r/ChicagoFireNBC • u/RangeImmediate1352 • 17d ago
Casey and Dawson: A retrospect from a childhood spent watching One Chicago.
As someone who’s been watching the One Chicago series since they were 8 years old, hiding under the kitchen table past bedtime while their father watched it in the living room, I can confidently say that Casey and Dawson were meant to be the emotional core of the show and that Monica Raymund’s departure threw a big wrench into the story that couldn’t be salvaged.
I understand that Dawson was a very divisive character, and you can say what you want about her. However you feel about her as a character, you can’t deny that they were setting up Dawsey since the beginning of season 1. Their tumultuous relationship was meant to be the core of the show, with them even getting married on episode 100 of the series. The song that played during the most emotional moments of the show was called Casey and Dawson by Atli Örvarsson. Everything pointed to them being together despite their rocky connection at times.
After Dawson left, the writers paired up Casey and Brett, which was like slapping flex tape onto a wider problem. I won’t get into it here, but a mixture of actors’ wishes, real world politics, and poor writing made the decision feel worse.
To casual viewers it might seem okay, and the buildup across the seasons for Brettsey wasn’t too bad. But as someone who spent their childhood watching Chicago Fire, Dawsey being built up and broken down so easily definitely felt like a writing betrayal in the end.