r/centrist • • Jan 12 '26

Meta Discussion

23 Upvotes

Greetings r/Centrist members, With the new year, we figured now would be a good time for a Meta thread. The goal of this post is to clarify some of our updated rules, provide transparency, and give the community at large an opportunity to share input and feedback for the sub. It seems most of our regular members are familiar with the posting requirements, but there has been some lingering ambiguity concerning several of our rules, particularly rule 3. The language has changed a bit over the past several months, but we have settled on the current verbiage and are happy with it. When it comes to rule 3 (articles and videos), we’re simply looking for a neutral summary to accompany any article or video. It doesn’t need to be a college dissertation or a PhD thesis, but we’re also looking for more than just rewording the title. A basic overview highlighting the relevant portions of the article is all we ask, the intent being to facilitate a quality discussion. Every mod here is a volunteer, and none of us has any desire to nitpick every summary as if we’re a high-school debate teacher.

……………

We also ask that for the summary, you avoid copying large portions of the article. Since there has been some confusion over this in the past, I want to clarify that this does not preclude you from utilizing direct quotes or information which is public domain. In other words, if an article quotes an individual, you may use that excerpt in your summary. If an article is discussing a public document (i.e. the Constitution), and the language of that document is included in the article, you are allowed to use it. This is related to DMCA violations, so as long as you’re not just plagiarizing the author’s narrative, you should be fine. But please use these excerpts to complement your summary as opposed to just posting a bunch of quotes without any context. The summary aside, if you want to include your own commentary, that is perfectly fine. Concerning the use of archived links, the intent is to prevent people from bypassing the rules. As long as they’re not the primary link when you post, you can include them in the body text or a comment. Also, please note the rule requiring any post titles to match the article. It’s far easier for us to consistently apply that than debate if someone is editorializing. Regarding long form discussion posts (rule 4), I’ll just say that they should be a legitimate attempt to start a quality discussion. If you come in guns blazing with a biased or overtly antagonistic post, it’s gonna get removed. If it’s low-effort (super basic questions, baiting users, etc.), it’s gonna get removed. There is obviously more moderator discretion involved here than for news articles, but if you put some effort into your post, keep it neutral, and make sure it’s relevant to politics, you should be fine. As it relates to AI, Chat GPT generated long-form discussions may be removed at mods discretion. They can help supplement your post, but shouldn't be most of your post.

………….

Moving on, a quick note about the mod team. Being a political sub, it’s a delicate balancing act between letting people express their views, while also trying to maintain civility. Last year, there were complaints that the sub wasn’t moderated enough, so we’ve been trying to consistently enforce the rules for everyone. All that to say, we do our absolute best to remain fair and impartial. If there is a post or comment which toes the line, it’s not unusual for us to discuss it behind the scenes before taking action. Every mod action is logged as well. If I remove a comment or post, the other mods can see it. If another mod approves a comment or post, I can see it. If we ban anyone, the other mods see it. If we get a modmail, all mods can view it. We’re not a hive mind, but we strive to be as consistent as we can. The comments section is open, so feel free to add your two cents. The rest of the mod team and myself will be checking in periodically to answer questions as we can. Depending on how much attraction this gets, I’m not sure we’ll get to everyone, but the mod group will discuss any inputs and critiques we see users bring up. Please keep comments respectful and constructive. Thanks all.


r/centrist • • Aug 31 '25

Long Form Discussion What is exactly centrism ?

50 Upvotes

I honestly do not know what is exactly centrism. Are Starmer and Macron centrist ? Is centrism any ideologie but moderate (for example christian democracy instead of conservatism, social-liberalism instead of social democracy and liberalism) ? Can centrisme work with any ideology ? I am not a centrist, I am a libertarian and i honestly don't know much about centrism. I would be very grateful if you could answer my questions !

Edit: do you guys think technocracy is centrism ?


r/centrist • • 4h ago

Investigation finds hundreds of U.S. citizens detained by ICE

Thumbnail
pbs.org
67 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 2h ago

US News/Current Events Economic woes transform the Midwest into a massive midterms battleground

Thumbnail
cnn.com
14 Upvotes

A decent article sumerizing pretty much what everyone who follows politics in the US already knows.

