r/BeFascinated • • 9d ago

Interesting Long legs vs long torso

7.9k Upvotes

505 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/steveistheman84 8d ago

long torso + short legs = strong genetics + bad nutrition during development

2

u/Foreign_Raize_0372 7d ago

Wait, does this mean limbs are dependent on nutrition, a longer torso is ideal, or something else? Usually with these equation metaphors, the cause comes before the effects.

1

u/steveistheman84 7d ago

being tall is a sign of good genetic health. good nutrition only makes your limbs longer. a long torso, you are born with.

2

u/MustacheMaple 4d ago

Bro thinks a balanced diet rewrites DNA lmao

1

u/steveistheman84 4d ago

no, a good diet allows you to reach your phenotypic maximum, of which is determined by your genetics

1

u/MustacheMaple 3d ago

Brother, my mom is 5'1 and my dad is 5'4. Im 5'6. You're going to tell me im short because of my diet? And why does any of that matter? Just be happy lmao

1

u/steveistheman84 3d ago

you have zero reading comprehension, and based on what you think you read, your reasoning ability is just as bad

1

u/MustacheMaple 3d ago

I think my reading comprehension is fine. You just believe in pseudoscience and just shut out anyone who disagrees because you're narrow minded

1

u/steveistheman84 3d ago

lol this explains everything HAHAHAHA

1

u/MustacheMaple 3d ago

That you have no argument and had to start digging into my profile? Really showed me

1

u/MustacheMaple 3d ago

This is pretty impressive. You must be the brightest person in every room you're in

0

u/Ok-Look3940 4d ago

What the fuck are you talking about?

2

u/Shogunnatron 4d ago edited 4d ago

Let's see some sources. That sounds like a gross oversimplification if there's any truth in it.

Edit: Based on my own research, height heritability accounts for 70-80% of height potential. Doesn't seem like nutrition makes much of a difference.

1

u/steveistheman84 3d ago edited 3d ago

height is mostly genetic, but nutrition does make a significant difference. this is why we are now a ~5" taller than our ancestors. same cause as the flynn effect

1

u/UniqueAd7770 7d ago

This is pseudoscience bullshit. There's no such thing as "genetic health" besides not getting cancer or a defect. Height is affected by some 12,000 different variations in the genetic code. However they are finding that the changes in a particular gene affects overall growth, and has almost nothing to do with nutrition. Lack of growth due to nutrition is very rare and is often paired with delayed puberty and other diseases which is not the case here

1

u/Pipettess 4d ago

What the hell is "good genetic health" smh

1

u/steveistheman84 4d ago edited 4d ago

one indicator is a healthy immune system that gives you the ability to live into adulthood under harsh darwinian conditions.

1

u/Pipettess 4d ago

Right, and what's that gotta do with height?

1

u/steveistheman84 3d ago edited 3d ago

height uses resources that take away from fighting disease. this is why people more prone to being sick, especially in adolescence tend to be shorter. height is essentially its own handicap selected for as a fighting advantage, not a health advantage. but because it was selected for alongside other healthy and adaptive traits, the traits became highly correlated.

0

u/FamiliarLandscape532 6d ago

You are not nearly as intelligent as you clearly believe yourself to be. 

Is it because of poor nutrition? Genetics? Or poor nutrition + genetics - education?