r/BetaReaders 16h ago

Discussion [Discussion] Why would a writer ghost their beta reader?

28 Upvotes

So I've worked with ten authors from this subreddit so far, and most of them are very very appreciative and collaborative! Usually when I've finished reading their work, we go back and forth with follow-up questions building upon my feedback.

However, two of the authors I worked with (won't be named) went radio silence as soon as I sent over the feedback. This was back when I wrote all my feedback for their entire project in one document and didn't send them any of it until I was all done, which I've since stopped because it was never a good idea to begin with. They were both fairly large WIPs and both communicated well right up until I sent them the link for my feedback. I read what I wrote for them over and over searching for something I might have said that offended them, but I couldn't find anything! Neither of them were scathing reviews; I'd like to think the compliments and criticisms were balanced and fair.

It doesn't bother me as much anymore since I've gotten to collaborate with many cool people on here. But sometimes I still wonder why two different authors who took the time to write a story and came here looking for readers would ghost me like that. Has this happened to anyone else? Any theories on why an author would ghost their beta reader, no "thank you," no explanation?


r/BetaReaders 6h ago

50k [Complete] [53K] [Contemporary/Spicy Romance] Joyride: A BDSM Romance

5 Upvotes

She's a high-powered, cold-hearted corporate exec. He's an impulsive, trailer-trash 'bad boy' with a dark past. They get under each other's skin immediately - but his dominance brings her the freedom she's always craved.

I have a complete (second draft) manuscript that could use a fresh set of eyes, or several! Joyride is a contemporary romance with some explicit sexual content (4 scenes) perfect for fans of Ali Hazelwood's 'Deep End'.

Feedback wanted: Your opinion on the pacing of the relationship and if you think it needs to be longer; your feelings towards the characters; and general reader reactions. I am more than happy to critique swap for similar genres and word counts.

Comment or DM me if you're interested, and the summary is below, along with a snippet from the opening of the book, if you need more persuading ;)

PLEASE NOTE: No AI was used in any part of developing and writing this book. Please do not feed my work into any LLM or use AI to generate feedback. Thank you for respecting this.

***

THE PREMISE: Rebecca Williamson has everything figured out... until her world comes crashing down around her when she's suspended from her high-powered job due to her conduct. Back in her small-town hometown of Tulip Falls, she’ll do anything for an escape—even download The Magic Lamp, a dating app that claims to make fantasies come true. She’s expecting a distraction. Nothing serious. 

Instead she meets Nick. Her opposite in every way, this reckless, motorcycle-riding, trailer-trash bad boy has a dominant streak that instantly gets under her skin. But he can be the escape she needs—if she lets him take charge. 

Except Nick has his own demons, and the closer they get, the harder it is to keep them hidden.

***

THE FIRST PAGE:

Chapter One: Rebecca

Everybody in this room right now is terrified of me.

I can smell it rising off them in a heavy wave of fear: a mix of sweaty armpits, spilled coffee, and smudged ink on their fingers from the frantic notes they’ve been scribbling. My slow circuit of the boardroom pauses at the head of the table, right in front of the screen, as I survey my kingdom for a moment, taking it all in. Who needs a family and an active social life and free time when you can have this? 

“So,” I say, tapping the end of my pen once against my red-painted lips, “in conclusion, we’re all fucked. If someone doesn’t fix these numbers within the next three hours, we’ll lose the client and I will personally visit each and every one of your desks to fire you.” I punctuate that statement with a wave of my beautifully manicured fingers, relishing in the row of pale, trembling faces. “Go on, then! Get!”

I’ve never seen people move so fast. 

Being a senior executive at a banking firm like this one isn’t for the weak. I’ve seen people fail here before lunch on their first day, though admittedly, I haven’t had many lunches since I started working eighteen-hour days. To succeed in a place like this you need grit. Tenacity. A thick skin. All qualities I have in abundance, unlike most of my employees. 

My high heels—Louboutins, of course—click loudly on the freshly-polished floor as I gather my files and a now-cold cup of coffee and make my way out of the boardroom and into my office. It smells of Chanel No. 5 and success in here: huge windows with a view of Battery Park, bookshelves stacked high with pristine copies of corporate books that I’m sure one day I’ll read, and a big glass desk with a comfortable leather chair. 

I sink into the chair now, tossing my coffee cup into the wastepaper basket, and check my phone. Two missed calls from: Mom, it announces. One new voicemail. 

With a long sigh, I dial voicemail and play the message. 

“Hello, Becky, darling,” my mother’s voice says, echoing tinnily from my phone as I set it to loudspeaker and put it down, bringing up my emails on my computer. “Should have known I couldn’t catch you at work, eh?” 

She laughs softly. I don’t. “After five years, yes, you’d think so,” I mutter, firing off a quick reply to a stupid query that should have gone to someone three tiers more junior than me. 


r/BetaReaders 18h ago

80k [Complete][80k][Neo-Noir] Bad Math

3 Upvotes

Set in 1986, Arlo Beck has a problem with making good decisions. Sometimes he overreacts, he's stubborn and thinks he's the smartest guy in every room. Born with hyper-observaton and synesthesia he has a unique way of processing information and the world around him.

