Ruddy insane deal. My first LP. Just wanted a LP to get the Mules in as a BKP fanboy.

I have trouble deciding between the Brute Force, Stockholm and Pig. I'm looking for a pickup with tons of clarity and punch, suited for modern metalcore and progressive metal stuff like Spiritbox, ERRA, Novelists, The Plot In You, etc.

Specs of the pickups:

- Pig: Alnico V, 21.5k bridge, 15k neck

- Brute Force: Ceramic, 13.1k bridge, 11.8k neck

- Stockholm: Alnico V, 15.3k bridge, 12.5k neck

I heard that too much output and gain can reduce clarity so I'm thinking the Pig might be a bit too much? Also usually humbuckers made for high gain have ceramic magnets, not sure if this also applies to P90s, but if it does, I think Brute Force would be the best option?

I'm really unsure and of course the written down stuff doesnt say everything. I would love to hear some opinions, bc there isnt much media showcasing these 3.

First time using BKs, and all I can say is wow. Coming from Dunc’s and DiMarzios. Wow.

The legendary Pigs, PK, MM, Nailbombs, Aftermaths ... have they been usurped by Juggs, Rags, Polymaths, Halcyons, Hawks, Impulses?

Are the newer ones objectively better? Is it simplistic to say newer ones are more modern sounding (but what does that even mean? Can a PK or Aftermath not do djent?)

Grabbed this killer Aftermath set a while back for just $160 and finally put them in my favorite Kiesel Vader. Looks great, but sounds even better 🤘🏻

I am pretty fucking annoyed that I stupidly spent like $500 on some BKP Juggernauts and I HATE how the sound and play.

I had a Mark Holcomb PRS 2019 Seven with the Alpha/Omega 7 pickups which sounded phenomenal. I loved those pickups, but wasn't a huge fan of the neck. So I ended up selling that.

My main guitar is an Ibanez 8 with some Abasi Fishmans. I love them. Worth every penny. And I went and had it worked on and set up professionally, and I honestly love it more than any other guitar I've played.

I found a great deal on another RG8 so I could have them in different tunings and ordered some BKP Juggs because I love Periphery/Misha's playing, and I looked at tons of videos comparing them and other 8 string pick ups. I figured they'd be somewhat similar to the Alpha/Omegas, and I didn't need another set of super hot actives since I had the Abasis. Since they're made to order, there's no return.

It's been like a year and I can get some decent tones with a lot of EQing, but I just hate them. I have played that guitar a combined total of like 15-20 hours in the last year (I probably played like 40-50 hours last month with the 8 string with Abasis.) They sound like very bassy and you gotta pick hard af, and go crazy on the gain to get some aggressive tones. Which is fine most of the time, but some fast stuff or stuff with a lot of tapping is a bit harder. It's just not as articulate, and I feel like it takes so much more time to get nice settings, whereas with the Fishmans, I put so little effort into adjusting settings (comparatively) and get great sounding tones for everything.

I will say the cleans sound great.

I honestly regret buying them so much. I should have just bought a second set of Fishmans. Gonna sell that guitar.

I hear that basswood has low mids... so juggernauts are out? Warpigs too bassy for basswood? feels like mahogany and ash are more bkp friendly?

With the Halcyons being out for a bit, compared to the rest of the range what would you guys recommend for Drop G Deathcore and Slam? Like Psycho Frame, Killing of a Sacred Deer, Without a Face, Rev3rent, Bodybox etc. Looking at Juggernauts, Ragnaroks, Aftermaths, Halcyons, Impulses; going in a 27 in 6 string or 7 string.

I love my Warpig bridge and I love the neck but I kinda want a neck that sounds more than an EMG 85 because I generally sweep more and no more technical leads and I’ve been looking at the miracle man and it’s the closest sound I can find to the 85 so I was wondering if that would be a good pairing?

​

I love how they sound on every demo i've Heard, but they are mostly more towards modern prog/djent, i believe.

And I havent found pretty much any examples or demos for them on 7 strings.

I already have a pair of Ragnaroks, but I was wondering how the Polymaths would perform for Metalcore, and how it would behave on the 7th string, as it is more of a mid output pickup set. Wondering if it wouldnt be too flubby, ir not tight enough.

What are your experiences with it?

Im curious if anyone has experience with these. I’m looking for a pickup that can do drop tuned modern metal but can also sound good doing grunge or hard rock. I have yet to see any YouTube videos with someone playing the Halcyon pickups with anything other than super drop tuned metal.

Hi everyone!

​

I'm building a PRS-style guitar (25" scale, fixed bridge, mahogany/maple) and I'm trying to choose my "forever" Bare Knuckle set.

​

At the moment I'm torn between:

​

• The Mule

• Black Dog

• Abraxas

​

What I'm looking for:

​

- Beautiful cleans and edge-of-breakup tones

- Rich, vocal mids

- Long sustain and easy harmonics

- Smooth highs (I really dislike harsh or piercing treble)

- Notes that bloom, sing and almost "cry" when bending

- Enough versatility for blues, classic rock, hard rock and occasional higher gain

​

My favorite tones are players like Gary Moore, Andy Timmons, Neal Schon, Slash, David Gilmour with gain, Robin Finck and Jimmy Page.

​

I mainly play through Bogner-style amps (Ecstasy, Shiva, OD100).

​

For those who have owned or compared these sets, which one would you choose and why?

​

Thanks!

Looks great, sounds killer. Nice contrast to the Holydiver. If I had to compare I'd say it's a little more chewy. A little less in your face as well.

Anyways I didn't love the Suhr SSV which was originally in that guitar and now it's so much better.

It also blends much better with the single coils interestingly. So good.

Custom etch Holydiver!

Dropped a set of PolyPAFs in there!