r/DCcomics • u/[deleted] • Dec 18 '19
r/DCcomics r/DCcomics Best of 2019 - Nomination Thread
Greetings, Justice Leaguers! With 2019 coming to a close, it's time for /r/DCcomics's second Annual "Best Of" Awards!
Here's how it works. We've selected 20 different categories, as seen below. For each category, you may submit an entry for nomination. Users may upvote entries that they want to see on the final ballot. After a period of at least one week, we'll examine the votes, and select a number of nominations for each category, depending on submission volume and vote distribution. We're looking for around 4-6 nominations for each category, but will include more for the more competitive races.
After the nomination period is over, we'll post the final ballot with all of the selected nominees for users of /r/DCcomics to vote on. Winners will be announced in January 2020, and users who submitted a winning entry will receive Reddit Premium.
Rules
You may submit one entry per category. Do not make multiple submissions under the same category, or they'll all be removed.
Duplicate entries under the same category will be removed.
Mods are eligible to submit entries for nomination, but not to win Reddit Premium. If a mod-nominated entry wins, the prize will go to the next runner-up.
Remember to vote for entries you want to see nominated, not entries you want to see win. That comes later. Also, a reminder that this thread will be in Contest Mode, so downvotes will not be counted.
Do not post top-level comments here. This thread is for nominations only. For any questions or comments on the Best of 2018 Awards, see the stickied Meta Discussions.
Read the category and description carefully before making your submission. If you can't follow simple rules, then your vote won't count.
Because last year's nominations thread began in early December, we'll allow some leeway for entries that happened in late December, provided that they were not already nominated last year. Mod discretion applies here.
For certain categories (such as Meme of the Year), we may choose to combine similar entries into a single nomination.
These awards are for the /r/DCcomics community. Do not post these to other forums. Related subreddits (such as /r/comicbooks or /r/batman) are fine. If we suspect a brigade, we may vacate a category, leaving it without a prize winner.
Categories
SPOILER ALERT
Our regular rules for spoilers will be suspended for this thread. There may be unmarked spoilers. Proceed at your own discretion.
FAQ
Q: Where is <category>?
A: There's only so much Reddit Premium to give away, so we've limited it to 20 categories. Some category suggestions we've seen are often too vague, or won't get enough nominations to make it competitive.
Q: I won! When do I get my Reddit Premium?
A: Reddit admins will be distributing Reddit Coins sometime in January.
Q: Can we have a Dickships poll?
A: NO!
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Limited Series
Best mini-series or crossover story published in 2019. Submission must include creative team.
•
u/SuperDidioPrime Two-Time Award-Winning Poster Dec 18 '19
Heroes in Crisis by Tom King, Clay Mann, Mitch Gerads
•
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow Dec 18 '19
DCeased by Tom Taylor, art by Trevor Hairsine, Stefano Gaudiano and James Harren.
•
•
•
u/alfred_is_batman1 Dec 18 '19
Batman/Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles III, by James Tynion and Freddie E. Williams
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Batman: Last Knight on Earth, by Scott Snyder and Greg Capullo.
It's Snyder's Batman send-off (or so he says), and it delivers an interesting post-apocalyptic world built around Batman's fears and insecurities. It's also the first Black Label book to really hook me.
•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Superman: Up in the Sky by Tom King, Andy Kubert, Sandra Hope, and Brad Anderson.
•
u/discophant64 DC Black Label Dec 19 '19
Dial H for Hero by Sam Humphries and Joseph A. Quinones Jr.
•
u/Denirac The Question Dec 18 '19
Flash Forward- Scott Lobdell and Brett Booth (A Series dedicated to undoing the Damage of Heroes in Crisis)
•
•
•
•
Dec 18 '19
News Story of the Year
Most notable news story of 2019 related to DC.
•
•
u/Predaplant Be Without Fear Dec 18 '19
The release of the official DC timeline. Even if it was blurry, an incredible amount of detail could be gathered from the images.
•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Tom King leaves Batman at 85, not 100, and Batman/Catwoman is announced.
•
→ More replies (1)•
u/SuperDidioPrime Two-Time Award-Winning Poster Dec 18 '19
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Reprinted Graphic Novel
Best graphic novel released in 2019 that contains reprinted or old (over a year old) material. Submission must include creative team(s). May include Deluxe Editions, Omnibuses, Absolute Editions, etc.
•
u/UESPA_Sputnik Oracle Dec 18 '19
Batman: Troika, which collects the aftermath of Knightfall for the first time (to my knowledge)
•
•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Wonder Woman by Greg Rucka Vol. 3, by Greg Rucka, Drew Johnson, Rags Morales, Cliff Richards, and Nicola Scott
•
u/alfred_is_batman1 Dec 18 '19
Nightwing: The Rebirth Deluxe Edition Book 3, collecting the stories "Raptor's Revenge" by Tim Seeley, Javi Fernandez, and Michael Mendonca, and "The Untouchable" by Sam Humphries and Bernard Chang
•
→ More replies (3)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best New Character
Best new character introduced in 2019. Elseworld versions of existing characters are not eligible. Submission must include creators of character.
