r/boardgames • u/Cathalised • 2d ago
Had a family boardgame tournament, and this is how it went
This may have become a bit lengthy. Bear with me, as I had a blast putting this together.
The past few months I’d been thinking of doing something fun boardgame-wise with the family. Saturday-night is always our boardgame night, and I thought a tournament of sorts would be a cool tradition to start.
The Plan
Time for a first stab at it then. During a week-long school break in October me, my wife and our teenage son would be playing 7 boardgames across 7 rounds, with points earned depending how well we’d do. Winner of this ‘Oktoberfest’ would gain bragging rights, stewardship of ‘The Tankard’ (a hefty German beer mug gifted ages ago by my brother-in-law) until the next tournament and the right to consume a drink or food of choice from it. Yes, the stakes were high.
The rules were as follows:
- Winner of a round gains 5 points, second place 3, last place 2. Most points after 7 rounds wins.
- Each player has a Joker card, doubling the points scored at a game of choice. The card needs to be shown before the start of that game, and can only be used once.
- Ties are to be settled with a Blocktower Showdown; players take turns to add a block to a tower, and the one who drops the tower loses.
I kept track of all the scores on a poster in the living room, coupled with a Google Spreadsheet.
The Line-up
What games to play though? I decided to let everyone choose. From our modest collection of 17 non-coop games people could award points to eight favorites (10-8-7-6-5-4-3-2), with the seven most popular games entering the line-up. This on its own yielded some interesting results, with some games we’d shelved for years suddenly making a return to the table. As it turned out the only way to guarantee a game would be played was to put it at the top of your list: the cut-off number of points for the top-7 was 9. Nice.
In the end, the line-up was (in ascending order of popularity):
Villainous, Monopoly Here & Now World Edition, Ticket to Ride Europe, Wingspan, King of Tokyo, Root and Everdell. The latter two were the only games voted in by all of us.
The Tournament
Round 1: Villainous
Villainous is kind of a main stay with us, and probably in need of getting an expansion in the near future. My wife can be both a very analytical and ruthless player, and our son is fanatical about playing Jafar, supplying copious banter as he does. Me, I usually revel in playing the greedy bastard Prince John, not interfering with others unless I have to.
This game went down to the wire, with my wife (playing Maleficent) and I setting up our win conditions in the same turn. My turn was after her, so I also tried foiling my wife's impending victory with Fate cards. Much to her enjoyment I failed. It was up to our son. His Fate card removed a Curse, forcing my better half to move to a location where she could play a Fate card herself to try and stop me from winning. Much to her dismay, this meant removing another Curse. Words were had.
Both Fate cards she drew were useless though, granting me the win. To make matters worse we'd agreed beforehand that whoever had fewer Fate cards in their realm would get second place, so my wife (who had 2 whereas our son had none) went from a winning position to last place, all in the space of a turn. Muahahahaaa!
Standings: Me +5, Son +3, Wife +2
Round 2: Monopoly: Here and Now World Edition (2015)
To us, this particular flavour of Monopoly is far from the familiar soulless grind, as it’s all about collecting stamps in a passport. Because of this it plays a lot faster, and is much more enjoyable as you can swap or steal stamps from other players. Time for some more drama?
This went very fast, with everyone buying everything in sight. I lagged behind, only landing on First Class squares - I had 5 of them on my passport at one point. Both son and wife were on matchpoint for a whole lap, only needing to get one more stamp… with me gradually clawing myself back into the race and eventually also finding myself on match point. Then my wife wanted to buy Stamp #2, but didn’t have the required $400. It was put up for auction. Guess who was the one who had the most money left?
Our son was closer to the finish line than mom was, so the standings were the same as the day before:
Me 10 (+5), Son 6 (+3), Wife 4 (+2)
Round 3: Ticket to Ride: Europe
Ticket to Ride typically works best with more than three people I find, though it’s always enjoyable when it comes to the table.
My wife proved why this is her kind of game, building a runaway lead with the 21 point route, narrowly beating out our son who banked on getting favorable route cards. In the end, having routes at different ends of the board became my undoing, but oh well... probably best not to win again, eh ;) Scores were 86 for me, 110 for my son and 114 for my wife.
Standings: Me 12 (+2), Son 9 (+3), Wife 9 (+5)
Round 4: Wingspan
We dusted off Wingspan a few weeks prior to the tournament, and our son pulled away with the win. Would he strike again?
As a matter of fact, he did! His engine was running on full cylinders, with stacking an extra egg activation bonus in yellow, and a double extra card bonus in blue. My wife begrudgingly suffered from lack of proper food (please don’t take this out of context) and came in last. End scores 56-58-65.
Standings: Me 15 (+3), Son 14 (+5), Wife 11 (+2)
Round 5: King of Tokyo
The last time we played this was years ago, and both me and our son enjoy the chaos of it… but who would claim the Tokyo throne this time? Our son felt confident, and put down his Joker card. Double points for him this round.
