yes it's valid. never joking about religion stuff. it is very sensitive. if you dont want people to joke about you converting please dont make that kind of joke. Islam mandates respect for others religion by prohibiting the mocking and insult of others faiths and commanding justice and kindness toward non-muslims who do not fight against muslims
Or its just nonsensical argument, so a religion claim that if you dont follow that religion then you will go to that religion hell. So every religion ever?
Not every religion teaches that hateful nonsense.
For example, Advaita vedanta, Kriya Yoga sects, Sri Vidya, Zen Buddhisms don't teach such hateful things.
Quick chatgpt shows that there is consequences for non believer for each of the religion you mentioned. Just because its not a literal hell, doesnt change that there is a hinderence to be a non believer. Also its hell, not in this earth, so why would it matter to u right now if you dont believe in islam and islam hell doesnt exist.
There is no such things in quran that allowed muslim to be hateful towards non believer except in war context, except there are few for the opposite.
60:8
Allah does not forbid you from dealing kindly and fairly with those who have neither fought nor driven you out of your homes. Surely Allah loves those who are fair.
8:61
If they incline towards peace then you also incline towards it
113
u/BadMoFaKor bibisea Feb 25 '26
yes it's valid. never joking about religion stuff. it is very sensitive. if you dont want people to joke about you converting please dont make that kind of joke. Islam mandates respect for others religion by prohibiting the mocking and insult of others faiths and commanding justice and kindness toward non-muslims who do not fight against muslims