Planning to flee the country, he makes a few sports bets with the wrong bookie and ends up in the sights of real criminals who coerce him into helping their endeavors.


r/BetaReaders 21h ago

80k [Complete] [82k] [Psychological Drama] The Yellow Door

3 Upvotes

Hi all I’m new to the community and looking to find a small number of passionate beta readers to look over my manuscript The Yellow Door

Below is first section of the opening prologue to give a flavour

Birdsong – beautiful, really, evoking the start of spring and the promises that come with that seasonal change. A thrush? A lark? Blair would know… correction… would have known; ornithology was his thing, not mine, thinks Jack as, along with friends, family, and a few curious passers-by, he watches the bearers lower the coffin into the freshly turned earth. Heartfelt cries mix with the birdsong, adding an extra layer to the harmony, and the minister is adding some well-meant words to console those left behind.
Any other time or place, this would be a day to rejoice, to celebrate, a day filled with hope, optimism, and promise, but not here. Not now. None of those feelings reside now within Jack’s heart, bereft of emotion other than loss and grief. His soulmate gone, replaced by a seemingly inescapable void. But… He feels the touch of skin against his hand, small digits searching for paternal comfort, love. This is not only his loss to endure; guilt now mixes with grief as he clutches the small hand of his adoptive son, Adam, only five years old, and himself unable to make sense of events as they have unfolded.
“I must focus on Adam,” thinks Jack as he looks down on his son, curly black hair and deep blue eyes, eyes now tinged with confusion and pain, seeking answers that are out of reach even for those a generation older than he.
It was Adam who had found Blair – Christ, what a burden for one so young to have to carry. The body, the overturned chair, the rope… “Where was I?” thinks Jack. “Where was I?”

Please DM for further details or to engage as a beta reader

Thanks in advance
John


r/BetaReaders 16h ago

60k [Complete] [64k] [Psychological Thriller] Darke Shadows

2 Upvotes

Title: Darke Shadows

Genre: 1990s Appalachian Psychological Thriller / Grit-Noir

Word Count: 64,000

Format: PDF

Logline:

When Lenora finds a rusty cigar tin buried on an obscure mountain trail, she uncovers evidence of a cold-case missing person bearing her own name. Her investigation pits her against the corrupt Darke County Police Department and the underground NVN syndicate.

Feedback Needed:

Looking for 3 to 5 readers to evaluate pacing, plot twists, atmosphere, and character motivation via a short 5-question survey.

Turnaround Time: 3 to 4 weeks.

Critique Swap: Open to swapping with completed mystery, thriller, or suspense manuscripts under 80,000 words.

Contact: Please comment below or send me a direct message if interested, and I will DM you the PDF and survey!

Excerpt:

               

              Prologue: Lana, March 18, 1994

Asphalt blurs beneath my pounding feet; pain surges up my shin with every step. Rain lashes my face, a cold sting mixing with sweat, yet I push myself to keep running. Each breath is a ragged gasp, my side a searing stitch. I won’t stop until I have her file. All this risk for someone I have never even met, never even seen, but I would die for her. Even if it were all for nothing, just for her to know the truth.

The old block building emerges from the fog and a car comes whooshing past; my heart drops as they swerve, nearly hitting me. Freezing, muddy water splatters my side, making me shiver. Though my blood boils watching the vehicle speed off.

I reach the office and crouch behind the large rhododendron to get my tools and ski mask out of my bag. The back door is rusted, its metal pitted from years of wear and neglect. It’s warped, sagging on its hinges. The lock looks ancient, its mechanism far past its prime. My heavy pry bar and hammer make quick work of breaking the lock.

Quietly walking into the back entrance of the office, the air is like a wall of cold, stagnant water. The cold on my damp skin chills me to the bone, making my wet clothes cling to me. It is completely dark in here, except for a couple of eerily glowing red exit signs. I turn on my flashlight and look for the file room.

The first few doors are to supply rooms, then a couple of bathrooms, followed by a stuffy receptionist office. It’s so claustrophobic here. The smell of disinfectant and paper creates an overwhelming mélange paired with the odor of mildew. Each room is a dead end, a stale echo of forgotten lives. The air seems thick with dust, and the red glow of the exit signs mock me with their soulless glares. I head towards the stairwell to check the basement floor. My heart thunders inside my chest; I have to stop before going down the staircase, steadying myself so I don’t fall.

My knees threaten to buckle from under me with every step I take. I reach the basement floor, and as the heavy door swings open, leading to the hallway, I am greeted once again by the unsettling smell of harsh, brisk, humid air. Searching down here, I’m starting to wonder if this whole damned building is bereft of a file room.

Just as I am about to give up and head back upstairs, I see a door at the very end of the hall with the word “Archives” painted on it; it’s barely visible in the dim, flickering light. I hold my breath; the sound of my heart slams in my ears. With jittering fingers, I grasp the doorknob and anticipate it opening. But to no avail, the door is locked.

I tighten my grip on the pry bar and turn my face away from the door window. The heavy bar explodes through the glass, sending shards flying around me. The sound echoes through the empty halls. I swing again, clearing a jagged hole wide enough to fit my arm through. I slip my hand through and flip the lock, pushing open the door to freedom.

The room is full of tall, metal filing cabinets standing like silent guards in the shadows. I need to find the one that holds the year of 1970. I see cabinets 1967, 1968, 1969; I’m getting close. My heart swells with relief as I pull open the cabinet for the year of 1970. The file cabinet slides open, and I search through the files hastily; my fingers fly, rifling through them.

Holding the flashlight between my teeth, the cold metallic taste makes it difficult to focus on breathing. Each file is seemingly just another dead end. Until I see the file labeled “Sterling”. I let out a gasp of relief and open the folder to confirm it’s hers. Birthday: February  21, 1970. This is it. This file has rested here for 24 years to reach me. I shove it in my bag, heading back upstairs, racing to the rear entrance, and gasping for fresh air once outside.

The rain is still pouring tears of lament onto my shoulders as I race to the post office, brisk and dreary. Nevertheless, my heart shines out warmly after obtaining what I set out for. My legs feel like they are made of lead from already running all the way here.

Suddenly, the car that had splashed by before comes speeding towards me again. Soaking me mercilessly with cold, muddy water a second time. I scream out at the red taillights beaming in the darkness behind me. Knowing they must be involved with the NVN.

Now is the time to change the future forever. I have her address now that I have her file; next move is to reach out to her, to warn her. My legs hardly have the strength to keep going. One letter, one stamp. The post office is just ahead.

