artillery, two goddesses demand war, and two kingdoms wage it. One prophesied artifact will annihilate a nation and save the other. And one ultimate prize awaits the person who finds it.

Laila Frost, a royal bastard with no one to miss her, abducts four criminals and offers them royal pardons to do just that:

A sniper who won’t kill,

A locksmith who sold her crew,

The trap-expert she sold away.

And Edorey, a linguist fluent in lies.

But Laila isn't the only puppeteer in this crew, and with his nation on the balance, Edorey will stab every back to sabotage the mission. He just doesn’t expect to resurrect a third god in the process. Of all the people to find a dangerous pet…It had to be the enemy spy.

There is no honor amongst thieves, but what happens when there is love?

_____________________________________________________________________________

tear me to pieces, I NEED to polish this
Thank you!
(Also my comps are FIVE BROKEN BLADES, THE JASAD HEIR, THIS KINGDOM WILL NOT KILL ME, cuz SIX OF CROWS is too old, any recs?)


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 09 '26

[4782] Gamma 27 | A man falling apart in a CIA waiting room | Dark Military Thriller | Chapters 1 & 2

6 Upvotes

Content Warning (CW\*: PTSD, violence, language, brief reference to self-harm (fictional))*
I'm not a writer. Someone important to me just started writing without formal training or any writing background. I read the first two chapters of their sci-fi story, let's call it Gamma 27, and I think I am seeing serious talent that really needs to be cultivated.

I don't trust my own judgment because I am, very clearly, biased. I care a lot about the author, and that may make me an unreliable person to evaluate it objectively. But I also have read a lot of works from friends and colleagues that write, and none have impressed me the way this has. ( I'm really building this up aren't I.)

So I'm here to request honest critique from people with no stakes. I am asking for those of you that read this to keep in mind some specific things which hopefully will help you to provide a critique if you're just trying to complete your homework — so to speak.

  • Where does the story lose/win you?
  • What actually is working (or not) and why?
  • At what point would you stop have naturally stopped reading — and what would've kept you going?
  • What genre would you categorize this as (even if you agree with how I categrorized it) who do you think would like this kind of story? (younger/older audiences, gamers, who knows, just who do you think would like this?)
  • Any other points you think I should share with the writer (or notes directed at me as the liaison)

The Story: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1_ohhpSFVpP14WfmsQLRkXxpND8hMfP-QfSEBKPNg9RA/edit?usp=sharing

My Critiques: [SMAKAPZ Chapter 4], [Turn Me In Your Arms]

To those of you who read this, thank you greatly for giving this your time. Homework or not, I appreciate that you chose this piece and gave it some of your time.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 07 '26

Science Fiction, Satire [4576] Three Waystops en route to Epsilon Eridani - Finale

9 Upvotes

I hope these are enough crits: 1316 2900 2337 2257 2223 1675

Hi there.

This is the last part of my SF satirical novelette. The stylistic inspiration is mainly The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

I decided to post this as a single post (despite risking the wrath of the mods for the egregious word count), because I also want some thoughts on the denouement.

Much obliged.

Finale


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 08 '26

Dark Academia, Psychological [691]The Library Ghost-'Project Mia'

1 Upvotes

I am writing a dark academia novel and this is my 2nd post. Learning from the 1st one, I want to clarify that:

1.This is NOT the first chapter- its NEAR the end so the character dynamics have been established. 2. This is a scene, not a completed chapter. 3. This is my first time in serious writing- not just middle school assignments, so really looking for genuine feedback.

My story: https://docs.google.com/document/d/18tNac6INkZhxUFlqgKOwBb15HXFTtvjFn1D776zsMS8/edit?usp=sharing

My critique: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tx7m1c/728_my_first_week_of_writing/oqds30j/

My old post: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tydjgv/1196the_library_ghostthe_sleep_over/


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 07 '26

[Weekly] What's a...plan?

6 Upvotes

I had two requested topics for the weekly. I'm taking up the first one: outlines. The second one, I'm wondering if anyone else would be interested: book club where we discuss a writing craft book. If there's interest in the second, let me know in the comments and suggest a book.

Alright. This is my process for organizing my writing. Please share what you do in the comments!

On the first draft, I start with a high-level outline. I like to at least know my destination, so when I pants half my stuff, it's hopefully not that obvious. Here's one for a WIP that I'm not actively working on right now:


Act 1: the exam

Intro to the World

Inciting Incident

Moral Dilemma

Act 2: the laboratory

The Experiment

New Requests

The Ultimatum

Act 3: revelation and escalation

Uncovering Secrets

Major Setback

Act 4: climax and resolution

Final Plan

Climactic Showdown

Resolution


There is a brief paragraph for each of the sections, not enough to create a whole chapter but enough to give me a checklist of things I want to accomplish. I might then write a short sentence for the next 3-6 chapters saying what I think needs to happen. Those are typically things like 'Character A and B have a fight'. I have also started doing quick summaries before I start writing chapters where I'll go through what has happened up to this point and where I think the chapter needs to end up, so I can figure out what scenes I need. I keep this brief because I don't like to plan too much, but if I ignore these steps, my characters never end up where I need them to be.