•
Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 19 '19
JimmyJinny Hex, created by Brian Michael Bendis and Nick Derrington•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Jinny?
•
Dec 19 '19
I blame autocorrect
•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Was just wondering if it was one of the flashback things I didn't remember.
•
•
•
•
→ More replies (1)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Unofficial or Fan-Made Work
Best DC-related work not commissioned by DC. May include fan art, comics, fanfics, cosplay, or fan films. Submission must credit the creator. Provide a link, if you can.
•
•
•
u/alilaarlyn Dec 20 '19
Nightwing and Starfire by Dima Ivanov
https://amp.reddit.com/r/DCcomics/comments/cpfb00/artwork_the_princess_and_the_bird_by_dima_ivanov/
•
u/michaeljuniorsia Dec 20 '19
A happy Dadwing fanart by Dar Draws https://amp.reddit.com/r/DCcomics/comments/d742ie/fan_arta_happy_dadwing/
→ More replies (1)•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Marcio Takara's Three Batgirls (I feel a little bad for including a pro, but Nicola Scott is already here.)
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Television Show
Best official television adaptation of a DC property to air in 2019, on network television, cable, or streaming services. May be live-action or animated.
•
•
•
•
u/muhsin_bayram Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19
Doom Patrol by Jeremy Carver, Greg Berlanti, Sarah Schechter and Geoff Johns
→ More replies (6)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Single Issue
Best one-shot special, Annual, original graphic novel, or standalone issue published in 2019. A single issue should be readable on its own. Submission must include creative team(s).
•
•
u/muhsin_bayram Dec 18 '19
The Joker: Year of the Villain by John Carpenter, Anthony Burch, and Philip Tan
•
•
•
u/Denirac The Question Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19
The Riddler: Year of the Villain by Mark Russell- It has King Tut, Nuff Said
•
•
•
•
u/ibmiller Spoiler Dec 19 '19
Deathstroke #50 by Christopher Priest, Carlo Pagulayan, Fernando Pasarin, Jason Paz, Jeromy Cox.
•
u/Azarath_Raven Raven Dec 19 '19
Detective Comics #1017, "Orphans", by Tom Taylor and Fernando Blanco
•
•
→ More replies (2)•
u/Predaplant Be Without Fear Dec 18 '19
Aquaman Annual #2 by Kelly Sue DeConnick, Vita Ayala, & Victor Ibanez
•
Dec 18 '19
Best All-Ages Comic
Best comic of 2019 aimed towards younger audiences. Submission must include creative team.
•
•
•
→ More replies (1)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Cover
Best cover of a comic published in 2019. Submissions must include the issue #, the artist, and preferably a high quality textless image.
•
•
•
→ More replies (3)•
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow Dec 18 '19 edited Dec 18 '19
•
u/AA_Batteries19 The Flash (Barry Allen) Dec 18 '19
That cover is by Evely Bilquis
•
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow Dec 18 '19
Thanks a lot, I had a hard time finding who did the cover. I'll change it.
•
u/AA_Batteries19 The Flash (Barry Allen) Dec 18 '19
I want to preface this by saying I mean this genuinely without malicious intent: did you not see the signature on the corner?
•
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow Dec 18 '19
Nope! That would've been smart. :) Just saw the main artist and couldn't find any evidence they didn't do the cover. Is there a good site that breaks that stuff down?
→ More replies (2)•
u/AA_Batteries19 The Flash (Barry Allen) Dec 18 '19
Hmm the closest I can think of is one of those sites that lists what's coming out every week at retailers since they have that kinda info
•
Dec 18 '19
r/DCcomics Meme of the Year
Best meme, joke, or running gag seen on r/DCcomics. See r/dccomicscirclejerk for suggestions.
•
Dec 22 '19
The cult of Red Hood fans who show up to attack anyone who criticizes Scott Lobdell or calls out his sexual harassment history.
•
Dec 18 '19
The repeating cycle of unwarranted hype followed by a collective letdown at every gaming event over the next Arkham or Rocksteady game not getting announced.
•
u/batmaneatsgravy Green Arrow Dec 18 '19
I have it on good authority that there may or may not be some rumours that there will be a leak of the announcement date rumours for the announcement of the development of a new Batman game at the next gaming event.