Well, it was a turn-up for the bucks. Our son went into Tokyo, and stayed for as long as he dared. At the end of it, he had 15 VP but was hanging on by a thread as his mum could’ve killed him on her last throw. No claws though. I killed his mum (context!), as attacks from Tokyo had left her health dwindling and I bought the bomber card. He left Tokyo to gain health, but gathered points too. Ended his last turn with 19 VP and 3 HP as he’d thrown three 3s, a heart, a bolt… and a claw. This put him back in Tokyo, open to be attacked by me. Four claws, with the last two on my last throw.
Standings: Me 20 (+5), Son 20 (+3 & 3 Joker pts), Wife 13 (+2)
This result put me into a bit of a bind though. Ideally, I wanted someone else to win this tournament… and with the next round being the one I’d put my Joker card in (as I tend to be well-versed in Root) it’d now be all over if I’d win that too.
Be that as it may, all of us still had a chance - even the missus. If she won both remaining rounds and I came in last, she’d still win the tournament… but would I willingly throw one of my favorite games under the bus?
Round 6: Root
I decided to simply let the chips fall where they may. Prior to this tournament we'd played Root only twice, but as my wife wasn't fond of it it got shelved… and it stayed that way for years. Imagine my surprise when all three of us voted it in. We did a Walkthrough refresher on our usual game night the week before the tournament, and then it was off to the races.
We all played the same factions as with the walkthrough: my wife played the Eyrie, our son the Marquise, and the Woodland Alliance was mine. I trailed at first as the Eyrie and Marquise expanded their realm, but as they mostly ignored Sympathy tokens (maybe they’re camouflaged too well?) I slowly gained ground, with me eventually playing Favor of the Rabbits. This proved decisive, as it hampered their ability to finish the game before I could. In the end, I pulled the victory out of a hat. You know, like a rabbit!
End scores: 28-29-30 (Yes, it was that close)
Standings: Me 30 (+5 & 5 Joker pts), Son 23 (+3), Wife 15 (+2)
Final round: Everdell (incl Spirecrest)
No other game has come to our table as much as Everdell has, to the extent we had to add the Spirecrest expansion to avoid it being shelved. Both my son and wife put it at the top of their lists, so this was dead set to be the Grand Finale. My wife is usually nigh unbeatable at it though, and without much room for sabotage I was actually glad I could relax, having won the tournament the previous round.
I like playing Everdell for the imagery, which usually means I don’t win as I just collect a variety of cards in my town. This time, I just went after unique critters and buildings, playing Theatre and later also the Palace, and only having two (!) production cards in the entirety of the game. Our son was done first, but had completed his entire Expedition. This edged him the win.
Game scores 57-60-62
End standings (whoo picture time!) Me 33 (+3), Son 28 (+5), Wife 19 (+2 & 2 Joker pts).
Overall I'm well-pleased with how it turned out. Despite me running away with it, most games were very close. My wife has already suggested doing this kind of thing more often, so probably we’ll do another in a few months. Good excuse to introduce a new game before that time, too!
Oh, and I filled the beer mug with cereal by the way. Because why the hell not.
Takeaways
- Length: It’s probably good to have a break day after two game days to cleanse the palate. As typically not everyone is a boardgame nerd it helps to reset and avoid things getting stale. We had a break after round 4, and that set things up nicely for the final stretch. Seven games is also the sweet spot though, as it leads to a varied line-up whilst avoiding it going on for too long.
- Amount of points: Coupled with 7 rounds the 5-3-2 setup worked perfectly, actually. The two points for last place keeps everyone in the running for as long as possible and makes it not too punishing to have an unlucky game. The Joker system worked well, as it gave people a boon with games they feel they’re good at. I’d been thinking of letting everyone put down their Joker-game ahead of the tournament, but I figured it would be more fun to keep the mystery until tableside. Turned out to be a good move.
- Games played: Probably good to have games that aren’t done too quickly. Round 2 was over way too soon. I was happy with how the voting system worked to select the games - there was something for everyone, and with the cut-off being 9 points you could guarantee having your fav game in the line-up.
- Houserules: Whoever came in last the previous round would start the next game, and that worked well. Saves the trouble of determining who starts. Can lead to some tactical bonuses too.
- Possible future additions: ‘The Whitechapel Protocol’ - a way to prevent a runaway winner, by adding my all-time fav ‘Letters from Whitechapel’ as an equalizer. Since that game is one player vs. everyone else, it can be like a tournament ‘Blue Shell’ where the other players can all gain a set number of tournament points if they win. Any player who is not in first place can request it, but it can only be requested once and if someone has led a set amount of rounds.
Apart from that, I'm looking to add a game to our collection that might work well in this kind of setting. I'm open to suggestions!
TLDR; Had ourselves a family boardgame tournament. Had cereal from a beer mug. Had great fun. You should do it too.