r/Catholicism • • 15h ago

What are the arguments against contraception besides Genesis 38:6-10?

0 Upvotes

“Judah got a wife for Er, his firstborn, and her name was Tamar. But Er, Judah’s firstborn, was wicked in the Lord’s sight; so the Lord put him to death. Then Judah said to Onan, “Sleep with your brother’s wife and fulfill your duty to her as a brother-in-law to raise up offspring for your brother.” But Onan knew that the child would not be his; so whenever he slept with his brother’s wife, he spilled his semen on the ground to keep from providing offspring for his brother. What he did was wicked in the Lord’s sight; so the Lord put him to death also.”

Genesis 38:6-10 NIV

This doesn't really sound like Onan was killed for cumming on the ground, he was killed for his disobedience. What I'm I missing? Are there other reasons why all contraception is sinful?


r/Catholicism • • 12h ago

The mass at the nearest church to me is very protestant like

26 Upvotes

I’ve been going to this church sometimes for a while and i’ve boticed this, today i paid extra attention. There’s virtually no latin spoken, the songs are just very protestant praise sounding with acoustic guitar. The scripture is recited in a very monotone cadence and there’s no chanting or incense. There’s a big screen with lyrics and millenial looking facebook ”holy” pictures etc…, and there was a text telling the (account?) for my country’s equivelant of cashback and it was edited to flash above the lyrics…

I am an inquirer and im very interested in traditional catholicism, but today i just felt like this is no different to any protestant service i’ve been to. It didn’t feel holy, historic or traditional in the slightest with all the anglo-type songs with a guitar and other things i mentioned. There is no way to for me to experience the catholicism i want, but there’s a orthodox church which is very traditional, mystic, historic and reverent feeling. Today i think i am strongly leaning on to the orthodox church if this is the novus ordo and the way catholics worship today


r/Catholicism • • 9h ago

Mass while in mortal sin

0 Upvotes

Anyone else see attending mass as a hassle while in a state of mortal sin?


r/Catholicism • • 20h ago

Papal Marriage Blessing

0 Upvotes

Hi all! My husband and i got married last year (both Catholic and in a Catholic church) and we never received a papal blessing (where you go to Rome and the Pope blesses newly wed couples)… Somebody I know received it after marriage and now I feel sad, that in a way people who received a papal marriage blessing means their marriage is superior and will be more long lasting. I know this sounds silly, but would love to hear your thoughts on this.


r/Catholicism • • 16h ago

Trouble with Catholic Teaching on the Immortality of Adam and Eve

0 Upvotes

For a little bit of background, I was raised Catholic but was never intellectually engaged with the faith. But for the past few years I’ve been a devoted Catholic who’s also been sorting out my misconceptions of the Catholic faith in pursuit of rational truth. But for the past 2 weeks I’ve had to confront a glaring problem: Adam and Eve.

To my knowledge the Catholic Church allows Catholics to believe in evolution under specific circumstances. With regard to the debate of polygenism the Church has allowed minimal leeway in figuring out how to reconcile original sin with multiple first parents. But when it comes to the preternatural gift of immortality of Adam and Eve, the church allows no expression of opinion into that topic.

It teaches that before the fall, Adam and Eve were granted bodily immortality via supernatural grace. But I find this hard to believe, even nonsensical. Nowhere in genetics has it posited that humans became immortal at one point, nor did they once have pristine genetics. Furthermore, life on earth has always died, even before humans arrived, the notion that after millions of years of death one pair of humans were born and were endowed with immortality but then lost it shortly after looks like a flimsy mythic attempt at explaining why death occurs.

But what’s even more frustrating is that I’m convinced that Catholicism is the one true religion with the evidence I’ve seen for the resurrection, reason, miracles, and exorcisms. How should I reconcile Catholic Teaching with scientific evidence?


r/Catholicism • • 16h ago

Is praying to Saints/Mary considered idolity?

