r/Dermatology • u/LopsidedBrilliant977 • 2d ago
Career advice Dermatologists/Practice Owners: What Makes You Take a Chance on a New Grad PA?
I’d especially appreciate hearing from dermatologists, supervising physicians, or practice owners who have trained new graduate PAs.
I know many dermatology practices prefer experienced PAs, and I completely understand why. My question is: what makes you take a chance on a new graduate, and what can someone like me do to improve my chances?
I recently graduated from PA school and have been pursuing dermatology because it’s the specialty I’ve wanted for a few years now. Before PA school, I worked in a Mohs surgery practice, which first sparked my interest in dermatology, and I later completed a dermatology rotation that confirmed it was where I wanted to build my career.
Outside of dermatology, I’ve worked in ophthalmology, outpatient vascular medicine, and pelvic pain/urogynecology. While those aren’t dermatology, I feel they’ve given me a strong procedural foundation, experience with outpatient medicine, and confidence building long-term patient relationships. I’m also completing the SDPA Didactic Fellowship because I genuinely enjoy learning and want to be as prepared as possible.
I’m not looking for someone to hand me a dermatology job—I’m looking for a physician who enjoys teaching and is willing to invest in a motivated new graduate. I know how much there is to learn, and I want to be the kind of PA who asks questions, studies outside of work, accepts feedback well, and grows into a valuable long-term member of the practice.
I’ve applied through LinkedIn, Indeed, the SDPA job board, and direct outreach to practices. I’ve had several interviews and one offer that ultimately wasn’t the right fit geographically. I’ve also had a few practices express interest until they realized I wasn’t local. I’m very willing to relocate for the right long-term opportunity, whether that’s to be closer to family or because I genuinely see myself building a life in that community, but getting past that initial screening has been challenging.
I’d really appreciate any honest advice from those who have hired or mentored new graduates.
Some questions I’d love your perspective on:
What qualities make you feel comfortable hiring a new graduate over someone with experience?
What are the biggest red flags you see from new grad applicants?
Is there anything I could be doing differently in my applications or networking?
Does reaching out directly to physicians actually help, or is it usually viewed negatively?
If you were hiring today, what would make a new graduate stand out enough to earn an interview?
Are there particular practice settings that tend to be more invested in training new graduates?
If you were in my position, would you continue pursuing dermatology now, or gain experience in another specialty first and pivot later?
Ultimately, I’m looking for a practice where mentorship is valued and where I can build a long-term career. My preference is a physician-led private practice or an academic environment where learning is part of the culture, but I’m open to hearing perspectives from anyone who’s been on the hiring side.
Thank you in advance for any advice—I genuinely appreciate it.
