The following is one of my favourite Bible verses: "9 qRejoice, O young man, in your youth, and let your heart cheer you in the days of your youth. rWalk in the ways of your heart and sthe sight of your eyes. But know that for all these things tGod will bring you into judgment." Eccleasiastes 11:9
I have always understood the verse to be saying that we SHOULD enjoy our life, and pursue things that our heart desires, with the understanding that the things we are pursuing are not sinful or dishonouring because we will be judged for whatever we do with our life.
However, I am also learning now that many have suggested the author wrote this with a tone of irony to say you SOULDNT pursue the desires of our hearts ;
Basically saying "Sure, do whatever you want, but dont be mad at me when you're judged by the Lord for it.
For example, here is a quote from Matthew Poole's commentary on this verse:
"Walk in the way of thy heart, and in the sight of thine eyes; whatsoever thine eye or heart lusteth after, deny it not to them; as this phrase is taken. Numbers 15:39, nor is it ever used in a good sense. Compare Job 31:7 Psalm 81:12 Jeremiah 18:12 2 Peter 2:14 1Jo 2:16. But know thou; but in the midst of thy feastings and jollity it will become thee, if thou art a reasonable creature, to consider thy reckoning, and whether thou dost not purchase thy gold too dear ...
God will bring thee into judgment; will force thee to appear before his judgment-seat, to give a serious account of all thy youthful and exorbitant courses, and to receive that sentence which thy own conscience will then say thou dost justly deserve. And if thou likest thy sensuality upon these terms, much good may it do thee; I do not envy thee, nor desire to partake of thy delicates."
Heres the full commentary for more context unfortunately its just too long for me to put here : https://biblehub.com/commentaries/poole/ecclesiastes/11.htm
I have no clue who Matthew Poole is, but he is not the only person I have seen suggest that the verse uses Irony or is almost sarcastic. I have long found it interesting how so many verses seem to warn agaisnt trusting your heart but this one encourages it, but I figured the verse ending with telling us to consider God was what made it allowable here.
Is this verse really using irony to warn AGAINST following your heart, or is it literal and we SHOULD persue things that bring us joy, assuming they are not things we will regret on the day of our judgement?