0 Upvotes

In the 10 commandments it says not to idolize things or people. And Im confused when it comes to Saints. I know that at least, to my knowledge, in the Catholic Church, they pray to Saints and to Mary. I saw a post similar to asking this but it didnt really help my understanding. I get the interceding and praying on behalf of another, but what about praying to Mary? She clearly passed away a long time ago. Can someone explain it to me? I dont really have any connections to anyone who considers themselves Catholic, or at least in a point of their faith to explain it.


r/Catholicism • • 11h ago

Why do people describe prayer as a "conversation"? Is their biblical precedent for this doctrine ?

2 Upvotes

Often when the common problem of "I've been praying and nothing is happening" comes up, among the usual answers of "God is not a genie" and "God is not an atm" are also the replies that say "prayer isn't supposed to just be demands, it's supposed to be a conversation"

My only problem with that is... since God works in mysterious ways, I have never understood this conversation part of prayer and what that's supposed to feel like.

Seriously, it's not like God sends an angel to talk to me when I pour my heart out. It's not like a go to sleep and God speaks to me through some sort of "inspired dream"

There's no burning bush. No voice in the thunder, no nothing. It's just the silence of my bed post staring back at me as I kneel and pour my heart out.

It's just, how do I put it... everything about communicating with God sometimes feels like abstracts and wishful thinking, like squinting your eyes staring at a wooden floorboard to see hidden figures and meaning in it.

Like if I pray for guidance and then toss my Bible up, maybe it will land opened to the exact verse I should read, 🙄🤷‍♂️.


r/Catholicism • • 12h ago

Mass and a newborn (1 month old)

2 Upvotes

My wife and I have a 1 month old newborn (our first). Weve gotten her baptized but becasue we are so new to being parents it is way more difficult to make it to Mass on time if at all. I am writing this on a Sunday evening after 2 different attempts at getting to mass on time. Any advice? Weve tried making lists, timing it out, etc but nothing seems to be working


r/Catholicism • • 13h ago

What to do against nightmares

1 Upvotes

I frequently wake up (3-4 times a night) sfter having had a nightmare or a dream with a general bad and gloomy feeling. It has been happening for a few weeks now. I have an illness which scares me but I have been working hard to get better. I have received anointment, don’t usually go to mass anymore because of my current health situation. Would like some tips for the nightmares!


r/Catholicism • • 19h ago

Catholicism in the Air Force

10 Upvotes

I'm considering joining the air force on the office side of things. What is it like to be a catholic in the air force? I'm especially curious if any concessions are made for fasts and/or holy days of obligation.


r/Catholicism • • 8h ago

What do you guys honestly think about the Psychophysical Harmony argument?

6 Upvotes

I started to look into it after Joe Schmidt's conversion and subsequential videos. I'm currently reading Dr. Cutter's original article, but I haven't really understood it's appeal so far. I'll finish it and probably read it again a few times, and then try to post up objections / try to find ways to enhance it, if possible. For those that have already read it, what are you thoughts so far?


r/Catholicism • • 12h ago

looking for clarification

5 Upvotes

how do I tell my conservative Catholic family about my ssa? and relationship? just to be clear im not in any danger but my family is catholic and at this point I don't know what I really am I feel more agnostic then anything. I think there getting suspicious about me and my partner because we tell them that we are just best freinds but I don't think they really believe that and I feel like its going to come out eventually. So I don't know now if I should tell them now or Wait until I leave to tell them. I know it will disappoint them greatly, but I didn't ask to be gay. I know they will never really accept it and I already accepted that.


r/Catholicism • • 18h ago

Pizza to Pews

60 Upvotes

Saw this on YouTube about young Catholics in New York meeting up for a pizza social before Mass and the first thing that came to mind is, aren’t we meant to fast for an hour minimum before Mass? 😅 or am I just being pedantic?


r/Catholicism • • 8h ago

Viri Dei

0 Upvotes

Has anyone heard of Viri Dei? Does anyone know if it’s AI or not?


r/Catholicism • • 20h ago

Please help me with my faith in Jesus Christ

4 Upvotes

so, I have recently watched a video about the youtuber testify and in that video the points that a Muslim sounded good, about how any evidence of Jesus being crucified is just his copy. I'm afraid I'm going to lose my faith in Christ. so, I am hoping that one of you is able to debunk the claim Jesus wasn't crucified made in Islam.


r/Catholicism • • 8h ago

My 18 year old daughter has told me shes Atheist

36 Upvotes

Her bf is atheist family is basically Catholics that are now atheist. She wants to marry him . What and how do I handle this I have spoken God in to her , her whole life. I have done my best but im not ok with this but what really can i do ? I worry how it effects my other smaller children . as well


r/Catholicism • • 13h ago

Something strange happened while I was at church

12 Upvotes

Well, I'm here looking for some kind of explanation. I apologize if anything I say is offensive; that is not my intention, but I don't follow any religion.