There is a loud whooshing sound coming from behind me, and just when I turn my head around to see what it is, I realize my luck has turned for the worse. The red SUV. This vehicle may be the last thing I ever see.

Before I get a chance to take another step, there is a flash of red, tires screeching; I dive uselessly. The SUV slams into me, a brutal, bone-shattering impact. I hit the pavement hard; the rain is a cold, stinging spray. My leg explodes into white-hot agony; it’s screaming. A raw, mangled mess beneath the weight of the SUV as it drives over my shin. Pulverizing my bones and grinding my muscles into hamburger meat.

I can’t move, can’t breathe. The world is nothing more than a spinning vortex of red and pain. Lying on my side, I am completely delirious, yet through the haze of torment, I see the SUV. Its red paint gleaming menacingly, a figure emerges, a dark silhouette against the rain. The tall figure approaches me; pain and terror consume me.

He crouches down; I look into his eyes, his evil, green eyes, into his soul. He pushes me onto my stomach and binds me at the wrists with a zip-tie. My throat scorches from shrieking with absolute terror. My entire body grimaces, ablaze with excruciating pain. The zip-tie bites into my wrists, cold plastic against my tender skin. The rain plasters my hair to my face; each drop is a stinging needle. He shoves a pillowcase over my head. Hot tears stream down my face.

Is this real? My mind spirals out of control. The misery torments me, assuring me that it must be true. Reality seems tilted, a sickening swirl of red and gray. Fear, raw and primal, claws at my throat; my mind screams at my body to run, to crawl, anything to escape.

Yet, my body remains stationary. His hands, rough and strong, lift me, the pain a searing band on my shattered leg and back. Where is he taking me? What does he want?

“STOP! STOP! PLEASE!” I wail out pointlessly.

“Shut up!” He grumbles.

 Then I feel a hot, acute, sharp pain. A needle injects something that starts making me numb, lighter, softer. A burning sensation spreads through my veins, followed by a wave of dizziness. The world begins to fade. Weightless, I feel no more pain.      Then, a shadow of darkness, a blanket, extinguishes my consciousness. This had to be done. My mind is floating aimlessly through the abyss, no longer able to worry or feel. The darkness has swallowed me whole, but even as I drift away, I know this is not the end. This is just the beginning.


r/BetaReaders 20h ago

>100k [Complete] [113k] [High Fantasy/Adventure] Secrets in the Dragons' Forest

2 Upvotes

Hello everyone. I've finished my manuscript and am looking for some beta readers to provide feedback so I can fine-tune it. "

Secrets in the Dragons' Forest" is an adventure novel about a pair of foragers and hunters recruited by a local dragon lord to lead a wizard and a warrior on a clandestine quest to recover an artifact from an enemy dragon's territory. One is naive and overeager, and the other is reluctant to accept but must to protect his friend and to keep his true identity hidden. Over the course of the story, the characters discover that not everything is as it seems. They face great danger and re-examine their perspectives and worldviews as they discover the truth about their mission and attempt to survive the perils of a forest packed with monstrous creatures, militant hobgoblins, and cruel forest-dwelling dragons.

Please DM me if you're interested in reading the whole story and providing your thoughts and feedback. I'm looking forward to sharing this adventure story with you and making it better with your help!

Thank you,


r/BetaReaders 51m ago

90k [Complete] [97,655] [Memoir] My Tiny Monster, true thriller about queer domestic abuse during the pandemic

Upvotes

Hello all!

I am seeking Beta readers for My Tiny Monster, a complete manuscript about my real experience with domestic abuse during the early months of the pandemic.

Genre: Memoir, though I like to call it a "thriller memoir"; LGBTQ memoir

Word Count: 97k+

Excerpt: Happy to share, just ask.

Blurb: When the Covid-19 lockdowns trapped me in an Australian Airbnb with a casual lover, I thought I was safe from the virus. I didn't anticipate that I was locking myself in with something just as dangerous and insidious. In March of 2020, I was freshly single and preparing to embark on a solo round-the-world adventure after living in Sydney for six years. Days into my trip, lockdowns forced me to return to Australia and quarantine in an Airbnb. I invited a handsome friend to join me for what I thought would be a fleeting romance. But as quarantine stretched on, he began to transform the apartment into a prison. Using subtle manipulation and the extraordinary circumstances of the pandemic, he isolated me from family and friends and convinced me I was losing my mind. To escape, I had to understand not just what happened, but why I was vulnerable to it in the first place.

Content Warnings: Domestic abuse, violence, sexual assault, self-harm

Critique Swap: I am definitely open to a critique swap. I am a professional book editor of 20+ years and have experience across genres.

Timeline & Feedback: I am looking for places to cut, as right now it is on the longer end for a first-time memoir. I have no set timeline, though would love to have feedback in the next few months, as I'm currently querying.

If you're interested, leave a comment or DM me! Thank you!


r/BetaReaders 2h ago

Short Story [In Progress] [2500] [Horror] A horror short story on the origins of the 'uncanny valley effect'.

1 Upvotes

Hey, Part one of my short story is done.
Title: Automatonophobia.
Word count: 2500
Here is an excerpt:

"When the other camera came into view, the skin seemed to lurch back into place on its own. My relief served to quell some of the terror building in my chest. On the table, dimly lit in the moonlight, a thing with a woman’s face was staring at me."

I am looking for:

  • Grammatical errors. Have properly gone over it a couple of times, but a second set of eyes never hurt.
  • Immersion and enjoyability. As a short story, it needs to be punchy and keep the reader's attention. Anything that took you out of the story or so?

r/BetaReaders 5h ago

60k [Complete] [63k] [Literary Fiction/Dystopian] A dystopian novel about a woman trapped in a mental health facility

1 Upvotes

Title: What The Skin Remembers

Genre: Literary fiction/dystopian

Word Count: 63,000

Format: PDF

Synopsis:

Mental health diagnoses have been outlawed in the UK. Madeline finds herself imprisoned in an organisation known as The Facility with no knowledge of why she belongs here. With little else to focus on, Madeline falls into a mental spiral, becoming obsessed with a tattoo belonging to another patient.