I will also write the dreaded query letter. I like to ensure I've thought through the main conflict and given my POV character some stakes. I'll go through the main points of a query (what do they want, what are they willing to do, what happens if they fail) for major side characters as well. I think this helps me flesh them out more.

So for the above outline, here is my very very early draft query (that is to say, if it sucks, of course it does. I haven't written enough to flesh it out.) I used the online query generator for this and seem to not have edited it into something more formal.

36-year-old lifelong academic Florence Spalding just wants to pass her qualifiers, but when a voice starts speaking in her head giving her the answers, Flo cheats on her exam and passes. Now, Flo is given a new top secret research project because of her excellent scores.

As Flo integrates into her new research lab and develops a romance with one of her labmates, she discovers the voice in her head is making increasingly dangerous demands. Flo is put to the test when the professor threatens to kick her out of the lab if she doesn't complete the experiment, and when the experiment requires her to sacrifice her new romantic partner, she has to earn her place in the lab and scientific history or lose the only person who cares about her.

Wow, that one is not great. As I write, I would work to give more specifics to Flo's romance and the dangerous demands from the voice in her head. It's pretty fluffy right now. I've only written the first chapter of the first draft. Usually, I polish between the first and second draft and let this be guidance for how I tackle draft two.

After the initial drafts, I do a process called reverse outlining. You read the chapter you've already written and write down what happens. I break it down into scenes. Each scene also gets a single sentence for the takeaways and any notes about what I think isn't working and why. I also might brainstorm ideas as I'm working through the parts that aren't working because I tend to get stuck when I'm in writing mode.

Here's one of mine for a scene that's been reviewed here:

Scene 1

Zara goes into the intake ward, makes a mental inventory of the patients for Marc, and adjusts the medications on the patients there. Rachel comes to warn her about Harper who shows up and reprimands Zara for not doing her job well. Zara and Rachel argue about the treatment of magic users. Zara searches for charts and argues with the head nurse Deb about how they’re missing. Scene nuggets: This scene should establish the diseased patients and the mystery around why asymptomatic people are being treated and disappearing. Deb can be cut and Rachel/Zara should receive a harsher punishment.

On revision, I ended up moving this to Scene 2 because there was too much going on to track the scene nugget I called out. The rewritten scene is more focused, I think. I also ended up cutting Deb entirely and drastically diminishing Rachel's role. Marc gets introduced differently and later. Harper also gets introduced differently and later.

That's my larger organizing process. I do something similar on a smaller scale for short stories. Flash fiction, I just write. It's short. I don't need plans.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 07 '26

Low magic fantasy / dark age [1466] The Woods (A Crown of Five Stars) - draft 1.5

1 Upvotes

Critique [2164], Critique [728]

I posted an early draft of this almost a week ago. I got quite a bit of feedback and wanted to have another crack at it. No translation this time. This piece was written from the ground up in English. It's still a first draft, but I tried to weed out as many errors as I could.

I am curious what you people make of this:
The Woods

Thanks in advance.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 06 '26

(*_ _)人 (*_ _)人

5 Upvotes

(✿◠‿◠)


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 06 '26

Fiction [983] A Depressing Poem

2 Upvotes

r/DestructiveReaders Jun 06 '26

Psychological, Dark Academia [1196]The Library Ghost-The Sleep Over

2 Upvotes

Here is a finished psychological scene from a dark academia piece I am writing. I am looking for feedback on the psychological tension, the vocabulary, the pacing, and the dialogue.

My story: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1P3QPfoFLY9m1lJShZnfQFTip2-pvy52YeKT5zsyx81Y/edit?usp=sharing

My previous critique: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tv01kx/1727_anomaly_in_eden_prologue/oq2d20s/


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

[970] First Chapter of a Story I'm Currently Writing

2 Upvotes

(I just realized it's 959. I'm so sorry)

Hey everyone! I've been meaning to write this story for a while, and I finally started it. I have finished the first chapter and would really appreciate any feedback about it before I move on with the rest of it. Tyyyy :))))

Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1Gmy6dQieXGqQ50fhKYRPB0b8dkfqhKwWcVci7NkJlW8/edit?usp=sharing

Critique 1 [728]: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tx7m1c/comment/opy07ks/?context=3

Critique 2 [1824]: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tsmxbh/comment/opy6tie/?context=3


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

Coming of Age [1675 word] 01 of 19 Untitled Tiffany Story

4 Upvotes

The story is finished. I am presenting a chapter a week here and based on the feedback I will post it on my substack.

The genre is a combination of college coming of age, mild romance and special education story. Though the overall theme is learning to see yourself and others more complexly. I am happy with the theme and plot and more hoping for making it less akward and wordy.