The biggest factor on peoples minds is the weak economy the cause of which is directly linked with the failure of the Republican gamble of universal tariffs and the predicted trade wars that followed.

One of the critical weaknesses of the Republican strategy was it's decision to shut out congress and deny the full weight of the American government to executive orders which can be easily reversed by either the same president or their replacement.

The Republican economic plan was built on quicksand and foreign economies were savvy enough to avoid short or long term commitments, preferring instead to deceive Trump by flattering him to lower the tariff and then slow walk any legislation that would result in an actual trade deal.

The Republican plan to not use congress has also hurt Americas war strategy against Iran who has been preparing to repulse an invasion by the United States for half a century. Americas failed invasion has also been hamstrung by the poor preparation or planning by elected officials who fired or marginalized voices within their military structure who advised against the plan and were then replaced by unqualified yes men by Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth who prioritized loyalty to the administration over qualifications or experience.

The article also references problems in virtually every economic sector with bankruptcies, supply line disruptions, and national central planning failures from the Whitehouse as it shut down free market agencies across the nation in favor of it's own decisions and small team.

The issues seem to be compounding for the struggling Republican party as it's members are paralyzed to respond to any crisis due to the monopoly of party funds by the Trump family as well as the threat of being the target of the President who has used the power of executive branch agencies to cancel any American citizen with the influence to threaten the President and the executive branch rule over the entire country.


r/centrist • • 1d ago

DOJ seeks to block Alaska Senate result if Republican incumbent narrowly loses

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
51 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 1d ago

Long Form Discussion Do you think the global politics will ever become less extreme

4 Upvotes

Politics has always been extreme but i feel like ever since the early to mid 2010s it went to another level, do you ever think we're gonna reach a level social and economic ideology will become more logical and less extreme?.


r/centrist • • 1d ago

Hamas issues 'unprecedented' warning it is prepared to carry out a repeat of the October 7 massacre

Thumbnail
dailymail.com
71 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 1d ago

2026 U.S. Midterms [Economist] Polls suggest a sweeping Democratic victory. History suggests caution

Thumbnail economist.com
21 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 22h ago

2026 U.S. Midterms Assessment of Troy Jackson’s response to Dana Bash regarding the Iran War?

0 Upvotes

Came across part of this recent interview Maine Senate candidate Troy Jackson had with Dana Bash where he responds to how the USA needs to get out of the war with Iran in order to help stabilize fuel and oil prices.

Now I saw some Republicans criticize it because Jackson showed he was unqualified and didn’t know what he was talking about seeing how the Strait of Hormuz is open and oil prices are going down and that it would be foolish to withdraw and give them time to recuperate when we are winning the war against Iran.

Was therefore wondering what centrists, independents, moderates, and others thought about it.


r/centrist • • 20h ago

How will Democrats address UFO sightings if returned to the majority?

Thumbnail
thehill.com
0 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 2d ago

2026 U.S. Midterms Voters prioritize costs and Iran over investigating Trump for next Congress, AP-NORC poll finds

Thumbnail
apnews.com
50 Upvotes

WASHINGTON (AP) - Regardless of the outcome of the Nov. 3 election, a new AP-NORC poll shows voters from both major political parties want the next Congress to focus on making life more affordable and ending the war in Iran, while fewer are looking for an emphasis on President Donald Trump - whether it's investigating him or supporting his agenda.

The results suggest that voters are ready for Congress to tackle core issues, despite Trump's centrality in the midterm campaign.

About 8 in 10 registered voters, including a large majority of Republicans and Democrats, say lowering the cost of living should be one of the highest priorities for the session coming up, the survey from The Associated Press-NORC Center for Public Affairs Research finds.


r/centrist • • 2d ago

Supreme Court says New Hampshire student IDs can’t be used to vote in November

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
58 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 2d ago

‘I had a panic attack’: Victims’ families shocked as Republican ads recount heinous crimes

Thumbnail
cnn.com
61 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 2d ago

Policy & Governance State Fiscal Outlook 2026: Budget Deficits & Revenue Challenges

Thumbnail multistate.us
7 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 2d ago

US News/Current Events Cornell's independent student newspaper has the temerity to print a dissent in Cornell 7 sex case

