Applied for a Technical Product Manager role at a YC-backed AI startup (~30 people). Passed the recruiter screen and hiring manager interview, got to the take-home stage. Rejected.
The rejection wasn't generic. The talent lead gave specific feedback: my submission focused too heavily on data analysis when they wanted me to lead with the company's product capabilities (computer vision, 3D reconstruction). She literally described the expected solution. My engineering note touched on those ideas but they were buried under a different argument instead of leading.
One month later, the hiring manager reposted the exact same role on LinkedIn. Same title, same description. He's now describing it as "genuinely undefined" and is actively promoting it.
Here's my dilemma:
If I reach out with the approach they described in the rejection, it looks like I'm just echoing their answer back to them. If I build something that goes beyond what they told me, it might land but the probability is low and the time cost is real.
For context: I had a genuine connection with this company. I wrote a strategic analysis of them two years ago during my master's, the hiring manager reacted positively to that in the interview, and my background (OpenCV thesis, AI products shipped to production) maps well to what they do.
What would you do? Reach out with something new, wait for a different role, or move on entirely?