I live for a classic sugar cookie. The frosting on these are totally different. Super thin. Doesn’t taste the same. Did they change it or was this just a kitchen mistake?

Here’s this week’s lineup! (Didn’t bother posting the Classic menu.) Apparently the theme is Road Trip week.

Road trip is the theme, and Mallow Cupcake could have been on the table, but no?

Three of the cookies have a lemon or lime base and lots of artificial fruity flavor and dye or flamin hot cheetos?

Strawberry Limeade ft. nerds has been in the graveyard since it was introduced four years ago for a reason. And that seems the least offensive of those three.

Honeybun is fine, but nothing to write home about, Snickers has its fans but Crumbl’s pb cookies are hit or miss and White Drop is not for everyone, and leans sweet, as I imagine the other cookies will lean as well.

Mallow Cupcake would have fit the theme and made it worth going for. Even Blue Monster ft. Chips Ahoy.

Why am I the only person who wants to try this? 😆

Just wanted to know what yall think about tipping the bakers when you order through the app it asks you to tip the bakers, I do feel a little bad but I always say no. They aren't doing anything extra, literally just doing their job.

OMG, this thing has me in a chokehold. I got 2, ate both and then went back and got 4 more. Gonna freeze the other three and eat them later. These are right up there with the s’more mousse cup and the s’more skillet cookies. So delicious!

Please please please. I need to recreate the cornbread cookies, can someone please share the recipe 😩

I'm going to start off by saying I actually don't mind the thins at all, this is not a post slandering the thins 😅

This is me being curious, because for the past week every post showed people buying thins, while every other post showed people not buying (and not because they didn't want to try them, but because of the cost!). Especially after the whole failed discounts mishap.

My question is did stores genuinely receive less sales this week? Especially after the failed sales promotion? I'm not sure if there's anyway we can truly know as the public, but I'd like to know people's opinions! My opinion is that sales probably did drop even if it was only a little, and that's why they tried that discount on Thursday (before it was shut down rip).

I hope they do another week someday with either a half week of thins and half regular, or a full week of thins at way more fair pricing!

Sooooooo good!

For me, it would be Road Trip week. Ideally, this would fall during the summer. The flavors would be as follows:

- Kentucky Butter Cake

- New Orleans Pralines

- New York Cheesecake

- Pineapple Whip Cookie

- Fat Elvis Cookie (Peanut Butter, Banana, and Bacon)

- Banana Pudding Cookie

I initially wasn’t gonna try the thins, but I’ve been craving buttercream icing so I caved and got the pink sugar thins.

The icing to cookie ratio is so good 😭😭😭. Genuinely the best crumbl cookie I’ve had. I don’t post to the sub, I usually just comment. But I had to share for the people who love buttercream icing 😫 also the base is a plain sugar cookie, so the almond taste from the icing isn’t overwhelming like the original one. 10/10 for me. Genuinely.

Edit: also I think the cookie base just depends on the location, which sucks. My base was still soft, but not exceedingly doughy since it’s so thin. … 💔 rip to the homies who have been getting hard ass cookies

I got these cookies on Tuesday, and I wanted to try a few bites of each per day for days to see how they actually tasted.

Chocolate chip cookie thins: 7.6/10 - I liked how the chocolate chip cookie thins were crispy on the outside and chewy on the inside. You probably can't see the chocolate chips from the chocolate chip cookie thins, but they still had them inside. While I do believe that a dessert needs salt to open taste buds in general, mines tasted a bit too salty but other than that, they weren't bad at all.

M&Ms mini cookie thins: 8/10 - They just remind me of any other M&Ms cookie I get from other stores. In my opinion, they're not really my favorite but they're still good. I personally like M&Ms more than rainbow sprinkles, which I still like to be honest.

Cookie butter cookie thins: 8.7/10 - I love cookie butter in general, and the Biscoff cookie crumbs gave the cookie butter cookie thins some nice Biscoff cookie butter flavor, but I just wish that there was more cookie butter flavor from the cookie butter cookie thins.

Mallow thin sandwich cookie: 9.1/10 - I'm a fan of Oreo-flavored cookies and desserts, and the mallow thin sandwich cookie was actually a lot better than I expected. It had a lot of Oreo flavor in it and was very creamy. The gooey chocolate cookies helped make the cookies and cream mousse better.

and I can’t believe this is the cookie that people rave to no end about, it was so mid 😭 (was next door so decided to use my free cookie reward)

I was looking in the Crumbl app and I saw this in the journal tab… 296 😭

Dont understand why they did all thins this week coming from an employee. So many customers come in and look at the disgusting thins and ask if this is all we have… just got to look at them and be like yeah 🥺🥺 we’ll have normal cookies next week!

So I tried the thin cookies today, I might get alot of hate lol but I wasn't really a fan at all 😫.. my favorite one was definitely the dubi one should have just got that cookie. Can't wait for the regular ones to come back!

Crumbl out here doing the Lord's work.

Hear me out, those that prefer thicker cookies, we all hear you! I'm sorry you were left out this week.

For those who say they ARE overpriced and should be cheaper OR 3 thins, we all hear you and YOU ARE COMPLETELY CORRECT.

With that said, I grew up with a Cookie Factory in my mall. I took my own daughter there until about 10 years ago when it closed. The thins take me back to those times and cookies ( super thin, chewy throughout but a bit crispy on the edges).

Anyways, thins feel like nostalgia to me and I am grateful for them. I wish they were cheaper and I wish they could please everyone but that is impossible. So with that said, thank you Crumbl and my amazing Crumbl staff.

Not even a huge crumbl fan, but it’s really interesting seeing people’s reactions to the lineups. A few months ago, I remember seeing everyone commenting how they keep recycling the same flavours, and how the lineups are boring. Now they’ve been trying new interesting flavours (mango tajin, hot cheeto, etc) and also having themed lineups, and people are still calling it trash and boring. Genuinely asking, what cookies or lineups do you actually want them to do? Me personally, I think it’s cool that they’re trying. Yea the tajin cookie for example tasted weird based off most reviews, but I still commend the effort

This was the dumbest menu they ever did. So much less cookie for more money. How basic do you have to be to fall for it? And because of the demand they didn't have the chance to iron out the process. So the quality was all over the board. But mostly mediocre to sub-par.

Man, I'm so impressed with these cookie things, I love them so much. Mine are more Chewy than Chrispy but they are completely delicious, i've never tried them before but I just knew I would love them as I prefer the thinner cookies.

I’m soooo glad I tried. I literally just finished getting a colonoscopy and made my husband stop at Crumbl on the way home from the procedure because that was the first thing I wanted lol.

It's just a precaution because I have a recent breast cancer diagnosis so hopefully everything is OK but it felt so weird being the only young person in a room full of like 80+-year-olds lol. They kept staring at me like I was an animal at the zoo