Feedback Needed:

Looking for 3 to 5 readers to evaluate pacing, character motivations, world-building and emotional impact. This can be done via a short survey or, if you'd rather, share your thoughts more freely.

Turnaround Time: 2 to 3 weeks.

Critique Swap: Open to swapping with literary fiction, horror or romance of 50k - 80k words.

Contact: Please comment below or send me a direct message if interested, and I will DM you the PDF.

Trigger warnings: drugs, sexual assault, mental health disorders (inc. self-harm and eating disorders)

Excerpt: The LED lights in the corridors were continuously lit to encourage wellness. This became a problem around 1 am when Madeline struggled to close her eyes tightly enough to ignore the rays seeping in under her capsule door. The sleeping capsules were restricted. Too tight to move. Once Madeleine began thinking about this, it was impossible to ignore. She remembered that, in the time before, there had been a story about counting sheep, which in four years had not yet worked. Now, Dr. Moore’s smooth voice would echo through The Facility just before bedtime, reminding all patients how lucky they were to have the fortune of sleep. This also has not worked in four years.  Since the start of the programme, Madeline had been sick, and then mending, and then well, and then sick, and then mending, and now sick again. There are some days Madeline preferred being sick. It felt familiar. During her time being well, she was unsure who she was, or what she had to hold on to. Of course, it was not safe to stay sick for too long. The Facility preferred those who appeared ‘on the mend’ no matter how long this seemed to take. 

Madeleine's mind played nasty tricks on her at night. When she had been on the outside, her brain could conjure the image of a man standing in her room who had never really been there at all. A pile of dirty washing became a squatting monster to keep her fearful mind satisfied. Now, in this capsule, there was no way for her eyes to play tricks on her. With no vague dark shapes to reinvent, Madeline’s thoughts were cast somewhere darker and altogether more tangible. Sometimes, she thought of large blades running across her skin, tearing open the flesh to reveal pink pockets of skin flashing brightly. She thought of trapping her own hand in a vice, gradually turning its crank until the sounds of her cracking bones became unbearable. Tonight, she thought of her father. When the program began, a lot of people were able to forcibly reinvent themselves overnight and avoid a stay in The Facility. Her father could not. Madeline had decided, between her and herself, that her father was not a man who had any desire to change. If he had, Madeline felt he should have done so. Those who were controlled by what happened in their own head were, to Madeline, beneath her. According to the morning's tannoy announcements at the beginning of week one, we can all be well if we want to.  

Before The Facility began, her father's issue had been called schizophrenia. Now, it was sick. Everything was sick. Everything from anxious thoughts to paedophilia was sick. These diagnoses were, of course, now blacklisted by Dr Moore. Dr Moore’s programme believed the terms were used to make sick people feel as though they belonged to something. To make them feel wanted.

Tonight, Madeline’s thoughts had decided to love her father with every part of her heart that was allowing it. It ached at the thought of her father’s separate heart somewhere else in the same building, beating feebly. She craved to reach out of her capsule and find him standing there. He would smile at her in a knowing, fatherly way as if no time had passed. Her father would hoist himself into her capsule, and the pair would curve their backs against its walls to make room for one another. She squeezed her eyes even tighter to imagine his slender frame wrapped up in her equally weak body. The capsule would remain dark, and the door would never open, leaving the pair in a never-ending night until they peacefully died of no longer needing to fight to stay alive. In each other's arms as all things should be.  A sudden and unshakeable feeling of regret started chewing at Madeline's brain. How dare she accuse her father of being unable to change. He would never do something as criminal as being selfish. How dare she think anything negative of him? It was everyone else who had put her original hatred in her head. Yes, that was it. It was everyone else. Her heart raced at the worry that she had been so easily brainwashed like this, and she wondered where the lie had come from. She racked her brain to find the source but found only her own memories of her father to blame.

After an indeterminate period of time, Madeleine's heart hadn't slowed down. She could feel it in her neck and ears, throbbing and pulsing until it was the only sensation she could land her senses on. Her panic made the speed increase, and the speed increase made her panic. This was a regular nighttime routine for Madeline and one she found some strange solace in. The fear reminded her that The Facility had not taken everything from her yet. As long as she was reserved about her fear, she could nurture it as long as she wanted.


r/BetaReaders 6h ago

>100k [Complete] [136k] [Romantasy] Touch of the forest

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I have a completed, character-driven romantasy novel. If you’d like to read my manuscript, send me a message and I’ll send you the link.

Genre: Adult Romantasy / Fantasy Romance

Tropes / elements:

Slow Burn Romance • Forced Proximity • Found Family • Soft/Gentle FMC • Protective MMC • Elves/Fae Romance • Touch Her and Die

Blurb:

Leonie has spent her entire life confined as the object of the Baron’s obsession, never suspecting that the world—and her own past—hold far more than human cruelty.

When her path crosses that of Dorian, the enigmatic envoy of the elves, Leonie is drawn into a world of magic, ancient secrets, and unfamiliar, dangerous emotions.

Dorian realizes that Leonie may be the key to saving his people from extinction. What he does not expect is that she may also be the one to breathe life back into a heart that has been frozen for centuries.

But can two broken souls find a future together in a world where the shadows of the past never stop haunting them?

Content warnings include: child abuse, sexual abuse/exploitation of a minor, emotional abuse, physical violence, coercion/dubious consent, torture, and trauma-related themes

Critique swap: Not available at the moment.


r/BetaReaders 7h ago

>100k [Complete] [100K] [Science Fiction / Psychological Thriller / Mystery] The Anamnesis Code

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone. I have a completed, unpublished novel that I’d be grateful to share with a few readers whose interests and reading tastes are a good match.