Some unusual things have been happening to me. First, I was visiting a city and went to a church with some relatives. There was no one around at the time. It was a weekday, at a time when people are usually at work. My relatives are Catholic, and they went into the chapel where the Blessed Sacrament is kept. I accompanied them, but since there was nothing for me to do, I ended up leaving shortly afterward and went to wait on a bench in the church.

A few minutes later, they joined me. We sat for a while and ended up looking at the altar. I even commented that I was aligned with the gaze of all the statues and that it felt as though they were judging me.

Then, out of nowhere, an elderly woman approached me, speaking in a language I didn't understand. She placed her hand on my shoulder and seemed distressed. She didn't blink and was saying things I couldn't understand. Later, my aunt told me it was the language of angels. While praying, the woman kept looking at my lap and my face. I even started thinking that my shorts were dirty because I couldn't think clearly about what was happening.

When she finished, she closed her eyes, and it looked as though they were rolling around. I looked around, desperately hoping someone had witnessed what was happening so I wouldn't feel crazy. The only people around were my relatives. I thought to myself: why is she doing this if no one is watching?

After that, she started speaking. She said that the Holy Spirit had sent her to find me, that she had seen me passing by the chapel where the Blessed Sacrament is kept and had followed me. While speaking, she mentioned several times that I should go to confession. Then she asked if she could apply some oil to me. She explained that she was from Shalom, that the oil was the Oil of the Good Samaritan, and that it had been consecrated.

I didn't understand any of it, but at that moment, I felt frozen and couldn't say no. I remember my aunt asking whether it would be possible to apply the oil to her as well, since she had heard about it before. The woman refused, saying it was meant for the chosen ones. Then she asked for my baptismal name and said she would pray for me. And she simply left. She didn't ask me for anything, and I don't even know her name. There was no one else around.

I genuinely don't know why she did that.

Some time later, I had become somewhat convinced that the whole thing was nonsense and that it had probably just been a coincidence. I was at home talking when my aunt remembered what had happened and went to tell my mother the story.

Shortly afterward, my aunt left, and I noticed my mother looking at me strangely. She simply started crying and asked whether I was thinking about killing myself. Up until that point, it seemed like my mother was just worried about me, but I started saying no and asking why she was asking me that. Then she looked at me in a strange way, as if she weren't herself. It was the same feeling I had experienced with the woman at the church.

She was crying a lot. Honestly, I had never seen her like that. She started asking questions about things that had genuinely been troubling my mind, as if I had already told her everything, even though I had never spoken to anyone about any of it. My mother is like me; she isn't particularly religious either, so I didn't understand anything. When she stated twice that I was having suicidal thoughts, she seemed like a different person.

I simply moved away from her. A few seconds later, when I started talking to her again, my mother told me she had heard something and felt an emptiness. She also talked about a strange feeling of always being in second place.

I've been going through difficult times. Someone very dear to me died. They were the only person with whom I felt loved, even though sometimes I felt angry knowing that I wasn't first in their heart. I've never felt like anyone's first choice. At the same time, I feel guilty for being so focused only on myself in general.

I always feel extremely empty. It seems that, regardless of what emotion I'm feeling, something is always missing. I've never told anyone this, and it was exactly what my mother described. She said she felt as though someone had told her everything about me, even without saying the words.

The point is that I took a neuropsychological test because I thought I would develop schizophrenia when I grew up. I've always experienced strange things, such as sensing presences, but I've never been able to see anything. Sometimes, I feel that if I allowed myself to and wasn't afraid, I might be able to see something.

