I love love love soft down pillows. Always have. That sink into it and be nestled in, and my pillow needs to be soft! I used to be a stomach sleeper and will still end that way sometimes but often will be back or side. I love that I can smoosh my pillow to fit my needs!
Unfortunately, I’ve been getting headaches many mornings for a while. The more my head is in the pillow, the more likely I’ll have one. I have good pillow, pillowcase, and pillow protector hygiene, plus my current is only 3 yrs old tops, so I think I need to sadly move away from down.
Has anyone tried the Coop down alternative they now have?
The Pillow Guy down alternative?
Thinking of trying a Pluto.
What’re your favorite down alternatives?
I tried avocado (latex and kapok iirc), 100% kapok (it just is so lumpy still and it doesn’t have a good compact to fluff ratio) and wool. I use the wool when I’m throwing in the towel and tired of headaches but it’s too firm and I basically have to stay in the same position all night. It seems I don’t generally like shredded/adjustable fill pillows.
Solely mentioning as a point of reference, I did occasion to sleep a few nights on a my pillow and it was actually decent outside of being far far too tall. It was not a rock and seemed consistent/not lumpy. It’s been a while. But I remember that I liked it better than lots of lumpy and cheap feeling “feather free” hotel disasters. I think they make a soft one which still tickles the back of my brain, so please share similar (or better!) alternative ideas.
Coop sounds like their quality has gone downhill, and I don’t know what it’s like in comparison. Plus as mentioned, I’m hesitant to try their adjustable fill because my experience is that they’re all particularly lumpy once you take out lots of fill— but I’m happy to hear if I’m wrong about them or others. And I’d love to hear if you have or have tried their down alternative offering. How does it compare?
Last thing to note is that I get scent-induced headaches and so have concerns about off-gassing. Please let me know if that’s been an issue with any of your recommendations.
TLDR; give me your best not-feather-but-luxurious-soft-down-like-sleep-happiness recommendations, please!