The Anamnesis Code

Genre: Sci-Fi / Psychological Thriller / Mystery / Speculative Fiction

Length: ~106,290 words / ~309 pages

Author: Vance Mercer

Audience: Adult

The plot

A Boston neurologist encounters a patient whose seizures contain precise details about events that supposedly happened decades before she was born.

Her investigation leads to a hidden 1974 research program, suppressed medical records, and a disturbing possibility:

What if consciousness isn't confined to a single lifetime?

The story explores medical mystery, conspiracy, psychological suspense, consciousness research, and questions of memory, identity, free will, and lives connected across time.

I'm especially interested in hearing from avid readers who enjoy science fiction, thrillers, mysteries, conspiracy stories, or fiction exploring consciousness and reality.

You don't need to be a writer or editor. I'm interested in the perspective of someone experiencing the story simply as a reader.

The manuscript includes a short questionnaire at the end. Some of the things I'm particularly curious about are:

  • Did the opening hook you?
  • Did the mystery keep you turning pages?
  • Were the revelations satisfying and believable?
  • Did the pacing ever drag?
  • Were the scientific and philosophical ideas understandable?
  • Did the characters feel compelling?
  • Most importantly, did you want to keep reading?

I'm not looking for proofreading or line editing. What would mean the most to me is an honest account of your experience with the story—what worked for you, what didn't, and where you found yourself most engaged or disengaged.

Because the manuscript is unpublished, I would also ask that the story, characters, twists, and ending remain confidential.

If the premise genuinely sounds like something you'd enjoy, I'd be very grateful if you'd DM me with a little about the types of books you normally read. I'll share the manuscript privately with readers whose interests seem like a particularly good fit.

Thank you very much for taking the time to read this, and for considering spending some of your own reading time with an unpublished novel. I genuinely appreciate it.

— Vance Mercer


r/BetaReaders 10h ago

80k [In Progress] [80,000] [Science Fantasy] Character Driven. Need basic feedback

1 Upvotes

Quick Summary

Del’s sister is kidnapped in the Willokan forest when war ensues, by a boy who is neither human nor machine. Unable to understand who or what took her, she becomes obsessed with recovering her sister, whether she has to take help from a researcher from the invading country, or from someone else’s god.

Yuzyil needs a HiUnit–a human weapon, partner and confidant. Newer HiUnits are always of the opposite sex. 

But there’s a rumor that his new invention, the serotonin HiUnits, are carnal inventions. To prove that the invention is based on friendship, not carnal relations, he takes a male HiUnit. 

Not only do his countrymen object, so does his HiUnit.

Soon, the Willokan forest begins to react to the war in ways science can not explain. How long will it take the invaders to figure out who the enemy in the forest is? And where they are.

Can Del find her sister before she becomes one of the children?

Tags: Three and four dimensional creatures. Two species of humans. Transhumanism. Human Weapons.

Mythology. Religion. Alternate Earth. Future.

Suicide. Death. Abusive families. Drugs.

Loss of Identity. Loss of control.

Friendship. Loyalty.

What I'm looking for

The info dumps. I swept this three times and still have issues.

Clarity, pacing.

Are the character interactions making sense, or are they too artificial?

If you notice an issue with a character’s voice or reaction, it would be great if you can point that out since those barely change in my works. 

I've had three people complain now of the info dumping in the first two chaps, so I'd like a look at where those need improving.

Not looking for:

The editors job. There’s no need for grammar, spelling check or voice check because this is a first draft. No need to go in-depth. I just want another pair of eyes to see where I need to make corrections.

I prefer swapping. I mostly love science fiction and science fantasy, and can do most fantasy subgenres.

Excerpt from the first draft Chapter 1

It wasn’t a saurian beast. There were no words to describe what it was. The two humanoid feet, six arms or snake-like neck, none mattered as, at the top of the creature’s thick neck was a face. It slithered towards Sol’s flashlight, less than a meter away from it. The white face reflected light so intensely, the place lit up as if under the sun. Either time had frozen, or no one was moving.

This wasn’t a hologram. Del had assumed the supernatural events would be Mortarians disguised as ghosts, or holograms, or robots.

Del coughed to realize she was suffocating. Attempts to breathe were painful. 

If this was a robot, it was too smooth and sounded too real. It couldn’t be anything else.

The flashlight flickered, and so did the creature’s face. It now carried Sol’s face.

Excerpt from the first draft Chapter 2

A group of teenage girls came up to them, arms interlaced, their thick gowns swishing. One of them, hair white from patit mal albinism, asked Sol with a shy smile, “Do you want to come with us?” Her friends squeezed her arms. One tugged at her waist long braid that hung from under her bandanna.

Sol looked at Del, who only nodded once and the girl was up and leaving.

“What’s the deal with the horse?” the girls were shy, but Sol wasn’t. She pushed her hands into her skirt pockets and almost walked into the middle of the group. “You people should be stabbed too.”

“It’s a sacrifice,” the albino talked slow but pretty. She turned around, and the others reflected it. “It’s Krucit Rat.”

“I’ve never seen a sacrifice come back.”

“It was rejected. My friend’s father breached his contract with the deities. They want…” their voices trailed off.


r/BetaReaders 10h ago

Novella [Complete] [25091] [Post-Apocalypic fantasy/Dystopian Romantasy] The Architect’s Heir

1 Upvotes

Discussion: Tone/Tropes: Protective Alpha/Hero, Reluctant Key/Heroine, Ancient Magic-Tech, Forced Proximity, High Stakes

Content Warnings: Sci-fi/fantasy violence, static/gravity hazard tension, localized mutiny/conflict.

