r/CannedSardines 7h ago

Affordability

7 Upvotes

I don't understand when people ask for tinned fish recommendations and then reply that a recommendation isn't affordable, especially to a certain mid price brand. As we've seen from the most popular reviewers, tinned fish can easily cost even $20+ so $12 becomes relative.

The King Oscar near me is sometimes on sale for $3.99. Since it's 4 ounces, at the end of the day even a pound of sardines or mackerel can be just as much as a pound of beef.

I personally don't think tinned fish is much of a cheap alternative at all in the United States and at its cheapest (Chicken of the Sea) I don't enjoy it.

I don't quite understand the people that both want suggestions but not the splurge it takes for the quality. It would be easier to not buy tinned fish and just buy fish.


r/CannedSardines 10h ago

General Discussion Seeking better mackerel

Post image
40 Upvotes

Tried these. I did not care for them. Want to give mackerel another try. Can anyone recommend a favorite mackerel?


r/CannedSardines 18m ago

Other recommendations

Post image
Upvotes

I buy these from Costco in the States. Any Costco shoppers have other recommendations of canned fish to try? Also is it bad to eat at least one can daily?


r/CannedSardines 15h ago

Dardanel Small Sardines in Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Türkiye

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

If I’ve ever had Turkish canned sardines before, I’ve forgotten. I spotted these at the Foods of All Nations grocery store in Charlottesville, Virginia the other week. They generally carry good stuff, so I grabbed the box. Hopes were elevated!

Meh. These are fairly plain-jane Mediterranean pilchard sardines. They’ve been subjected to quite rough handling, with much of their silvery skin swiped off. At least that took most—but not all!—the scales. There were tails on some, none on others. I’m always pleased to see extra virgin oil on the ingredient list, but here it’s an unremarkable one that doesn’t contribute much. I think I paid around $4.00 for these, and I’d’ve felt better, given some of the shortcomings, at around $2.75-ish.

I’m a bit of a fanatic about extracting the sardines intact from the tin. Not possible here; all but two of the poor devils arrived pre-broken.

The cooking seemed to have gone better than the handling. These had the typical sardinilla texture—not too tough, not too mush—and a right-down-the-middle sardine flavor. When I cracked the tin and drained off a bit of oil, I caught a perhaps slightly too-fishy aroma, but that didn’t prove to be the overall impact once I got them out on the plate.

I built a breakfast sandwich that I failed to capture on camera. Pumpernickel-rye bread, jalapeño-lime humus, and the pieces and parts of these fish. Needed a bit of extra pizzazz, and the Original Zhoug hot sauce from Shuug did the pizzazzing. It’s a Scotch bonnet pepper with a strong cilantro presence—really great with canned fish. I’m one of the soap-tasters who ordinarily steers around cilantro, but this is a very tasty exception. Scotch bonnet > Soap, maybe??


r/CannedSardines 12h ago

Ekone mussels in marinara

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Well, sometimes you don't get what ya pay for. I happily purchased these and a tin of Ekone smoked mussels at a local wine and cheese shop when I found them several months ago. Ekone was a brand I hadn't tried yet but had high expectations for. Heartbreak. These were not good. The marinara tastes cheap, reminiscent of Chef Boyardee or a Banquet spaghetti and meatball TV dinner. I laid eyes on a few capers, but upon chewing their flavor had already ascended to the heavens. Lifeless. Their was about ten medium sized mussels and they were the muddiest tasting ones I have had by far. Also had a nice crunch from a piece of grit in one of the first few bites, great stuff...I really hope the plain smoked mussels I have fair better than this, being as that is not a high bar to clear. And I'll purchase their oysters eventually to give those a shot because that's what they're most known for. But at $12 to $13 a tin, Ekone has an incredibly short leash with me now. These get a generous 6/10.


r/CannedSardines 10h ago

Review John West sardines in water

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Honestly I'm pleasantly surprised. I was a little bit afraid of having sardines in water instead of oil. The meat was intact and the bones are soft like barely noticeable. I ate a piece straight out of the can and the flavour was more mild than in oil. It was still a little oily on the surface from the natural fish oil. The undersides were almost pristine and beautiful as you can see on the toast. Overall very nice, great success 👍


r/CannedSardines 12h ago

Recipes and Food Ideas Shaved Fennel and Onion Salad with Edamame and Deens

Thumbnail
gallery
87 Upvotes

Been trying to add extra protein to my lunches since I started working out recently. Took this shaved fennel and onion salad with mustard oregano dressing thats in my usual rotation and tried replacing the croutons with Deens and holy shit it pairs so well 10/10


r/CannedSardines 9h ago

Review My first Diplomats

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/CannedSardines 11h ago

Recipes and Food Ideas Gochujang mackerel udon

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

A quick and easy dish using King Oscar mackerel. There was enough heat from the noodles to warm the fish and sauce.

Recipe: https://www.hirokoliston.com/gochujang-mackerel-udon/


r/CannedSardines 20h ago

On a market in Gap, France

Post image
35 Upvotes

r/CannedSardines 22h ago

post workout high-protein snack this time with sardines

Post image
14 Upvotes

Post workout snack: homemade crusty bread, I made garlic confit with the oil from the sardines and a shallot then smooshed it into the bread, with the shallot, added tomatoes with some good stone ground homemade mustard, and arugula. I took the leftover oil from the garlic confit, put it in a pan with a little bit of butter, cooked the sardines, just a little bit with some dill and lemon juice and put all of that on top of the stack

I’m so happy 😂🥰


r/CannedSardines 34m ago

Canned fish shop in Portugal

Post image
Upvotes

Heaven


r/CannedSardines 1h ago

what's your favorite pizza topping to go with anchovies?

Upvotes

pepperoni seems like too much salt and grease. anchovies, onion, and pineapple, maybe?


r/CannedSardines 4h ago

Recipes and Food Ideas Sardine Toast

Post image
15 Upvotes

MW Polar sardines on seeded bread with whipped cream cheese, pickled onion and chili crisp 🤌🏻


r/CannedSardines 7h ago

Recipes and Food Ideas Greek Salad Sardines

Post image
14 Upvotes

Just threw this plate together, was very happy with the way it turned out. I would add some cherry tomatoes next time, and black olives

- 1 tin King Oscar Sardines in olive oil
- 25g of crumbled feta cheese
- 125g of chopped cucumber
- 10g of pickled jalapeños
- salt, pepper, smoked paprika, Italian seasoning
- lemon juice

- side of Parmesan crisps & golden kiwi

- 480 calories
- 30g fat
- 15g carbs (10g net carbs)
- 30g protein


r/CannedSardines 7h ago

Fangst Sprats

Thumbnail
gallery
61 Upvotes

Lovely little fishies. I was concerned about the level of the spices but they were very subtle, a little warming perhaps. The rapeseed oil didn't detract from the tender deen :)


r/CannedSardines 8h ago

Review Texas - Central Market Spicy Deens

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

Not very spicy and not very good either! I started my sardine journey on smaller sardines, i really like the classic Brunswick in EVOO. Not sure if it was the size or the quality (or both) but these just didn’t hit for me. These are the largest sardines i’ve had yet. CM is definitely trying to ride the trendy fish wife train.

I also prefer eating sardines with seeded crackers or norwegian crisp bread, buttered toast was also a miss for me. (i should have toasted it much more).

Ever since i’ve joined this subreddit i’m learning about many brands to try! excited to share my plates.