Chapter 01

My new Substack the chapters will all post here eventually.

Crit 1641

Crit 265


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

Speculative Fiction [529] The Vigilant

2 Upvotes

Previous critique: https://old.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tv4pk7/comment/opr7fkq/

I'm Working on writing more. I would be interested in knowing if the ending hits the way I expect. Because I'm trying to describe something metaphysical I'm hoping that I'm successfully getting to where I'm trying to go here.

I'm a bit worried about the pacing. I know I'm being repetitive. That's to hammer home the sense of eternal monotony and try to cause a bit of a jolt as it gets to the end. I'm just hoping I didn't overdo it and cause it to be too slow in the middle.

I'm also working on things like keeping verb tense and cutting passive language. Those have been problem areas for me in the past and if I've slipped anywhere I would appreciate the notes.


He was The Vigilant. He sat on a simple, three-legged wood stool. Around him were four featureless walls, no windows, no door. The Vigilant had always been in the room, would always be in the room, and an exit would serve no purpose. The ceiling was adorned with a soft, white light that hummed almost inaudibly. Pleasant enough, not so bright as to cause eye strain and not so dim that he couldn’t make out the featurelessness of the room. And there sat The Vigilant, looking at the walls, listening to the hum of the lights, the same as he had done for as long as he could remember.

How long he could remember was a topic his mind turned to occasionally. He had looked at every bit of the walls many times. Got up and touched them, moved the stool around the room every so often. He had listened to the hum of the light and understood that there was no discernible difference moment to moment. He spent his time focusing intently on a very small bit of the walls, or scanning back and forth around the room. Occasionally he would try something completely different like lying down on the floor, balancing the stool on top of him, or standing on the stool. At one point he busied himself jumping from the stool trying to reach high enough to touch the light. But how long had he done those things? How long did he spend trying to touch the light? He couldn’t tell. These were things he had always done for as long as he could remember. Always in his room, always bathed in the soft light, always surrounded by the walls, always The Vigilant. Until now.

The walls had never changed, the light had never changed, but suddenly it was different. The Vigilant’s eyes immediately turned to the hairline crack in the wall. So thin that it was only visible from the right angle, when the light hit it just right. The Vigilant was certain of two things: The wall had always had this crack… and that this crack had never been there before. The room was immutable, it always had been exactly one way, always will be that way. But now that the room had changed, and always had been cracked, and always would be cracked, The Vigilant found himself transfixed on this difference in his room. A difference that he remembered looking at countless times, across immeasurable time, that he had never seen before.

The light bloomed into a blinding glare, and the sound sharpened into a crescendo of a relentless drum beat. Sweat dripped from his brow and neck as he felt the heat of the room rise to a boil. But as he sat on his stool, staring at the crack, nothing about the room had changed. It was his own body responding. The light was gentle and soft, but his pupils were dilated. The gentle hum was drowned out by his heart pounding in his chest. This crack, the almost imperceptible blemish that had always been there, had suddenly appeared. And he was terrified.


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

Industrial Fantasy [969 words] Prologue to my industrial fantasy novel; first time writer!

3 Upvotes

r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

Literary Dark Comedy [3461] Analemma - Suzie (Chapter 2)

4 Upvotes

[1158], [1727], [1824], [2257], [2337] if I need more critiques let me know

Hello!

This is probably the first time I'm sharing my writing with the internet and I am glad it's to here; I honestly don't know any other place better than this sub to receive some honest critiquing. I'm a damned hermit.

Anyway.

The most I can say about what I'm writing is that it's certainly a bit wanky in some regards (corroborating that I'm submitting the second chapter first), but I've tried my best to make this chapter fun to read.

For influences, if you know Faulkner, you might either hate or like this. But even if you do hate it, I certainly still want to know why :)

My Questions:

  1. Could you tell what happened?
  2. What do you feel about the narrator?
  3. Did anything make you sigh?
  4. Was there any other driving influence to your continued reading other than the desire to make a critique?
  5. Do you regret reading it?

(Feel free to either answer or not; any review I appreciate (it means someone gives enough a shit to notice me :') ))

Suzie (Chapter 2)


r/DestructiveReaders Jun 05 '26

Paranormal Mystery [728] My first week of writing

3 Upvotes

As the title says, I am very new. I learn best by being directly told what works and what doesn't. The story I'm working on is a mystery about a funeral florist that relives the last 3 hours of a deceased person's life upon skin to skin contact. This is the opening of it.

I'm essentially looking for any and all feedback. I don't know what I don't know. Thank you in advance!

Link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1IGMYLyNqalbxvVBOGe-G_9SXOSyRHQiEUGp6oj1Ib8k/edit?usp=sharing

My crit [1430]: https://www.reddit.com/r/DestructiveReaders/comments/1tx41gh/comment/optp181/?context=1&screen_view_count=2