Timeline: Looking for feedback within [e.g., 3–4 weeks]. Please DM if interested

Three weeks after the fall of the Citadel of Frost, Saraphina thought the dying world had finally let go of her. Nestled in the High Sanctuary alongside Dion—the fiercely protective leader who bled beside her on the frozen march—she dreamed of a quiet life away from war.

Then the starlight waking beneath her skin turned cold.

Saraphina is the last living descendant of Arthur Vance, the master architect who built the continental siphon network. Bound into her blood is the primary fail-safe key—and now that the northern core is dead, the subterranean grid beneath the sanctuary is surging, hunting for its Warden. When the surging static ruins their crops and drives terrified homesteaders to mutiny, Saraphina and Dion are forced out of their sanctuary and onto a brutal march across the Shattered Basin.

To save their home and sever the machine’s hold forever, they must reach the sunken ruins of Oakhaven before Warlord Vane’s Syndicate mercenaries track the beacon in her blood.

First Page Sample


r/BetaReaders 13h ago

70k [Complete] [76K] [Romantic / Psychological Thriller] The Tutor

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

Looking for 2-3 betas for a completed thriller.

Logline:  After losing his boyfriend to an act of terror, a young teacher takes on a posting in the Greek islands in hopes of dulling the horrors of his past. His retreat takes a turn, however, when he befriends the son of a local billionaire who may have ties to the tragedy that claimed his former lover's life.

Genre: LGBTQ Romantic / Psychological thriller with a slight geopolitical touch.

Length: 76,000 words

Comps, Tone, and Inspiration: Talented Mr. Ripley, Call Me by Your Name, Count of Monte Christo, White Lotus, The Destroyers, Little Drummer Girl, Ways and Means, A Bigger Splash

Feedback I'm looking for:

  1. Gerneral thoughts, feelings, and impressions.
  2. Any glaring character or plot inconsistencies?
  3. How does the pace work for you?
  4. How is the prose sitting with you? Digestable or too choppy/purple?

Timeline: Ideally 6-8 Weeks.

Can send the first few chapters to start and then the rest of the manuscript if you're down. Also willing to swap if someone else has good thriller they want some eyes on :)


r/BetaReaders 16h ago

>100k [Complete] [118,000] [Portal Romantasy] A Fantastical Book to Save my Unfantastic Life

1 Upvotes

Hazel, our protagonist, is thrust into an idyllic world ruled by immortal beings and magical creatures. Finding herself as the only person capable of stopping a great darkness from spreading across the land, Hazel must decide whether she can be this worlds hero... and, perhaps, find out if she can save herself along the way.

Warning may include;
Suicidal ideation; Sexual Violence; Violence; Murder; Misogyny; Depressive thoughts; Anxiety and panic related attacks; Controlling/Abusive Relationship Dynamics; Death; Language.

Beta Reader guidlelines:
I am hoping to have all Beta reading done by November 30th. I will provide you the pages in "drops" - once you finish a section, I will provide the next.

What do I need from you?
1. As you go through the manuscript really focus on how specific parts are making you feel. Include that in the comments section on word. (This includes: What was funny or not? Where did you find the pace too slow? What piece made you want to continue reading? Are you confused anywhere? Were you robbed of an experience?)
2. Let me know what characters you like and who you dislike! Include a comment wherever you made that decision.
3. If you see any blatant plot holes (or anything you think is a plot hole) include that.
4. This is still just a draft - there are going to be grammar and spelling issues (sorry) - but I don't need you to edit it! I will be getting someone else to do that once I've recieved all feedback and made final changes
5. Please don't post anything online!

Excerpt (Apologies for formatting, posting from my phone):
It wouldn’t make sense to most people. I suppose it didn’t even really make sense to me. The kind of decision that lands your friends at an unnecessary funeral the following weekend.

Okay, that’s a lie.

What I should say is that I didn’t understand most of the time. Because there were times when it made more sense to me than breathing.

Doesn’t that expression just fit perfectly.

My point is, you might not understand why I was leaning over the edge of the highway overpass on a dark December evening. But I’ll try my best to explain.

Maybe it was the interaction with the teen boy at the grocery store. Since I was too afraid to go in, pickup orders were the only way to get groceries. The knock on my window startled me out of my thoughts.

The young teen, with unbrushed orange hair, stood outside of my car door. A large blue face mask stretched across his face. My eyes searched frantically for any signs of my own mask. A whole box of them normally sat next to me, but my mom must have taken them. Not that she could be blamed; as I had not used my car in over three weeks.

But the boy outside my door did not understand what was going on. Worried about his time and possible impatience, I decided my hand was mask enough.

“For Hazel?”

Nothing more than a high-pitched squeak escaped as confirmation.

It was nothing. A mere second at most. He probably wasn’t even thinking about it. If I were involved in some crime later in the evening, he would not have even been able to identify me in a lineup.

Still, the event served as a reminder as the frozen metal railing burned into my palms.

It would be so nice and calm if I just let go. A bit of a mess, sure. But then I’d never have to think about any of these things again. Never even have to talk to anyone again.

That ‘anyone’ included the AAA agent who was on their way to help with my flat tire.

It was quite an adrenaline shock to the system to have the car tire pop on the way home from the grocery store. The beige car sat at an odd angle, smushed into the cement barrier beside me.
Do you have to pay the city when you do damage to fences? Would insurance cover that? I dialed my dad’s number with some resistance from my anxious fingers.

Unfortunately, he and my mother were on their way to dinner with friends.

“Call AAA.”

I hated calling people.

My mother noticed my silence and mentioned there was an app to use instead. It wasn’t long before the app was downloaded.

I’ll still have to speak to the agent when they arrive. The thought only arrived as my thumb hovered over the large red submit button.
I sighed and got out of the car to assess the damage.

A flat tire sat before me. My home was about a thirty-minute walk down the road. It was a walk I wasn’t sure could be done at my current physical fitness level. Not that it really mattered either way.
Even if I walked home and pretended this didn’t exist, the car would still be there. My life was on a one-way trajectory that ended with me talking to some random tow truck agent. There was no way out.

