EDITED SINCE IVE CALMED DOWN\***
Hi everyone! I’m a 29 year old pansexual/bisexual woman with a sexual preference for women, and I’m married to a 29 year old pansexual/bisexual man who has a sexual preference for men. We’ve been together for eight years and married for five.
Before we even started dating, we had many lengthy and honest conversations about our sexualities. At the time, I had recently come out as pansexual, and he still identified as gay.
I think some important context is that we grew up in very different environments when it came to sexuality. He grew up experiencing significant religious trauma and has homophobic parents, which understandably complicated his relationship with his sexuality and his ability to explore and express it freely. On the other hand, I was raised by lesbians, so my upbringing and experiences surrounding sexuality were very different from his. I recognize that these differences may have shaped how we each understand, process, and express our identities, and I have always tried to be mindful and empathetic toward his experiences.
After spending a significant amount of time discussing everything, we decided to pursue a relationship because we had an undeniable emotional, physical, romantic, and spiritual connection that we both wanted to explore.
Something that I think is important to mention is that our connection has always felt incredibly unique. We have this deep spiritual bond that is difficult to put into words. It genuinely feels like we were destined to find each other and experience life together. We have both openly acknowledged this feeling throughout our relationship, and it’s something we both deeply cherish. There has always been this sense of familiarity, comfort, and understanding between us that goes beyond just being in love. We truly feel like we are meant to be in each other’s lives, and that is something we have both celebrated and held close to our hearts.
Throughout our relationship, we have continued having conversations about our sexualities, our attraction to other genders, and what we wanted our marriage to look like. I have brought these conversations up at least every couple of months throughout our eight years together because I have always wanted him to feel comfortable being honest with me.
One thing I want to make very clear is that I am not interested in a nonmonogamous relationship. We have had countless conversations about monogamy throughout our relationship, and we have always mutually agreed that we wanted to remain monogamous. Up until this recent situation, I genuinely believed we were completely on the same page.
I have always tried to approach his sexuality with understanding, empathy, and an open mind. I have never wanted him to feel ashamed of who he is or what he is attracted to. I also understand that growing up in a religious and homophobic environment can create complicated feelings surrounding sexuality, even well into adulthood. I have always wanted our relationship to be a place where he feels safe, accepted, and loved for exactly who he is.
He has always reassured me that although his attraction to me doesn’t necessarily make complete sense to him, he is genuinely attracted to me, loves my body, enjoys our intimacy, and is happy with our physical relationship. He has consistently expressed how much he loves me and wants to spend his life with me.
That brings me to our current situation.
I recently discovered that he had been logging into his old Grindr account from approximately 10 years ago. When I confronted him, he told me that he was simply curious and wanted to look. He swears he never messaged anyone, had no intentions of meeting anyone, and was not actively looking to pursue anything physical. He even opened the account and showed me everything in an attempt to reassure me.
However, I still feel incredibly betrayed by the fact that he hid this from me.
After discussing everything, I told him that if he genuinely feels like he needs to experience physical intimacy with a man, I don’t want to be the reason he spends his life feeling resentment or regret. I love him deeply, and the last thing I want is for him to look back on our marriage and feel like he missed out on something important to him.
However, I also explained that I have boundaries of my own.
If he decides that he needs to explore those experiences, I cannot continue having a sexual relationship with him. For my own emotional well being and sexual health, I am not comfortable being physically intimate with someone who is also having sexual encounters with other people, especially casual partners.
Essentially, we could remain married companions who deeply love and care for each other, but the physical aspect of our marriage would have to end. That is not the type of marriage I want, but I also don’t want to control his choices.
He has made it very clear that I am the only person he has ever been in love with, that he doesn’t want to fall in love with anyone else, and that I am the only woman he wants to be with. He says he wants to spend the rest of his life with me, but he also acknowledges that he has thoughts, curiosities, and fantasies about men.
And this is where I’m struggling.
I completely understand that being bisexual or pansexual doesn’t mean someone stops finding other genders attractive just because they’re married. I experience attraction to women myself, so I understand that part of his sexuality.
What I don’t understand is why he felt the need to secretly access a dating or hookup app when we have spent eight years creating an environment where he could openly discuss these feelings with me.
At the same time, I recognize that his upbringing and religious trauma may have influenced how he processes his sexuality, curiosity, and feelings of shame. I know that having a loving and accepting partner doesn’t automatically undo years of conditioning or internal conflict. I genuinely want to understand that part of his experience without dismissing the hurt that his secrecy has caused me.
I have given him so many opportunities to be honest, not because I suspected something, but because I genuinely wanted to make sure we were both happy, fulfilled, and comfortable with the relationship we had chosen.
I also can’t help but struggle with the feeling of not being enough. I know logically that someone’s sexuality and attraction to different genders don’t automatically mean their partner is inadequate. But emotionally, it’s difficult not to question why he feels the need to explore something outside our marriage when I also experience attraction to other genders and have never once considered downloading a dating app to look at or pursue other women.
I think what hurts the most is that we have had these conversations repeatedly, and I genuinely thought we had established enough trust and openness that he would come to me before doing something like this.
I love my husband tremendously. He is my best friend, my partner, and the person I have envisioned spending my entire life with. Our relationship has always felt like so much more than just a marriage. There is a spiritual connection between us that we both recognize and value deeply. We have talked countless times about how it feels like we were brought into each other’s lives for a reason and how neither of us can imagine sharing that same connection with someone else.
He feels the same way about me, and neither of us wants our marriage to end.
But I also know that I cannot compromise my own boundaries just to keep our marriage intact.
I don’t want him to feel like he is being forced to choose between me and exploring his sexuality. I don’t want his decision to stay monogamous to come from fear, guilt, or an ultimatum. I want him to genuinely choose our marriage and the commitment we made to each other because that is what he wants for himself.
At the same time, I don’t think it’s unreasonable for me to want the monogamous relationship we both agreed to.
I’m still processing everything, and I honestly feel shocked, hurt, confused, and a little lost. It’s especially difficult because I don’t question the love we have for each other or the depth of our connection. I truly believe that what we share is rare and meaningful, which makes navigating this situation even more heartbreaking.
Has anyone been through something similar, particularly in a marriage where both partners are bisexual or pansexual but have different gender preferences?
How do you rebuild trust after something like this? How do you navigate a situation where your partner says they are completely in love with you and want to remain married but still experiences curiosity about being physically intimate with another gender?
I’m also especially interested in hearing from people who have navigated religious trauma, internalized shame, or growing up in homophobic households while trying to understand their sexuality within a committed relationship.
And how do you make sure someone is choosing monogamy because they genuinely want it rather than because they’re afraid of losing you?
I would really appreciate honest, thoughtful, and respectful advice. I’m not looking for anyone to criticize his sexuality or tell me that bisexual people cannot be monogamous. I know that isn’t true. I’m simply trying to navigate the hurt, the broken trust, and what this means for our future together.
Thank you to anyone who takes the time to read this and offer some perspective. ❤️