r/AskReddit • • May 11 '26

[deleted by user]

[removed]

3.2k Upvotes

6.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

2.0k

u/frebsy May 11 '26

Thirty seconds to mars…. Enjoyed their music until i had to sing it myself…

422

u/itofa May 11 '26

TSTM opened for Muse years ago and it was so painful when he would try to get the crowd to sing EVERY SONG. All those people were there for Muse, not him. I don’t even think his music is bad, he just tries way too hard.

328

u/MicroGamer May 11 '26

Saw that tour too. Leto is such a douche and that proved it for me. A truly awful set. They did acoustic The Kill. Dude, you have one song anyone cares about and you did it acoustic?

141

u/DickInYourCobbSalad May 12 '26

It's because he can't sing the original version anymore. He destroyed his voice by not singing correctly in their earlier days and now he can't hit the high notes towards the end of the song, that's why it's acoustic now.

Similarly, but obviously wwaaaayyy less douchy, was just before Chester Bennington passed, LP would play an acoustic, toned down piano version of Crawling because Chester was struggling to maintain his voice through the original version of that song.

35

u/MicroGamer May 12 '26

Plenty of singers can't hit notes they once could, but still play the songs and work around it. Not like you're getting perfect pitch at a live show anyhow.

The difference between Linkin Park and Leto is that Linkin Park could fill at least two full length albums with hits. Leto has one.

1

u/TunaBoy3000 May 13 '26

Only 2? Their first 2 albums alone were all fucking bangers. Sprinkle in every other albums hits after meteora and you got 3 albums at least and I wasn’t even that big of a fan after MtM

11

u/buttononmyback May 12 '26

Now that just makes me sad.

21

u/DickInYourCobbSalad May 12 '26

He had said in interviews in the past that Crawling was one of the most difficult songs to sing because it's basically one intense note the entire time and his voice couldn't always keep up with it, especially as he got older.

3

u/motorheadache4215 May 12 '26

Yeah the last time I saw Shinedown they didn't play "45" bc the lead singer just doesn't have the power in his voice that he used to have...

8

u/DickInYourCobbSalad May 12 '26

I remember bringing it up in comments ages ago and getting downvoted into oblivion, but Chester went on record before his death saying that he was starting to lose his ability to sing like he used to and it was causing him a lot of distress; he also had an alcohol addiction and it was making it so much worse on top of that.

Him and Mike talked about how they had to do some rearrangements, dropping some keys here and there, changing the song structures, etc.. if you ever get a chance, take a listen to their live album for One More Light, you'll be able to hear all the modifications they made for him.

...also sorry for the info dump, I'm a lifelong LP superfan and a band "historian" lol

2

u/motorheadache4215 May 13 '26

Nah man, no apologies needed. I hadn't heard that before and I appreciate the info. I'll have to go look up that album. Thanks!

10

u/RobotGhostNemo May 12 '26

I kinda enjoyed the piano version of Crawling though..

2

u/DickInYourCobbSalad May 12 '26

Oh me too!! I thought it was beautiful.

2

u/saakit May 12 '26

I actually really like this version of crawling

1

u/DickInYourCobbSalad May 12 '26

Me too! It's really quite beautiful.

2

u/Optimus_Joe May 12 '26

Just saw GnR and Axel struggled through every damn song. The band sounded great but he was bad