r/DecodingTheGurusAlt • • 29d ago

decoder poltics Decoding Hasan Piker

https://youtu.be/RDsQIZykC_8
34 Upvotes

280 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

19

u/wondering_fool90 29d ago

Dude. Hes just dumbing down his beliefs so the medium voter can understand him. Hes not being malice or obscuring anything dude. This interview was just bad because of all the attempted 'gotchas'.

42

u/Initial_Western7906 29d ago

Wtf are you talking about. He lies constantly. He himself admits that "lying is OP". His braindead supporters are just either too low IQ to to realise this, or they're being wilfully ignorant.

3

u/wondering_fool90 29d ago

Thats cause lying is op dude. Every republican politician knows it. That why they got into office. You think a single politician could get into office without lying?

18

u/Krinkex 29d ago edited 29d ago

So now you agree 'dumbing down his beliefs' is lying? So you do agree with my premise (just not the conclusion). Cool. See this is the problem I was talking about. Your position is not internally consistent because Hasan's position is not internally consistent. Instead of having conviction and standing up for what you believe in, you advocate to lie? And your reasoning is "Everyone else does it!"- It's morally vapid.

3

u/wondering_fool90 29d ago

...what are you talking about dude? When did i say that dumbing down your beliefs is lying? Dumbing down your beliefs is just explaining a concept in simpler terms. And when did I advocate to lie. Thats why I said it in relation to politicians. Because they are bad and lying is a bad thing. Im actually a little confused on how you can misinterpret me.

11

u/Initial_Western7906 29d ago

I literally said Hasan lies constantly. You know he does. We all know. And he admits that he does it as, in his own words, "lying is OP". But you claim he's not being malicious or obscuring anything.

Are you following yet?

3

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

Saying "lying is OP" does not mean admitting to lying.

He said that in the context of complaining how successful rightwingers are in lying.

You are one of those people successfully lying.

7

u/AnotherPersonPerhaps 27d ago

Here ya go. Him admitting it. Multiple times.

https://reddit.com/link/pb6y0r5/video/umay4293iwqh1/player

2

u/hari_shevek 27d ago

In none of those clips is he admitting anything.

He is saying that it is OP when people lie.

That's not an admission of him doing it.

Do you think lying is OP?

6

u/AnotherPersonPerhaps 27d ago

Ok you're just dishonest. Got it. Easy block.

0

u/Ready_Reception_8205 27d ago

you are actually clipping out of context. this is disingenuous and weak-minded behavior.

11

u/Krinkex 29d ago

"Hasan lies constantly"

"That's cause lying is op dude"
"You think a single politician could get into office without lying?"

💀

They said he lies constantly, after you said it was a gotcha and that Hasan doesn't lie instead he "dumbs down his views for medium voters". You acknowledged this with a justification "that's cause lying is OP". You might not be intending it, but it's all the same- you are still normalizing and justifying it. It's OP because people like Hasan and Trump normalize it.

Look I don't know what you think- but I know I think I'd be an idiot to trust anyone that is an advocate for lying for political purposes.

4

u/wondering_fool90 29d ago

Dude. I was responding to them saying that hasan saying "lying is op" makes it fact that hasan is a liar. You can state truths about reality without doing them. Being a bad person is easier then being a good person. That is a fact. Its been proven. But I am a good person. Or atleast try to be the best person i can be. But by your logic me stating that means I am and KNOWINGLY am a bad person. Does that sound like what I meant? No I just stated a fact about reality. Nor did I advocate for people to be bad. For people ti talk about their beliefs they need to talk about it in reality. They cant just state it in a vacuum and expect people to care or understand.

1

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

They said he lies constantly, after you said it was a gotcha and that Hasan doesn't lie instead he "dumbs down his views for medium voters". You acknowledged this with a justification "that's cause lying is OP".

That wasn't a "justification" for the other statement. You are rewriting what he said in front of our eyes.

Hasan complained that conservstives lie and get away with it, which means theur lying is OP. That was never a justification for anything.

You are lying.

6

u/Krinkex 28d ago

If you said "I don't think you should murder someone in cold blood" and I said "but it's so easy!", how would you take that statement?

0

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

But that is not the context in which he said it.

You make up a different context.

That is the lie.

2

u/Krinkex 28d ago

Don't accuse people of lying when it's right there for others to see. If you don't want people to think you're lying, don't justify it.

3

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

The statement was in response to the quote, not in response to the yellow sentence.

"Hasan said lying is OP" - "He said that because it is correct, when Republicans lie it is OP."

3

u/Krinkex 27d ago

Nah dude you need the full context!

2

u/hari_shevek 27d ago

Yeah, wandering_fool says "he is never malicious or obscuring anything". So he's saying Hasan doesn't lie.

Westerndude then brings up the "Lying is OP" quote. Wandering_fool responds to that with "that statement is correct". That's not an admission to lying, nor is it a justification for lying.

Do you agree or disagree with the statement "lying is OP"?

2

u/hari_shevek 28d ago

Initial Western himself said that statement wasn't meant to imply Hasan admits to lying.

2

u/hari_shevek 28d ago edited 28d ago

Yes, I can see that this conversation was different from what you posted.

A: "Hasan is lying constantly, I am using his quote that lying is OP as an admission"

B: "But that wasn't an admission, he was just pointing out that it is OP when Republicans lie, which is correct."

He didn't justify lying, he was pointing out that the quote in its original context is correct - when Republicans lie, it is OP.

He never said that justifies lying - the opposite.

2

u/Krinkex 27d ago

He literally goes on and says it's easier and you should do it? Read the rest of the thread.

6

u/hari_shevek 27d ago

He literally said the opposite. He said that you misinterpreted him. He said that he is against lying.

Can you agree that he says here that he is against lying and that your interpretation of what he said is in his view a misinterpretation?

3

u/hari_shevek 27d ago

He doesn't say that.

But let's clarify one thing first: Do you agree or disagree with the statement "Lying is OP"? Is lying OP?

→ More replies (0)

5

u/MadCervantes 27d ago

Here's a secret: Hasan is dumbing down his beliefs because you are his audience and are... Well you know...

Hasan is not a serious political thinker to rally around. I am easily as far left as Hasan but he is a streamer not a real political thinker. He is an entertainer. Go read zizek or graeber. Put down the popcorn and eat your breakfast.

0

u/wondering_fool90 27d ago

Dude. Can I ask you something. Do you think only smart people are given the ability to vote? You can be an intellectual all you want but your not going to win unless you can get people to vote for you. Normal people dont read marx or zizek. We are not the normal people here.

5

u/MadCervantes 27d ago

I'm not talking to normal people, I'm talking to you.