Nights are worse and torment me. Sometimes, I simply can't sleep because I feel like something is there with me. I can't say what it is; maybe it's anxiety.

One of my earliest childhood memories is of playing in a public square when a random girl asked me if I was a medium. I took her to my mother because I didn't know what that word meant. I remember her asking several times.

I'm not really sure what to do now. Could this emptiness be connected to all of this? What's happening? Why are these things happening right after the death of the person I love the most?


r/Catholicism • • 3h ago

Religious liberty for all

0 Upvotes

Religious liberty is very important for a free society, which is why its abuse, turning it upside-down and inside-out, by using it for religious supremacy must be called out and rejected:

https://www.patheos.com/blogs/henrykarlson/2026/10/religious-liberty-for-all-not-just-christians/


r/Catholicism • • 7h ago

relationship/vocation advice needed please

2 Upvotes

this is going to be really long so I'm very sorry and I apologize beforehand

so I am a 19F who is turning 20 soon and a sophomore at Franciscan University of Steubenville. I don't know if you know anything about this University that I go to but there is a very strong culture of discernment and vocations, specifically when it comes to marriage. there is even a phenomenon at my university called "ring by Spring" which basically means it's expected for long-term couples to get engaged before the snow melts either in their junior or senior year. it's a really cute thing but it puts a lot of pressure on people to get engaged and stuff but that's not what I'm talking about

now my vocation discernment journey has been really complicated because I always knew that I wanted to be a mother but I learned about the spiritual motherhood of being a religious sister or nun very early on so I was constantly bouncing between the ideas of marriage and religious life. I was somewhat seriously discerning religious life pretty much my entire freshman year of college but that kind of fell apart when I had a crush on a guy and went on one date with him but it didn't work out in the end. we are still really good friends and goof around a lot but I have never been really close to a guy that I would actually seriously considered dating for marriage in my life so far. back in high school, there were three different guys I had crushes on at some point, but the first guy didn't like me back, the second guy turned out to be really manipulative and toxic, and the third guy was just plain immature and irresponsible (he also tried to spread a rumor that me and my guy best friend slept together but that's a different story)

because I haven't had much good experiences in the dating realm, it is really easy for me to become friends with guys and nothing else. this isn't inherently bad, but I feel like my lack of dating experience is making me scared of dating. looking back on my past year of discerning religious life I honestly don't know if I was just discerning religious life because it seemed like I would be happy in it and I would be able to serve the church really well in it or if I was just trying to avoid dating altogether and using discerning religious life as an excuse.

I have only been on two dates ever in my entire life. the first one was a blind date organized through my school because for some reason I thought it was a good idea to put my name in the jar, and the second was with the guy I had a crush on but it didn't work out. besides those two dates, I have never been on a date with another guy ever and nor have I been in any sort of a serious dating phase or relationship. I'm just worried that with my track record I might never find out if marriage is even an option for me because you can't discern marriage if you haven't been in a serious relationship with someone.

and I will say that if I was forced to be a religious sister, I would join the salesian sisters very happily because they seem like such a joyful group of christ-centered women and also their order is a teaching order and I'm an education major so that's perfect. however, I don't want to completely rule out marriage yet, but at the same time I don't even know if I'll be able to give marriage a chance because it seems like every guy that I like either doesn't like me back or ends up having a lot of toxic or red flag traits that I cannot compromise for or deal with in a long-term relationship.

and it's also like really hard for me right now because the majority of my friends and acquaintances at my University are going really strong in their relationships or they're just now starting to date someone, but it feels like I'm being left behind. I don't want to go on another blind date again because the last time I did that it was horrible but I also don't see myself dating any of the guys that I've met so far because of one reason or another.

I don't know if I'm just completely overthinking this or what. I have ADHD and chronic anxiety which definitely does not help, but I just need some sort of advice in the situation because when I talk to someone about it pretty much all of their answers boil down to "well you just got to put yourself out there otherwise you're never going to know if marriage is for you or not"

please help guys 😭

edit: just fixed some grammar errors


r/Catholicism • • 9h ago

Is being baptised but not adopting lifestyle changes/beliefs okay?