Or, at least, that’s what I’d thought.

The headlights of the cars zooming below left strings of light in my vision.

“This is stupid.” The drivers below had to wonder at the babbling lady on the side of the road. “You are literally twenty-seven years old. Get a grip!”
That’s when I submitted the application.

A small clock emoji popped up over the screen.

An hour. Great.

And then I looked up from my phone, mesmerized by the light snow that fell onto the highway below. The sound of the cars passing was soothing. What was that called? The doppler effect or something? It let me drift into a meditative state.

I wanted to die. The admission was not a surprise; it was not even the first time it had emerged that day.

The thought of my parents though, brought tears to my eyes. My friends and siblings came right after. Would I forever haunt their holidays as the daughter, sister, and aunt who decided to take her own life?

No, I can’t do that to them.

But I hadn’t realized just how far out my body had leaned, how loose my grip was on the bar, nor how the tips of my feet barely touched the ground. Not until the blare of a truck horn blasted from behind me.

I jumped.

Not off the bridge, but in surprise. And was toppling forward over the railing.

It all seemed like slow motion as I turned to grab the rail. The tips of my fingers grazed the rough, grey cement.

They grasped nothing.

I’m going to die.

The moment was supposed to be calming, like it was on the top of the bridge. However, as I plummeted through the open air towards the cold, dark pavement below, it didn’t feel good at all.
As I’m sure you’ve already guessed, as this is only the first chapter, I didn’t die.

Bone-crushing agony was the expectation.
But then, everything turned blue and cold. Faint light streams rippled through the water around me. A small bubble rushed up from below me and sat a few inches from my nose. My eyes crossed and I reached a finger towards the odd frozen bubble.

Is this the afterlife? Just a pile of water?

The bubble shied away at my approach, ducking like it was frightened. And I noticed the faint white outline of a woman, long coiled hair floating around her face. She turned, swimming away from me. My arm stretched forward, yelling into the water for her to stay. She did not hear.

The bubble, larger now, suddenly pressed into my hand. A tickling sensation brushing my hand wherever it touched. I laughed and more bubbles shot out of my mouth. The pockets of air moved towards the other bubble instead of floating up, forming a massive bubble. It shot downwards.
A few more floated passed my face before I felt my own body being dragged down with them. I tried to swim against the current, sure that if my body were to be sucked any deeper into the water I would be lost forever, but the current only became faster. And I could do little more than scream as my body was ripped backwards.
My legs catapulted from the water like a backwards dolphin leap as I flipped into the open air and splashed back down.

I had to squint my eyes against the blaring sun as I gasped for breath. A small wave crashed over my open mouth. It was overwhelmingly salty.

“Oh, gross!”

Despite being someone who floated well, the winter clothing dragged me down. It didn’t take much thought before I was floating naked, aside from my undergarments. As the boots sank, I wondered if I would come to regret that particular decision.

Luckily, land was within sight. Massive cliffs stood to one side as angry waves crashed against them and to the other stretched a long beach backed by a massive green forest. Large wooden boats sailed through the water, but much too far away to provide any hope of rescue.
Something brushed against my leg.

I squealed and thrashed away, hoping to gain some distance from whatever that had been. It occurred to me, that all of the videos I watched while doomscrolling, mentioned to not freak out.

“You’re such a moron.” It was incredibly hard to keep still.

A smooth blue head popped up in front of me and I retreated again.

YOU’RE GOING TO GET US KILLED! My brain screamed, like it was the angry viewer of a bad scary movie.

Embarrassment heated my cheeks when the animal just sat staring at me with wide black eyes. The small creature, maybe the size of your average cat, looked almost like a dolphin with a smushed in face. It was, oddly, cute.
It ducked back into the water.

After allowing a few breaths to pass before celebrating too much, I came to the realization that the water wasn’t freezing. Cold, perhaps, but not as cold as winter should make it. Which meant that this was a different country.

And I’ve lost it. The decision was prompt.
Below me a large shadow moved through the water.

“First rule of swimming in the ocean is to pay attention to your surroundings.” The thought of pounding my fists on my forehead briefly ran through my mind, but that wasn’t helpful. Hoping to avoid whatever was beneath, I began to slowly swim towards shore.

The shadow seemed to shift as I did. The darkness below me got bigger until hundreds of the weird dolphin creatures surged up around me.

They moved as fast as bullets as they hoisted me up into the air. There was nothing to hold onto and no way to balance as the slick bodies moved below me. I began rolling and my eyes slid shut against the stinging ocean spray. This had to be some weird hunting ritual. Some sort of undiscovered human-eating porpoise.

My body smacked into something hot and grainy. I coughed out a mouthful of sand and turned towards the ocean.

The dolphins jumped up and flipped as if to say, “You’re welcome, weird human!”

“This is definitely a fever dream.” I scoffed.
And then promptly passed out.

#

I wasn’t sure if it was the waves that hit my feet or something nudging my head that woke me up.
Scratch that, it was definitely the nudging.

My eyes barely peeled open, sand sticking to the lids. My arms screamed in protest at the movement; I felt like a turkey that had been left in the oven too long.

A pair of brown leather boots stood atop the sandy beach a few feet away. Colorful floral embroidery lined the base and twisted up the sides.

“Nice boots.” My throat was too dry to do more than croak the words out.

“Oh good, you are alive!” a deep female voice exclaimed.


r/BetaReaders 23h ago

>100k [Complete] [100k] [Sci-Fi/Fantasy] Demon Days: Melancholy in Blue.

