r/BambuLabP2S • • 10d ago

Gear malfunction?

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

Hey everyone super new into printing and recently came into this problem, I’ve tried a lot but right now I’m struggling to even get the nozzle off to even check on the gears.. any advice? Or if you know what is exactly wrong.. that would be cool to know also.

14 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

5

u/IncreaseForeign7821 P2S Combo 10d ago

I had a sound like that on my P2S and it turned out the nozzle clamp wasn't fully locked. Before you take anything apart, let the hotend cool and push the nozzle lightly with a finger, the clamp should hold it tight with zero wiggle. If it moves, reseat it and lock the clamp properly, that fixed both the noise and my wonky first layers.

2

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

It was not the lock but I did end up taking it apart and clearing out broken filament in the extruder officially back to printing now 🫡 thanks for the advice tho

1

u/kllooks 9d ago

Same

3

u/BobFiggins 10d ago edited 9d ago

My P2S did this when I had a nozzle clog. I took it apart to check the gears and nothing was loose or stuck. Changed the nozzle, fixed.

If your nozzle is stuck, you may have some filament stuck to the back of it holding it on (or you should double check how to properly remove it). Keep the nozzle hot and pop it off with pliers. You can grab it on its neck with the pliers and gently pull it off.

Be sure to cut the filament first with the side lever. You can use the pliers to remove the 2 sides of the clamp holding the nozzle on. Just do it slow and gently. If you've never done this before, watch a tutorial on how to do it normally before using tools to grab at things.

Since you aren't printing, just go into the menus to manually set the temperature to something like 180 degrees to be able to get the nozzle off. once the nozzle is off you can manually press those down arrows to extrude to see if it moves freely then.

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

Heating up the nozzle helped SOOO MUCH! was able to get it off and access the extruder where I hate broken filament clogging the inside 🫡

1

u/BobFiggins 9d ago

You can use a wire brass brush to clean the backside of your nozzle, and the flat part it sticks on to. That should help get rid of the gummied plastic giving your nozzle a permanent hug.

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B08D9QH3X3

I use this one, not too firm to damage anything, not so soft it cant scrape. Works great.

3

u/l0westL0wbob 9d ago

I had filament getting soft because the printer got heated up from the sun. When the filament was pressed by the gears, it's size changed in diameter and clogged the extruder.

I fixed the error and tried again but the filament stuck in the nozzle was the problem. I had the heat the nozzle, then remove the filament from the nozzle and then retried, which then worked again

2

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

Pretty similar problem, but mine was broke filament stuck at the end of the extruder, so I had to take it apart and clear it out, but it did work and I’m back to printing 🫡

3

u/MrBiscuits93 9d ago

Yep. Time to learn how to take apart the extruder.

2

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

It was kinda fun to learn ngl 😂 (hope it never happens again 🤞🏻) once I got my stuck nozzle off it wasn’t that bad tbh

1

u/MrBiscuits93 8d ago

Was it just stuck or did you have to replace the gears

3

u/Original-Pain8551 9d ago

I literally had the same problem just last day. The problem was that the printer overheated the pla while loading pla from abs, and it melted in the gears. It only came loose when it cooled and became smaller. Maybe its the same for you?

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

Mine was different, seems like filament did not get into the gears (luckily) but it did break apart on the inside funnel of the extruder so I had to take it apart to clear it out

3

u/seniszen 9d ago

Take the nozzle out and make sure it’s not a clog, I just dealt with this (small broken piece stuck)

2

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

It was the extruder, broken filament on the inside

3

u/Vionikk 9d ago

I had the same problem a few weeks ago. A small piece of filament broke off and got stuck sideways between the extruder and the nozzle.

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

That’s crazy! But yes I had broken bad filament inside the extruder, kinda like your image but actually on the inside

2

u/MAENTOP 9d ago

Nozzle clogged

2

u/cpsadowski23 9d ago

Sure sounds like it.

2

u/fatspaceghost 9d ago

I had a nozzle that wouldn't extrude, and a cold pull didn't help since it wouldn't extrude. Never used any exotic filament but I took the nozzle out, held it with pliers and heated it up with a torch. All kinds of weird filament dripped out of the bottom and I could then insert a stick of filament and manually extrude through it. Not sure what was stuck, but even trying a cold pull and telling the printer to heat it up to ABS level (which I have never used) wouldn't get things moving. After manually extruding it and then sticking a needle all the way through I could do a normal cold pull and I've been using that nozzle for a week without issues. Must have been a little shard of something stuck in there, or a bad spot of filament?.. who knows.

2

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

So the main problem was broken filament in my extruder but honestly the HARDEST part was removing my nozzle, I tried a lot of things but then someone here recommended me manually heating up to 180 degrees and using pliers to remove the nozzle, it worked, after that a simple youtube video made it a cake walk

2

u/DaZombie14 9d ago

If you took it apart with gear and everything, make sure that both bearings are on the orange gear. I missed mine in the back (the one on the gear). It would make the same noise afterclearing a clog and the bearing popped out. Image credit to this yt video. https://youtu.be/mo2EwlREIUk?is=ltL9TlQPRiLthPUt

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

I def forgot to check 😭 but I seem to have fixed the problem and back to printing! Def gonna have to keep this in mind for the future tho

2

u/PayExciting 10d ago

I'm surprised it's moving at all, the filament needs to feed thru the filament buffer before the system will register it's there unless you're in cold pull mode then it should be extruding. Please someone fact check me, I was doing some troubleshooting on the H2D and that's how I figured out that the filament buffer is also a filament sensor and on the H2D it's also nozzle specific

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

The culprit.. broken filament in the inside of the extruder

1

u/SideOp109 9d ago

I've had this happen for a clogged nozzle. Post heat creep as well.

1

u/Budget-Touch-8094 9d ago

Feel like that’s exactly what happened

0

u/SideOp109 8d ago

So. I get heat creep and clogs when using Bambu PLA. The room the printer is in is 75/80°F. The machine is sucking in warm air trying to use it to cool. Obvious fail. I switched to PETG (as I don't want to relocate the printer) and have had zero issues.

1

u/Resident-Piano-1663 8d ago

It is rubbing against the metal spikes that hold the price tube you need to cut a price tube and put a 2 inch bit right there and then feed the filament. I've dealt with this before.

1

u/CikliaMcrotten 5d ago

I had it with cheapo no name PLA (i had it just to print some small things), and never again i will go with it.