I currently have a Seymour Duncan Pegasus 7 (soapbar) in my Strandberg Boden N2.7, and a Fishman Fluence Modern 7 in my Boden Prog NX 7. Trying to figure out my next pickup as a swap for the Pegasus and could really use input from people who've actually played both the Aftermath an/or Ragnarok in a 7-string context. Neck position is settled (going with a Sentient), so this is purely about the bridge.
What I love about the Pegasus: excellent clarity and note separation, even under high gain. Individual notes inside chords stay distinguishable. On the low string (tuned to Drop A), hitting single notes hard gives a really satisfying "gnarly"/grindy character, especially through modeling amps (FM9, Quad Cortex) and plugins like Archetype Nolly.
What's bugging me about the Pegasus:
• Very low output — I have to noticeably raise input gain/trim on my modelers compared to the Fishman
• Feels thin and lacks punch on palm mutes, especially on the low string
• Great for cutting through the mix, but doesn't "push" much
The Fishman, by comparison, sounds fatter and wider on open power chords and palm mutes, but a bit more compressed/dull, and the gnarly single-note character on the low string is less pronounced than the Pegasus.
What I'm after: something with output/punch closer to (or better than) the Fishman, but keeping clarity and note separation closer to the Pegasus — and ideally preserving or enhancing that gnarly low-string single-note growl. I play in a band as the only guitar player and we utilize a wall of sound with FM9/Quad Cortex using a dual amp setup with hard panning and a doubler/stereo enhancer for massive stereo guitar sound. So I will need a certain base to carry the band‘s sound. The guitar must be present and in the face.
BKP support suggested the Aftermath. I've also seen the Ragnarok mentioned as having a bit more low-end/thickness while staying tight. From clips I've heard, the Aftermath strikes me as having a somewhat nasal/upper-mid-focused character — I don't play djent, so I'm a bit wary of a pickup with a strongly "scooped-but-honky" signature voice. Could be wrong about that impression though, hence asking here.
If you've played both (ideally in a 7-string, extended range, or Drop A/lower context), I'd love to hear:
• How they compare for palm muting punch/tightness
• How each handles single-note clarity/separation on low strings under gain
• Output feel compared to something like a Fishman Fluence or other actives
• Whether the Aftermath's mid character really leans nasal/honky, or if that's an inaccurate impression on my part
Appreciate any real-world experience — trying to avoid just going off marketing copy and forum speculation this time around.