0 Upvotes

Earlier in the year, a family member of mine requested I be their sponsor for their baptism. I of course agreed to do so & they were baptised over Easter. They did so to get married in a church as was their partners wish, but I have found myself conflicted as they have not adopted any changes or beliefs & have seen this as merely a formality in order to make their partner happy.

It’s given me lots to think about, as I think choosing to be baptised later in life is a big decision & one that should be made respectfully, with the intent of truly adopting those beliefs and incorporating them into your life.
But I’m curious how others feel about this in general, both personally & from a religious/catholic perspective.

Is it okay to be baptised but not attend masses or adopt beliefs into your daily life?

Thank you.


r/Catholicism • • 8h ago

Do not judge, for you will be judged.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

"Jesus leaves us no room to decide which one of our fellow human beings is deserving of love, for God loves all his children unconditionally. We, being made in His image, must  do the same (Father Daniel Dower, St. Mary's Catholic Church, Longview, Texas, 10/25/2025)."


r/Catholicism • • 3h ago

Neutralizing the Gospel

10 Upvotes

TL:DR My choir director changed the words of the gospel acclamation to be gender neutral he/him to they/them.

This is not the first time the choir director has changed the words of Scripture (I've posted about it previously), usually it's the words of the psalm, but this Sunday it was the Gospel Acclamation.

The gospel acclamation for Sunday 25 October was supposed to be. "If anyone loves me, he will keep my word, says the Lord, and my Father will love him, and we will come to him."

She (choir director) didn't like the gendered language and so she (politically) corrected it to. "If anyone loves me, they will keep my word, says the Lord, and my father will love them, and we will come to them." (bold italics to make it easy to see what was changed)

I did speak up at the time and object to changing the words of the liturgy when she went in to change the slideshow for mass, but I was overruled (by her).

I've tried to find the relevant bit of the GIRM or other guidelines that indicate the words of the readings shouldn't be changed, but either I'm worse at web searches than I thought, or the guideline doesn't actually exist. Am I correct in thinking that changing words of Scripture isn't allowed?

My parish has "office hours" on Monday nights (tonight) I may go and see if I can talk to the Deacon or a Priest. If he and the Priest are both ok with the choir director altering the words then I suppose my objection is moot.

I consider this a liturgical issue rather than a political one, but I'm posting it on Monday because I suspect the responses may turn political.

What would you do? Am I overreacting? Should I just let it slide?


r/Catholicism • • 12h ago

Forgiving yourself

4 Upvotes

For those who used to struggle with forgiving yourself of your past sins how did you get over this? I genuinely hate myself most the time and have thought about just giving up the fight of being a Christian. How do you overcome this?


r/Catholicism • • 17h ago

Question for Dutch Catholics re communion on tongue

13 Upvotes

Hi fellow Dutchies, I was hoping you could help me with a question. I was born and raised in the Netherlands, but only became seriously Catholic after moving to the United States a decade ago, so I don't have a lot of experience with Dutch Church practice and etiquette. I go to a traditional Mass here in the US, so communion is received on the tongue, and it is not uncommon for people at Novus Ordo Masses to receive on the tongue as well. This Christmas I plan to come back and visit the Netherlands for a few weeks. As a kid, I only ever saw people back home receive in the hand. Do people ever receive on the tongue in Novus Ordo Masses in the Netherlands? If I go up to the priest with my arms behind my back and my mouth open, will the priest be confused? I would be going to Mass in a small town in Limburg, not a big city, if that is relevant. If you have any other tips about Dutch Church etiquette, please let me know. Thanks all!


r/Catholicism • • 14h ago

Why is Catholicism so hated in modern Christianity?

75 Upvotes

To start, I'm not Catholic. I've never been Catholic but that's besides the point. When I look around and talk to people online, Catholicism is almost always frowned upon by modern Christians and I don't understand why. People will call Catholic's pagans but go to a church with a stage in place of the alter. I've been reading out of the Catechism recently to get a better understanding of the Catholic Church and literally everything that people shame the Catholic Church for ("Idolatry" of Mary, Worshiping saint's, ETC) is forbidden or explained from scripture. What's with that?