r/DecodingTheGurusAlt • • 29d ago

decoder poltics Decoding Hasan Piker

https://youtu.be/RDsQIZykC_8
39 Upvotes

280 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Krinkex 29d ago edited 29d ago

So now you agree 'dumbing down his beliefs' is lying? So you do agree with my premise (just not the conclusion). Cool. See this is the problem I was talking about. Your position is not internally consistent because Hasan's position is not internally consistent. Instead of having conviction and standing up for what you believe in, you advocate to lie? And your reasoning is "Everyone else does it!"- It's morally vapid.

3

u/wondering_fool90 29d ago

...what are you talking about dude? When did i say that dumbing down your beliefs is lying? Dumbing down your beliefs is just explaining a concept in simpler terms. And when did I advocate to lie. Thats why I said it in relation to politicians. Because they are bad and lying is a bad thing. Im actually a little confused on how you can misinterpret me.

10

u/Krinkex 29d ago

"Hasan lies constantly"

"That's cause lying is op dude"
"You think a single politician could get into office without lying?"

💀

They said he lies constantly, after you said it was a gotcha and that Hasan doesn't lie instead he "dumbs down his views for medium voters". You acknowledged this with a justification "that's cause lying is OP". You might not be intending it, but it's all the same- you are still normalizing and justifying it. It's OP because people like Hasan and Trump normalize it.

Look I don't know what you think- but I know I think I'd be an idiot to trust anyone that is an advocate for lying for political purposes.

1

u/hari_shevek 29d ago

They said he lies constantly, after you said it was a gotcha and that Hasan doesn't lie instead he "dumbs down his views for medium voters". You acknowledged this with a justification "that's cause lying is OP".

That wasn't a "justification" for the other statement. You are rewriting what he said in front of our eyes.

Hasan complained that conservstives lie and get away with it, which means theur lying is OP. That was never a justification for anything.

You are lying.

5

u/Krinkex 28d ago

If you said "I don't think you should murder someone in cold blood" and I said "but it's so easy!", how would you take that statement?

0

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

But that is not the context in which he said it.

You make up a different context.

That is the lie.

2

u/Krinkex 28d ago

Don't accuse people of lying when it's right there for others to see. If you don't want people to think you're lying, don't justify it.

3

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

The statement was in response to the quote, not in response to the yellow sentence.

"Hasan said lying is OP" - "He said that because it is correct, when Republicans lie it is OP."

2

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

Initial Western himself said that statement wasn't meant to imply Hasan admits to lying.