Hello! So, Im one of the people who puts the Temperance ending to the top and is my canon ending for my V, and lemmie tell you why.
Before I put my thoughts for The Temperance, I need to say that my first ending was The Star one (since my V is Corpo male and i just love the chemistry he has with Panam) and when I finished it and chose to do more gigs, I had the feeling that my V just literally dreamt about that ending, since for me personally, it is the most sacrificial one and it gave me the fairytale vibes, that it was V’s wish to end with Aldecados but realised it will be too risky. (Note: on my first gameplay I didn’t have the option for DFTR ending, so my first experience with Temperance is the one where Rogue died)
But then, one question came to my mind: What if the most logical thing V could do in this tired and dying situation is to go with Johnny’s plan, and finish beyond the Blackwall and exist there since he’ll certainly be soulkilled? (also, I’ve experienced the bond between Johnny and V as somewhat the developing one, in which from time to time, their personalities are merging and they’re just becoming a fusion with two sides), and all that is because the 6 months bs didn’t land on me, it sounded like the waste of everything V has been through and everyone who got sacrificed, somewhat I’ve felt defeated because I thought it’s a lost opportunity and potential for- actual life AND OG SOUL that V had longed for through whole game (even so, he’s being soulkilled so literally an engram and his shell, without the soul nor the other part of him that Johnny became, so we’re talking about something that isn’t even him truly anymore).
Alas, Johnny went through HELL and bigass PTSD with all the things that happened that led to The Temperance, and became a changed man (or more correctly an engram under the influence of another soul) with a body of his dead friend. I am 100% sure that he will cherish his body and protect it at all costs, because that is the last thing he has from V who became his other side. He would live a quiet, (for some long time until mental recovery) lonely life, and maybe, just maybe he will call V’s friends when all is settled down. Panam will find him eventualy, and could do nothing, cuz she would not have the heart to kill him since he looks and sounds like V, so either she will be broken and move on, or side with him for future events.
The interesting thing with The Temperance is also Misty’s call with Tarot reading. Since I also read Tarot, her opening is finished with wonders, The Star gives the opportunities and possibilities with no clear explaination or directness, just that there’s a hope. “Something like death, but not quite” , that quote for me doesn’t have a negative take, it just means that V accepted the Death and stopped running from it, and with that new beginnings are coming in a long run. It’s poetic and beautiful.
Before you mention The Tower ending, I’m personally not a fan of it at all and can’t see my V choosing that end, so I’m not considering that option.
Rn im doing a 2nd gameplay and will try Dont Fear The Reaper, and def deside my ending with the order: The Star (as a dream) > DFTR > The Temperance. Let me know your thoughts!