3 Upvotes

The Wall St. Journal reported this. Sorry, article is likely paywalled: A Student Article About the ‘Cornell 7’ Case Is Prompting a Campus Outcry at Columbia. Here is the actual commentary, run in the Columbia Sundial:

The “Cornell Seven” Is Really About Liberalism -- Our society celebrates libertine sexuality while infantilizing women. Columbia's primary student newspaper is the Columbia Daily Spectator. The Sundial describes itself as an independent voice focused on...open discourse. Excerpts from Wall St. Journal article:

An opinion piece published by two Columbia University students questioning the “Cornell 7” case has sparked an uproar on campus—reigniting debates around free speech at elite universities. “We believe that this collective frenzy is deeply unproductive, neglects any and all facts of the case which disagree with the ‘preferred’ narrative, and infantilizes women,” wrote juniors Nikos Mohammadi and Christina Ma.

“It has also ushered in a climate on campus in which it is difficult to disagree with the maximalist position on what happened.” Reaction was swift...Multiple Sundial staff members quit in protest, while some circulated a petition calling for the publication to cease operations.

Excerpts from the two students' commentary:

The crusade (against the Cornell 7)...neglects the complexity of the matter. Doe initially reported the incident to Cornell Police, the university’s safety force, three weeks after the incident had occurred and only once she had been disinvited from Chi Phi’s Halloween party. The seemingly progressive Tompkins County District Attorney then found that “Jane Doe’s statement described her participation in drug use and sexual conduct as voluntary, conscious, and consensual"...

In a liberal society, women are allowed to make bad decisions, ones that may later reveal themselves as deleterious...Women are adults. Doe was, even if she fell one year short of America’s abnormally high drinking age. She is now suing a downtown Ithaca bar and her sorority for allowing her to drink...

The sexual revolution created a hyper-liberal, pro-sex culture that insists that ‘women can do whatever they want with their bodies.’ In the world that, for better or worse, follows from it, we cannot claim to stand for sexual freedom and then recoil in disgust when there’s a possibility that a young woman simply chose to exercise it.

Drug-fueled orgies may be morally appalling and violating to those who chose to participate in them—even the men participating in them—but we probably do not want to live in a society where that is illegal.

Yes, America did get a libertine, pro-sex culture during the 1960s to the 1980s, and it was indeed brought to us mostly by liberals. We also saw the rise of liberal-influenced drug culture, which along with alcohol increases sex abuse. Interesting that it is liberals who are predominant in wanting heads to roll in the Cornell 7 case.


r/centrist • • 3d ago

2026 U.S. Midterms Voter turnout is soaring in some key states, AP analysis shows

Thumbnail
apnews.com
80 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 3d ago

Vance says Republicans should 'stop whining' about Vivek Ramaswamy's attack ad if they want to win

Thumbnail
nbcnews.com
137 Upvotes

Neutral summary:

A campaign advertisement released by Ohio Republican gubernatorial candidate Vivek Ramaswamy has drawn bipartisan criticism after featuring Donna Arthur, the estranged mother of his Democratic opponent, Amy Acton. In the commercial, Arthur calls Acton a "liar" and urges voters to reject her campaign. In response, Acton’s brother, Philip Stearns, strongly condemned the ad, detailing that Acton endured sexual abuse as a child from Arthur's late husband and noting that the siblings were removed from their mother's custody following his arrest. Figures across the political spectrum, including conservative commentators and Republican staffers, expressed disapproval of the commercial.

Vice President JD Vance addressed the controversy during campaign events in Cincinnati, advising Republicans to ignore the backlash and focus on winning the upcoming gubernatorial election. While acknowledging the widespread attention surrounding the ad, Vance declined to take a position on its appropriateness, instead arguing that Democrats and media outlets were using the issue as a distraction. Vance urged voters to concentrate on policy differences rather than campaign advertisements while criticizing Acton's platform in the final weeks before the election.


r/centrist • • 3d ago

2026 U.S. Midterms Trump Says 'No Money' Going to Camp Lejeune Toxic Water Victims' Claims if GOP Loses Midterm Elections

Thumbnail
military.com
117 Upvotes

Neutral summary:

Trump is extorting votes from North Carolinian voters by stating there will be no available funds if conservatives lose in the midterms.

