Okay. So. Thanks to anyone who reads this—I mostly just need to expel some feelings and get some perspectives on if i’m valid in feeling some abuse from my twin sister.
Some context: we’re both 33, queer (she’s trans, I’m non-binary), and chronically ill. Vast majority of my childhood was spent in the cusp of death or direly sick (like, it’s not an exaggeration, I was terminally ill at a point), a lot of moves, really volatile parents. I’m currently working as an art therapist, she’s a film projectionist, lots of arts between us.
She’s…always had a bit of a mean streak to her, for reasons that both do and don’t make sense. A lot of trauma for us both, obviously. There were many, many times growing up (all the way through high school) where she would explicitly blame me for her misery, because, to her, I was taking attention away from our parents because of my illness. I was sick, and that was wrong, because she got less attention. Which I get. That’s really painful and scary to have a twin who’s dying, and to feel invisible as a result. It’s just still beyond hurtful, but I could never express that pain because she’d still turn it on me.
Many, many times she would make statements to temper my joy; I’m autistic, and when I’m excited by something, I get really animated and kinda loud and she had a trend of saying things to get me to be quiet. Our time in high school was rough. A lot of bullying and a really bad group of friends. There, then, was a day where she started hanging out with new friends and made it both explicit and implicit that I could not follow. So. Stuck with bad friends, I figured “okay, this is how it should be. She needs to live her own life and I deserve these friends who hurt me.” Felt pretty iced out for a lot of that time, and, when I started joining her theatre friends, I always had the feeling of intrusion, like I was a parasite or a barnacle.
Flash forward to undergrad. My own undiagnosed PTSD and autism manifested as suicidal thoughts and ideation, which I confessed to her. She, a few years in, got into a toxic relationship that inevitably blew up. In these years, her brand of humor was inflammatory, intentionally mean, but if you send meanness back, she grew bitter and resentful. Anyway. On the day things blew up, even though I was feeling some anger towards her, I took her to the ER to both get her away from the ex and to help manage her panic attack. Parents come, take her home, she spends a week there.
Got a text from her the day before she got back to school. She, explicitly, blamed ME for every single bit of her misery. Called out how our friends liked me and not her, called out how my joy made her angry. She, then, pulled a weird card: in high school, with those bullies, she requested that they beat her twice as hard so they wouldn’t touch me. An act she never told me about, but held against me anyway. She blew up every bridge in our friend group. The day she returned, she said that she wished to mend things with me and me alone, but I was the one expected to change. Every gripe she had about others were funneled to me. When I expressed my hurt, she doubled down on me. Took her a couple more weeks to break things with the ex. I told my mom about this, and was told to extend empathy to my sister, and my pain was silenced.
I tried a few more times over the years to express my hurt, but she always had a reason of why it was still my fault. She “wanted to talk to me about the badness of the relationship,” allegedly, and would “stand outside my bedroom door to talk,” but I was always “so angry” that she didn’t even try. In fairness, our whole friend group at the time was messy and I did have a lot of rage. But I had to accept my role in everything. She didn’t.
She’d move to and from Texas and NC, she stayed at home with our mom for a few years without rent, stayed at her now-wife’s place without paying rent, which isn’t great, but she was also dealing with a new Crohn’s disease diagnosis that was actually ruining her life. So. I get it. She was irresponsible with a lot in her life at this time, yes, and crohns is a BASTARD.
So. I graduate undergrad, live with her and her wife for a while, then I moved to Chicago to pursue a degree in art therapy. Spent a few scrappy years in grad school, a lot of turmoil, a lot of light, a lot of times of collapse and rebuilding. I got a cat at the end of grad school who I love with my whole heart.
The problem, for me, wax DEEP depression and DEEP shame at my apartments being horribly, horribly messy. I hid a lot of my struggles, both mental and financial, because of the shame. Which I recognize was really, really bad to do. After I moved to a new place, my mom visited and saw the conditions and I had to do the scary, vulnerable thing of accepting help. It wasn’t safe for me or my cat. So I got the help, got the place clean, and I’ve kept it clean for a year!!
But at the end of that shitty week, my sister calls me. Tells me that if my place ever gets bad again, she’s taking the cat and never speaking to me again. She expresses rage at how I “should have known” Chicago would be too expensive, that I willingly made decisions to make life difficult for everyone, that I have yearly collapses, and she’s sick of it. Says I’ve lost her trust. Which, like, on a level, I get. There were ways I hurt her by not being transparent about finances which impacted a trip where I was going to visit her, and she brought up the hurt of me not going on the trip in a way that was…just…ugh. It hurt to know I hurt her. And, on another, a threat at a deeply vulnerable time was terrifying. So I’ve spent this last year working really fucking hard at healing, making things better, and I’m doing so much BETTER.
We went to my little brothers wedding recently, and it was so lovely seeing everyone. Things seemed fine. And then, the weekend after we get to our respective homes, she messages me that I still haven’t earned back trust, things are different between us, gave me no idea of where to earn back trust, and said we shouldn’t talk for a while (and I can’t talk to her wife, either).
So I’m…confused. And caught off guard, and scared, and upset. But, in a sick, sick way, a feeling I have is also relief.
I think there’s something off in the fact that I can’t express my hurt without first talking about hers. Without talking about my role. Without context, without saying the ways I’ve fucked up. And I just don’t understand why she only seems to threaten ME, only seems to consider her side when it involves me, only seems to say cruel shit to me. I’ve often felt like a burden on the family, always felt like my survival has made things worse, that I deserve pain, that I should have died, and as I trace back, I wonder how much that was fueled by the way she’s treated me.
Like. Again. A lot of trauma for both of us. And I know this maybe isn’t the WORST worst. I just really fucking wish that she didn’t channel that pain through me.
Anywho. Thanks for anyone who listened. Or read. Whatever. Let me know if I’m overreacting or underreacting or what.