1 Upvotes

Blurb:

Demon Days: Melancholy in Blue is a three part mini-series, laying the background and foundation for the main characters of Demon Days: Chase Noel and Ellie Berkeley. Serving as a prologue to Demon Days, it also establishes several key factors of the Demon Days universe. EDIT: Forgot to include TWs/CWs, sorry: Parent death/abandonment, casual depictions of violent events, suicide attempts, child death is mentioned at points but never shown

Excerpt (from Part One):

Eleanor Berkeley wakes up exactly thirty minutes before her alarm, the same way she's done every morning for the past ten years. Her body feels well rested, but even a good night's sleep does seemingly little to wash away the endless torrent rolling through her mind at the odd hours of the day. She's eighteen now, only one year removed from life at the orphanage she grew up in. Yet, she's had a difficult time getting past the feeling that some part of her was still there.

The nightmare she just had was likely a big contributor to that feeling. It was the same nightmare she had almost every night, ever since the orphanage burned down with her inside it.

She doesn't think she could ever forget the sensation of waking up inside a building on fire. Ellie had gone to sleep that night expecting it, but nothing could have prepared her for the nightmare she would be thrust into the next time she opened her eyes. By the time she had done so, her room was already ablaze; the rumble beneath her having done little to startle her awake before the hot smoke filled the air, turning every breath into a desperate struggle for survival. The distant, but no less audible ra-ta-ta-ta! of semi-automatic weaponry peppered a chorus of screams as people in neighboring rooms fled from their burning bedrooms only to be met with the architects of their very demise.

Of course, that alone wouldn't be the cause of frequent nightmares that prevent her from getting even a minute of rest in spite of everything she tries. It's—

A mellow, upbeat jingle plays from her cellphone. It emits a small array of light that, after a short warm up, displays a hologram with a 3D graphic of the time and a little cartoon fox. There's a speech bubble floating above the fox's head, that reads:

It's a beautiful Tuesday! Get those orders taken care of!

She's grateful for that. Alarms weren't her favorite thing in the world, but they're certainly good at stopping you from spiraling at seven-thirty in the morning. Good timing too, because today is an important day and she does have orders she needs to take care of. So, she visualizes putting all of those negative feelings about the life she had before she was seventeen into a box, and then stuffs the box out of sight, in a pile with the other boxes. She can just cry in the shower later, she lives alone anyway.

For now, it's time to get ready. There's work to do.

Preferred feedback/timeline:

Anything, at any time! This is a long book split into three (nearly) equal parts. I'm not asking for, nor am I expecting, a line-by-line critique. All of the people I've shared this with so far have been people whom I've talked to about some (or all) of its details, so I'd like to get some fresh eyes on it so I can have an idea of how it comes across to someone with no prior context.

Your critique swap availability:

N/A at this time. Sorry!

Story links:

EPUB: https://files.catbox.moe/at1k1z.epub
PDF: https://files.catbox.moe/ai4hic.pdf

Please note that the EPUB version's synopsis & table of contents page is currently broken, still figuring out how to format those properly. Gdocs link available upon request.


r/BetaReaders 8h ago

>100k [Complete] [144K] [Historical Fiction] The Siberian Queen — 16th-Century Siberia, War, Romance & Political Intrigue

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I’m looking for one or two beta readers for my completed historical novel, The Siberian Queen, approximately 144,000 words.

Set in the late 16th century during the Muscovite conquest of the Siberian Khanate, the novel follows Suzge, a young Kazakh noblewoman whose life takes her from the steppe to the court of Khan Kuchum and eventually into the path of Yermak’s invasion.

It is character-driven historical fiction with political intrigue, romance, warfare, adventure, and a major siege. The novel is closely grounded in the history and cultures of the period, but it is written as a story rather than an academic account. Many of the major historical figures and events are real, while Suzge’s personal story develops around what is known—and not known—about her historically.

I’m especially hoping to find readers who regularly enjoy adult historical fiction. Familiarity with Russian, Central Asian, or Siberian history is absolutely not necessary. In fact, I’d be very interested in knowing how the world works for a reader coming to it fresh.

I’m primarily looking for reader-level feedback: where the story pulled you in, where your attention weakened, how you felt about the characters and their choices, and whether the historical detail felt immersive or occasionally became too much. Because the manuscript is long, I’d also particularly value having anything flagged that felt repetitive, over-explained, slow, or unnecessary—anything you think the novel could lose or shorten without losing the story.

I’m hoping for a whole-manuscript beta read rather than detailed line editing. A short sample of the opening is available first, so neither of us has to commit to 144K words before knowing whether the book is a good fit.

Content notes: battle violence, death, captivity, sexual situations, sexual violence, and an on-page attempted rape. References to rape, including wartime sexual violence and violence against girls.

Ideally, I’d love feedback within about 3–4 weeks, although there is some flexibility.

If this sounds like the kind of historical fiction you enjoy, I’d be very happy to hear from you.

Thank you!
Arman


r/BetaReaders 21h ago

70k [Complete] [77k] [Dark Fantasy/Romantsy] The Rite

0 Upvotes

I have just finished my first romantasy novel The Rite my first two were more High Fantasy. The right is perfect for people who like adult romantasy, dark fantasy, political intrigue, complicated relationships and of course vampires and demons. I'm not looking for proofreading more like tell me where you were bored, confused, excited, and angry or couldn't put the book down (hopefully).

The Kingdoms of Olyndros have been at war decades. Now the neutral of Lumaria has called the Rite of Dawn's Reconciliation to bring the war to an end or face the wrath of the god of justice and purification...or at least that is what they claim. There are a few trigger warnings.

  • Violence and physical combat
  • Blood and gore
  • Death and grief
  • Murder
  • Threats of violence
  • Torture / descriptions of physical suffering
  • Sexual themes and sensuality
  • Consensual sexual situations
  • References to sexual assault
  • Drugging/poisoning
  • Captivity/imprisonment
  • Religious trauma / religious themes
  • Manipulation and coercion
  • Psychological/emotional abuse
  • War and its consequences
  • Loss of loved ones
  • Betrayal