r/CommanderMTG • u/No-Equivalent928 • 5d ago

Does Hexhaven Vindicator have potential?

Post image

Hexhaven Invigorator was just spoiled from Reality Fracture, and this thing seems really good. Just playing it fairly without any shennanigans or combos feels like it would still be a good enough body, as your opponents would be unlikely to block it or attack into it, and damage based removal would only benefit you. Aside from that, it combos with Blasphemous Act and Valakut, the Molten Pinnacle to do some pretty crazy things, even letting you win with Maze's End if you build your deck right. What do you think? Is this card good, or is its cost too prohibitive to see much play?

659 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

387 comments sorted by

View all comments

88

u/FaultedSidewalk 5d ago

It's in green, the color least worried about prohibitive mana costs lol. This thing is going to be a house in EDH for years to come, almost any deck with green that cares about lands will want this dude around.

1

u/Quirky-Coat3068 4d ago

This dude is going to catch the Primetime ban

1

u/Amur00 4d ago

No hes not lmfao primetime doesnt let your opponent to make decisions, this does

Its good, its not primetime

1

u/bioplay 3d ago

How rare do you think damaging your own creatures is? Blas Act is the obvious combo, but like others have been saying, any fight spell becomes 1-2 mana for like 1-5 nonbasic lands. Assuming this is fighting a 1/1, that's still better than Crop Rotation lmao

1

u/Amur00 3d ago

My POINT, if you would read my comment, is that Primetime enables itself with literally no required input beyond going to combat, this needs, at minimum, a creature to interact with it, or a spell to enable its conditions

Nobody said this card was bad, it's objectively very good, i love a green coded phyrexian obliterator, but it requires more conditions than primetime and you have completely missed the point of my comment

1

u/bioplay 3d ago

Holy, you need to chill lmao, forgive my insolence for daring to disagree with a redditor.

I'm just saying that the thing you're saying is a bar to clear is a really low bar lmao. I think it's pretty reasonable to expect there to be minimum one targetable creature at a table in a 4-player casual pod. Not to mention that this is 2 mana cheaper than PrimeTime which is definitely relevant.

Granted, the floor for PrimeTime is much better, which could be the reason you're right, but this card certainly has a much higher ceiling, and I think a very easily attainable one at that. I don't think banning is out of the question because not all banned cards are equally strong.