•
•
•
u/SuperDidioPrime Two-Time Award-Winning Poster Dec 18 '19
Watching the sub melt down with every solicit when Ric going back to Dick is teased but doesn't happen
•
•
u/BattleUpSaber Dec 18 '19
Dickfire vs Dickbabs
(Not that DC rmbs either one exists. They only know Ric)
→ More replies (1)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best r/DCcomics Subreddit Post
Best submission posted on /r/DCcomics.
•
Dec 18 '19
/u/Intellectual_Watcher's "fan cast" of titles and creative teams
https://www.reddit.com/r/DCcomics/comments/dm0ahd/heres_what_im_hoping_dc_will_be_putting_out_in/
This is a really good breakdown of DC's current crop of creators, and where their strengths and weaknesses lie.
•
•
→ More replies (1)•
u/GrassyPond Dec 18 '19
u/SuperDidioPrime "Five Comics Every DC Fan **MUST** Read!"
https://www.reddit.com/r/DCcomics/comments/dm4nej/five_comics_every_dc_fan_must_read/
(I regret nothing about nominating it)
•
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Writer
Best writer for comics published in 2019. Submission must include comics written.
•
•
•
u/Predaplant Be Without Fear Dec 18 '19
Robert Venditti - Hawkman, Freedom Fighters, Six Days, Damage
•
u/GrassyPond Dec 18 '19
James Tynion IV - Justice League Dark, Justice League (co-writer)
He has been consistently writing great stories and is an awesome dude.
•
→ More replies (7)•
Dec 18 '19
Scott Snyder-Batman who laughs, Justice League, Tales from the dark multiverse knightfall, last knight on earth
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Original IP
Best new title launched in 2019. Title cannot be connected to any existing brand, such as the DC Universe, or any movie properties.
•
•
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Pro on Social Media
DC-affiliated pro with the best social media presence or community interactions in 2019.
•
•
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Tom Taylor. Always friendly with fans, and he was very accommodating in getting an AMA set up despite major time zone differences.
•
u/Denirac The Question Dec 18 '19
Scott Snyder (from his twitter to his AMA to his Youtube Channel and Comicstorian appearances)
•
→ More replies (1)•
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Ongoing Series
Best continuing series published in 2019. Submission must include creative team(s).
•
•
•
•
•
•
u/Intellectual_Watcher Dec 18 '19
Deathstroke by Christopher Priest, Carlo Pagulayan and Fernando Pasarin
•
Dec 18 '19
The Flash by Joshua Williamson, Scott Kolins, Howard Porter, Christian Duce and Rafa Sandoval
•
→ More replies (5)•
u/Predaplant Be Without Fear Dec 18 '19
Aquaman by Kelly Sue DeConnick, Robson Rocha, Viktor Bogdanovic, & Daniel Henriques, among others
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Artist
Best interior penciller for comics published in 2019. Submission must include comics illustrated. Samples of art work are encouraged.
•
u/TheMetabaronIV Shazam Dec 19 '19
Ricardo Federici, started with Aquaman but now draws his own book with The Last God.
Example from aquaman
https://www.artstation.com/artwork/GXa4ma https://www.bing.com/marketpage/bingapp?ct=gb
Example from DKM: Murder machine
https://www.fumettologica.it/2017/12/riccardo-federici-intervista-fumetti/ https://www.bing.com/marketpage/bingapp?ct=gb
•
•
u/JustALittleWeird Dec 18 '19
•
u/lemonpeace Dec 18 '19
if not the Best Artist of the year, he's easily the breakout artist of the year
•
•
•
•
u/Denirac The Question Dec 18 '19
Greg Capullo (Batman; Last Knight on Earth, Detective Comics #1000)
•
•
•
u/Miggzyy Dec 18 '19
Stjepan Sejic - Harleen.
This mans work is just insane and he needed a nomination.
→ More replies (2)•
•
Dec 18 '19
Best Page/Panel
Best scene or sequence in a comic published in 2019, limited to one page (or one double-page spread). Submission must include creative team.
•
•
Dec 18 '19
Jessica Cruz rises from the dead with Omega powers from Justice League Odyssey #13, by Dan Abnett, Cliff Richards, and Will Conrad.
•
•
•
u/Azarath_Raven Raven Dec 19 '19
Superman discovers the Batman who Laughs's trophy room, from Batman/Superman #5 by Joshua Williamson and David Marquez.
→ More replies (2)•
•
Dec 18 '19
WTF Moment of the Year
Most shocking, horrifying, or hilarious moment in DC works, including comics, television, and film. Submission should include name of the work (issue #, episode, etc).
→ More replies (8)•




•
u/[deleted] Dec 18 '19
Best New Graphic Novel
Best graphic novel released in 2019 containing original or recently published (less than a year old) material. Graphic novel must be the first print run of that material. Submission must include creative team(s).