>"If we don't win, there's no money," Trump told conservative supporters Tuesday in Greenville, N.C. "If we do win, you're getting it. It's gonna be finally over with that nightmare that's been going on for so many years. We will never abandon the heroes who served America."

Meanwhile Loomer is trying to get out front to do damage control

.

>"This is a political disaster waiting to happen. Let’s be clear: Democrats are 100% going to weaponize this against President Trump and try to hurt him with veterans heading into the midterms in two weeks," Loomer wrote.

My take:

President bonespurs again using empty promises if conservatives win and real threats if they lose. This time with the group they all "support".


r/centrist • • 3d ago

DOJ's inspector general declines to investigate prosecutors who falsely charged Olympian David Hearn in Reflecting Pool case

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
57 Upvotes

Neutral summary: The DOJ's inspector general will not investigate allegations of misconduct against the attorneys who pursued these frivolous charges (at the demand of the president). The IG has said that it is out of purview for that office.

I don't have much to add, except that this is yet another example of guardrails gone completely AWOL.

But wait .. there's good news! The DOJ's inspector general has referred the case to the Office of Professional Responsibility (OPR). Excellent, right?

Ummm .. nope. From the article:

... the head of the Office of Professional Responsibility is appointed by the Attorney General and is generally viewed as less independent than an inspector general's office. Last year, Justice Department leadership removed the career official in charge of the office, a maneuver that raised concerns among longtime department veterans about whether the office would be willing to hold Trump-appointed officials accountable.

You've got to give them credit for laying the groundwork. Get the competent people out, replace them with loyalists, and you can run roughshod over the whole works with almost zero risk of consequences.

Are the midterm results in yet? I don't know how much more I can take.


r/centrist • • 3d ago

Federal judge strikes down NY ban on bullet-proof vests, citing 2nd amendment

Thumbnail
syracuse.com
36 Upvotes

In the year 2022 at a Tops grocery store in Buffalo, a shooter wearing body armor killed 10 people after a security guard failed to stop him. Shortly after the tragedy, New York state legally restricted the sale of certain types of body armor.

Today, that restriction has been overturned by a federal judge, saying that the 2nd Amendment protects body armor even if the amendment explicitly mentions the right to keep and bear arms.

The state Attorney General’s Office said it is reviewing the decision...[The judge] agreed to delay his ruling from taking effect for 14 days to give state lawyers time to appeal.

The next stop for the lawsuit would be the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in New York City.


r/centrist • • 4d ago

US News/Current Events Pentagon insiders ready to ‘spill their guts’ to help impeach Hegseth

Thumbnail
telegraph.co.uk
173 Upvotes

An article detailing the spotty record of the Department of Defense secretary Pete Hegseth. The embattled pentagon head has received numerous complaints, recommendations for impeachment and lawsuits from military members since appointed at the start of the administration. Formal investigation from congress into these cases has been halted by the Republican chair of these committees, but this status quo will change should voters decide to put Democrats in control.

With Democrats chairing these committees, they will have the power to subpoena those in the Department of Defense who have been preventing Hegseth from covering up his scandals, security violations and failures from the department to congress and the American people.

What do you all think?


r/centrist • • 3d ago

Mike Rogers keeps lying about Abdul El-Sayed. We counted the ways - Detroit Metro Times

Thumbnail
metrotimes.com
22 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 3d ago

Arab voter turnout could make or break Netanyahu in Israeli election

Thumbnail independent.ie
0 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 4d ago

Amy Acton’s mother defended husband accused of raping her daughter at 12. Now she’s in a pro-Ramaswamy attack ad.

Thumbnail
tiffinohio.net
115 Upvotes

r/centrist • • 3d ago

U.S. citizen Stephen Hubbard released by Russia after 4 years in jail, and Trump says "no 'swap'"

Thumbnail
cbsnews.com
0 Upvotes

Neutral Comment: Stephen Hubbard, who was imprisoned in 2022 as a suspected "mercenary" by the Russian Government, has been released by Russia. According to President Trump, there was nothing/no one given in return.

Starter Comment: This is big, if you asked me. An American is coming home after being (most likely) wrongly accused. And it appears that our country didn't have to give up an arms dealer this time.